Taxing Long Island
News12 New York
Download the App
Where to Watch
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files
Stony Brook Medicine

Court ruling on vote on creating Village of Edgemont to be blocked by Town of Greenburgh 

A state Court judge has ruled that residents in the Edgemont section of the Town of Greenburgh should be allowed to vote on whether to incorporate as their own village.

Jeremy Hopwood

Mar 9, 2026, 10:22 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A state Court judge has ruled that residents in the Edgemont section of the Town of Greenburgh should be allowed to vote on whether to incorporate as their own village — the latest chapter in a years-long legal battle over the proposal.

Supporters say incorporation would give Edgemont residents more control over how their tax dollars are spent and allow them to make local decisions about zoning, development and services.

“Let people vote,” said Edgemont resident Michael Goldstein, who supports the effort. “What people talk about a lot is just making sure our tax dollars are going to the best possible use and in the most efficient way.”

But Greenburgh Town Supervisor Paul Feiner says the move could have major consequences for the town if Edgemont breaks away.

“It would be devastating,” Feiner said. “We would lose significant revenue, there would be mass layoffs and major cutbacks in services.”

The proposal has been attempted multiple times over the past decade, with previous petitions rejected or tied up in court over legal questions about boundaries and petition requirements.

Feinberg says he plans to appeal the latest ruling.

If the decision stands, a vote on whether to create the Village of Edgemont could take place within about 40 days.

The incorporation issue has also entered local politics. Edgemont resident Barry McGoey, who is challenging Feiner in the Democratic primary for town supervisor this June, says some residents feel they lack representation within the town government.

The legal fight over Edgemont’s future is expected to continue as the town prepares its appeal.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:31
LITN_2026-05-11-13-02-07

Man shot dead by police stabbed his mother over 40 times on Mother's Day

02:10
Screenshot 2026-05-10 163502

Clouds today give way to sunshine tomorrow before more rain returns to Long Island

00:22
51126gasstationfire2_2026-05-11-05-19-35

Fire destroys portions of Garden City Park service station

00:25
Drug Sales MS 051126_2026-05-11-13-05-29

Merrick duo arrested after substances believed to be cocaine, ketamine seized

AP26126594564151

Trump says he'll suspend federal gas tax to help address high fuel prices due to Iran war

00:28
LIArsonArrestKK_2026-05-11-13-26-56

Baldwin man accused of setting fire to several cars

02:12
5112026WCkane_2026-05-11-07-28-59

New Jersey cyclist sues after delivery robot ‘hit-and-run’ leaves him with broken shoulder, head injury

00:36
RTLILIECrashNearExit41VO10pm_2026-05-10-22-09-03

Drivers faced with hours-long traffic jam on Long Island Expressway

00:20
Rape Arrest

Riverhead man charged in Montauk sexual assault case

00:17
0511LIKITTENSAVEDNJ_2026-05-11-06-06-27

Kitten saved from sewer drain in Massapequa

00:18
51126uptowntaco_2026-05-11-05-31-41

Floral Park taco restaurant closes after final weekend service

00:42
LIFatalFireKK_2026-05-10-06-06-28

Two people found dead during blaze at Hempstead house believed to be vacant

00:21
sexual assault arrest police MON copy

Riverhead man accused of sexually assaulting man while he slept inside Montauk home

01:40
li5pmbolmotherdayworker_2026-05-10-17-08-49

Long Island moms put others first on Mother's Day

APKnicksDefeat76rsAdvanceEastFinals

Knicks bury 76ers 144-114 behind Game 4 3-point barrage, back in East finals for 2nd straight year

01:23
Screenshot 2026-05-10 184646

Man armed with knife shot and killed by Southampton Town police in Riverhead 

01:09
li5pmbollivingliver_2026-05-10-17-23-28

Merrick man in need of living donor for rare liver disease

Long Island Rail Road LIRR

LIRR planned schedule adjustments go into effect Monday, a week away from possible strikes

02:01
limtalirrrally12pm_2026-05-09-12-56-19_12-00-34,16

MTA union leaders hold rally week away from possible LIRR strike

00:37
generic

Five hospitalized after exposure to an unknown substance during police investigation

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices