Taxing Long Island
News12 New York
Download the App
Where to Watch
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files
Stony Brook Medicine
LIRR Strike

Jury finds Gary Lawrence not guilty in his second murder trial

Gary Lawrence was acquitted of murder in the killing of Hofstra coach Joseph Healy in 1990.

Cecilia Dowd

May 13, 2026, 6:06 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Just minutes after a jury found Gary Lawrence not guilty of murder and attempted robbery, he told reporters, "I just feel relieved that justice has been served after all these years and the truth finally came out. That's all I wanted."

Lawrence was convicted of murder in the killing of Hofstra coach Joseph Healy and served an entire sentence -more than 20 years behind bars - before his conviction was set aside due to evidence that was never handed over.

During his retrial, one of the key pieces of evidence was a confession signed by Lawrence - a confession the defense maintained was coerced.

The defense said Lawrence was not there the night Healy was killed in an Arby's parking lot in Hempstead.

Jurors deliberated for approximately 90 minutes before the foreperson sent a note that they'd reached a verdict.

"In 42 years, I've never had a jury come back this quickly," said defense attorney Ron Kuby.

"We respect the jury's decision," said a spokesperson for District Attorney Anne Donnelly.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:35
Image (3)

Person in custody following series of car crashes, ending near the Americana Manhasset

01:30
Screenshot 2026-05-13 160110

Overnight storms into Thursday ahead of a gorgeous weekend for Long Island

02:11
Strike MS 051326_2026-05-13-18-11-35

Gov. Hochul says LIRR contract talks now focused on wages, not work rules

01:28
LI_5PM_LIRR Presser_ajc_2026-05-13-17-39-34

MTA officials, union continue to differ in contract talks as LIRR strike looms

02:08
Bernagozzi Sentence MS 051326_2026-05-13-17-19-04

Ex-Bay Shore teacher convicted of sexually abusing multiple children; to serve up to 50 years

01:06
LI 5PM WED_Gary Lawrence_ajc_2026-05-13-17-24-06

Jury finds Gary Lawrence not guilty in his second murder trial

00:55
LIIslanderKK_2026-05-13-18-18-51

Islanders' Schaefer helps launch child support center at Northwell Health

00:25
LISSASSAULT513_2026-05-13-05-08-49

Woman assaulted while leaving Nassau County supermarket

00:34
513burglaryli_2026-05-13-12-06-33

North Valley Stream home ransacked while owner enjoys family vacation

01:47
dji mimo 20260513 064410 20260513064410 1778669102597 photo

MTA, union leaders return to the bargaining table today as strike deadline looms on Saturday

iaai.com

Looking for a deal? Nassau DA auctioning off forfeited vehicles

00:16
LIULTATHEFT513_2026-05-13-05-45-09

Woman wanted for stealing nearly $900 worth of merchandise from Ulta

00:22
LIFANELLI513_2026-05-13-05-38-59

Former Nassau Community College president, Hofstra professor dies

00:51
LIBAUERRECORD513_2026-05-13-05-54-30

Trevor Bauer sets Ducks single-game strikeout record

01:44
Butterfly Rescue MS 1008_2025-10-08-17-18-43

How to choose the best pollinator plants for bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds

01:14
513hottoys_2026-05-13-06-04-10

Hot Toys: Perfect toys for travel and long trips

01:50
513whatscooking_2026-05-13-07-27-09

What’s Cooking: Chicken rollatini

01:31
5PMSchwallyDayTwoKK_2026-05-12-17-29-32

Eyewitness in Steven Schwally trial says she's never seen a car go that fast

01:43
li10pmbol2026jeremy_2026-05-12-22-38-40

'He dove through my window like Superman.' Police arrest man following burglaries in Coram

01:40
5PMDaniellaFootageKK_2026-05-12-17-21-09

Proposed law would require Suffolk County businesses to turn over security footage to aid police investigations

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices