Plea deal revoked for Thomas Costa in death of jogger Karen Benjamin

A judge revoked a plea deal today for a man who pleaded guilty to fatally striking a Mount Sinai mother with his car over the summer and driving off. Thomas Costa expected to be sentenced to 2-6 years

News 12 Staff

Jan 14, 2014, 12:03 AM

Updated 3,833 days ago

Share:


A judge revoked a plea deal today for a man who pleaded guilty to fatally striking a Mount Sinai mother with his car over the summer and driving off.

Thomas Costa expected to be sentenced to 2-6 years behind bars for admitting he fled the scene after running down Karen Benjamin. Benjamin was out jogging back in June when she was struck.

However, when the judge took the bench today, he said he was "extremely upset." He said Costa has "consistently and repeatedly" lied to probation officers, claiming that he did not know he had hit a human being despite his guilty plea.

Costa's attorney said the curve ball in court came as a "total shock."

The victim's family believes that Costa deserves the maximum sentence of seven years, so they say they're glad the case could now go to trial.


More from News 12
1:45
NY AG's Office releases body cam video of fatal police-involved shooting in Bay Shore

NY AG's Office releases body cam video of fatal police-involved shooting in Bay Shore

1:59
STORM WATCH: Warm temps with scattered showers and storms for Saturday before sunny skies on Sunday

STORM WATCH: Warm temps with scattered showers and storms for Saturday before sunny skies on Sunday

2:40
Gilgo Case: Suffolk DA speaks with News 12 ahead of one-year anniversary of Heuermann’s arrest

Gilgo Case: Suffolk DA speaks with News 12 ahead of one-year anniversary of Heuermann’s arrest

2:08
Blueprints of Heuermann home detail where pieces of evidence were found

Blueprints of Heuermann home detail where pieces of evidence were found

1:50
Spokesperson: Bomb threat called into district office of Rep. D'Esposito in Garden City

Spokesperson: Bomb threat called into district office of Rep. D'Esposito in Garden City

2:32
4 Stop & Shops to close on Long Island

4 Stop & Shops to close on Long Island

0:21
Police: Nurse at Nassau University Medical Center punched in the face by patient

Police: Nurse at Nassau University Medical Center punched in the face by patient

2:10
How to spot scams, fake listings on Amazon Prime Day 2024

How to spot scams, fake listings on Amazon Prime Day 2024

0:23
2 Suffolk schools chance mascot names to comply with state ban on Native American mascots

2 Suffolk schools chance mascot names to comply with state ban on Native American mascots

0:29
Bellport man accused of cutting off dog’s ears, leading to its death

Bellport man accused of cutting off dog’s ears, leading to its death

0:35
NY Office of Cannabis Management issues recall for ‘Sky High’ brand marijuana products

NY Office of Cannabis Management issues recall for ‘Sky High’ brand marijuana products

0:26
Gov. Hochul distributes extra resources to Long Island beaches to monitor for sharks

Gov. Hochul distributes extra resources to Long Island beaches to monitor for sharks

2:22
PSEG LI, Island Harvest partner for ‘Power to Feed’ food drive

PSEG LI, Island Harvest partner for ‘Power to Feed’ food drive

0:16
Officials: 3 rescued from boat in Oyster Bay Harbor

Officials: 3 rescued from boat in Oyster Bay Harbor

1:43
Long Island lacrosse stars support veterans with ‘Shootout for Soldiers’

Long Island lacrosse stars support veterans with ‘Shootout for Soldiers’

2:24
Food Truck Friday: Angie’s Empanadas

Food Truck Friday: Angie’s Empanadas

0:14
Man wanted for stealing $1,800 worth of medicine from Medford store

Man wanted for stealing $1,800 worth of medicine from Medford store

1:34
The Real Deal: How to beat inflation with a summer spending plan

The Real Deal: How to beat inflation with a summer spending plan

0:23
Police: Child dies days after being found unconscious in North Haven pool

Police: Child dies days after being found unconscious in North Haven pool

2:12
Best Beaches: We are at Coopers Beach in Southampton

Best Beaches: We are at Coopers Beach in Southampton