Judge vacates murder conviction of LI man who spent over 30 years in prison

Keith Bush was convicted in 1976 in the murder and attempted rape of 14-year-old Sherese Watson.

News 12 Staff

May 22, 2019, 3:58 PM

Updated 1,824 days ago

Share:

A judge on Wednesday overturned the conviction of a Long Island man who spent over 30 years in prison for a murder he says he didn't commit.
Keith Bush was accused in the 1975 killing and attempted rape of 14-year-old Sherese Watson. Both attended the same party in North Bellport. Bush was convicted in 1976. Throughout the trial until now, the 62-year-old has maintained his innocence.
On Wednesday, Suffolk County District Attorney Tim Sini pointed out several problems in the case, most notably the existence of a second suspect, a man named John Jones, whose plastic comb was found at the crime scene. That information had been withheld from the jury at trial.
Jones, who had a long criminal history, claimed he had tripped over the dead body while walking home and was never investigated. He died in 2006.
"They covered it up," Sini says.
Sini also asserted that the murder, as it was described by authorities in the 1970s, was forensically impossible. Prosecutors said the victim was stabbed and then strangled, but Sini's investigators found that she was, in fact, strangled first and then stabbed.
In addition to that, a key witness has since recanted her testimony, and Bush says police beat him and coerced him into signing a false confession.
Bush's cleared name comes on the heels of a special Newsday/News 12 investigative report that revealed much of that new information about the case.
Bush said on his way into court Wednesday morning that he never gave up hope, even after all these years, that he would one day be exonerated.
Bush was released on parole in 2007 and had to register as a sex offender. Wednesday's decision means his sex offender status will also be vacated.


More from News 12
1:46
Pizza Strong: Massive fundraiser supports family of slain NYPD Detective Jonathan Diller

Pizza Strong: Massive fundraiser supports family of slain NYPD Detective Jonathan Diller

1:52
Pleasant Monday kicks off workweek warm up on Long Island

Pleasant Monday kicks off workweek warm up on Long Island

1:55
Northwell Health Walk at Jones Beach raises money to support women and children

Northwell Health Walk at Jones Beach raises money to support women and children

0:29
State police: Crash closes section of Southern State Parkway in West Babylon

State police: Crash closes section of Southern State Parkway in West Babylon

0:15
Superintendent: Swastika found on classroom desk at Harborfields High School

Superintendent: Swastika found on classroom desk at Harborfields High School

Guide: School Vote 2024 budgets and tax informaton

Guide: School Vote 2024 budgets and tax informaton

0:39
Police: Man injured in Wyandanch shooting; suspect at large

Police: Man injured in Wyandanch shooting; suspect at large

1:59
Greenlawn teen arrested, accused of making ‘threat of mass harm’ at Oldfield Middle School

Greenlawn teen arrested, accused of making ‘threat of mass harm’ at Oldfield Middle School

1:45
 Missed swim lessons due to COVID-19 may be contributing to rise in child drownings

Missed swim lessons due to COVID-19 may be contributing to rise in child drownings

0:51
Vet Fest in Farmingdale aims to support, encourage veterans who need help

Vet Fest in Farmingdale aims to support, encourage veterans who need help

0:17
Authorities: George Washington Bridge climber in custody

Authorities: George Washington Bridge climber in custody

0:32
Police: 3 people arrested during State Liquor Authority compliance check at Huntington Station deli

Police: 3 people arrested during State Liquor Authority compliance check at Huntington Station deli

2:28
How did a Nassau County doctor overprescribe highly addictive pain pills, despite strict laws in place?

How did a Nassau County doctor overprescribe highly addictive pain pills, despite strict laws in place?

1:43
CDC urges people to get vaccinated amid resurgence of mpox

CDC urges people to get vaccinated amid resurgence of mpox

1:46
Hit-and-run on South Oyster Bay Rd. in Plainview leaves woman with concussion, 6 staples in head

Hit-and-run on South Oyster Bay Rd. in Plainview leaves woman with concussion, 6 staples in head

0:26
Principal: Student approached by van full of men in ski masks in Selden

Principal: Student approached by van full of men in ski masks in Selden

1:39
Montauk Music Festival rocks the East End

Montauk Music Festival rocks the East End

2:06
Homeowners asked to check home security video after string of Nassau County break-ins

Homeowners asked to check home security video after string of Nassau County break-ins

0:24
Police: Hempstead man exposed, touched himself inappropriately at Roosevelt Field Mall

Police: Hempstead man exposed, touched himself inappropriately at Roosevelt Field Mall

1:53
Toys for Tots make contribution to Promise of Hope Foundation to honor fallen Detective Jonathan Diller

Toys for Tots make contribution to Promise of Hope Foundation to honor fallen Detective Jonathan Diller