Taxing Long Island
News12 New York
Download the App
Where to Watch
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files
Stony Brook Medicine

Police: 3 killed in fiery Bethpage car crash

Detectives say a 2022 Dodge Durango was driving east on Stymus Avenue near Carol Drive when it struck a tree and caught fire around 1 a.m.

Logan Crawford

and

Bob Doda

and

Lauren Pena

May 11, 2025, 8:05 AM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A fiery single-car crash early Sunday morning in Bethpage killed three people inside the vehicle, Nassau police say.

Detectives say a 2022 Dodge Durango was driving east on Stymus Avenue near Carol Drive when it struck a tree and caught fire around 1 a.m.

A neighbor told News 12 that she heard the crash.

"I ran, and all you could see is that car totaled, and it was just destroyed," said Angela Signoriello, of Bethpage.

Nassau police still had Plainview Road closed later in the morning, diverting traffic. It has since reopened.

Neighbors say the area near Plainview Road can be dangerous for drivers and that crashes happen too often.

"It's a blind turn. I've been involved in accidents because of it. Several of the residents have been involved in accidents because of it," said Chris Theo, of Bethpage.

Police have not named the three who were killed. The cause of the crash is under investigation.

Friends of the three victims were the scene Sunday, mourning their loss.

More Stories

Top Stories

02:20
IMG 5110

Proposed law would require Suffolk County businesses to turn over security footage to aid police investigations

02:18
F P1 PM 1(193)

Sunny today with chance of thunderstorms Thursday; warm up for weekend

00:21
trampoline

Woman wanted for harassing child at trampoline park in Suffolk County

00:31
embezzlement arrest

Holtsville man arrested for embezzling over $400K from employer

01:35
li10pmboldaniellalirr_2026-05-11-22-04-39

MTA urges LIRR riders to prepare for possible strike as negotiations continue

01:40
Screenshot 2026-05-11 143123

3 New Yorkers among passengers exposed in MV Hondius hantavirus outbreak, says DOH

00:22
LIHARRISONBOOK512_2026-05-12-05-47-43

Gilgo Beach serial killer investigation detailed in former police commissioner’s new book

00:30
05125AMSCHAEFFERNJ_2026-05-12-05-57-34

Islanders Children's Foundation donates $150K to create child support center for Northwell Health

01:23
LIHotToys512_2026-05-12-06-02-21

Hot Toys: Super Mario toys

00:19
05125amPizzeriaNJ_2026-05-12-05-58-34

New pizzeria comes to Williston Park 

01:40
0512TAXINGLINJ_2026-05-12-05-46-55

Tax experts warn Suffolk homeowners about tax grievance scams ahead of filing deadline

01:42
LITN_2026-05-11-13-02-07

Man shot dead by police stabbed his mother over 40 times on Mother's Day

01:53
5PMCeciliaSchwallyKK_2026-05-11-17-28-52

Trial underway for man accused of driving drunk into a Deer Park nail salon, killing 4, injuring others

00:55
li5pmbol2026arrest_2026-05-11-17-31-28

Arrest made in 2024 Deer Park carjacking that left disabled man dead

01:47
li10pmbol2026gastaxfreeze_2026-05-11-22-09-54

Trump pushes for federal gas tax suspension as Long Islanders seek relief at the pump

00:37
Security MS 051126_2026-05-11-17-20-56

Long Island law enforcement officials view new security technology that can help prevent crime

00:25
Drug Sales MS 051126_2026-05-11-13-05-29

Merrick duo arrested after substances believed to be cocaine, ketamine seized

00:22
51126gasstationfire2_2026-05-11-05-19-35

Fire destroys portions of Garden City Park service station

APSupremeCourtExtensionAbortionPill

Supreme Court temporarily extends women’s access to a widely used abortion pill

00:21
seldentinyhome

Selden home without bedrooms back on the market at slashed price

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices