How can DNA evidence be recovered in Gilgo Beach case 13 years later? A forensic scientist explains

While most DNA degrades over time, mitochondrial DNA can survive the elements simply because there is so much of it, according to Dr. Lawrence Kobilinsky.

Rachel Yonkunas

Jul 21, 2023, 9:35 PM

Updated 368 days ago

Share:

Evidence technicians combed through Rex Heuermann’s Massapequa Park home for the eighth consecutive day on Friday. Investigators are searching for clues, such as DNA, that could lead back to some of the Gilgo Beach victims.
Dr. Lawrence Kobilinsky, forensic scientist and expert in DNA analysis, said analysts are likely focusing on recovering mitochondrial DNA. While most DNA degrades over time, mitochondrial DNA can survive the elements simply because there is so much of it.
“The one chance you have to do a forensic DNA analysis is mitochondrial DNA, so they're looking for hair. Hair is ubiquitous at a crime scene,” explained Dr. Kobilinsky, professor at John Jay College of Criminal Justice. “They may find garments that they can't identify as his wife or his daughter, Heuermann’s. So what they would do is if they find hair on those items, they can do mitochondrial DNA and tell the origin to see if there's a match to one of the victims.”
Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney said they are also looking for blood and trace evidence, in addition to DNA. The specificity and the sensitivity of next generation sequencing can give investigators significant information, even with small amounts of DNA that may be left after decomposition.
WATCH: DOCUMENTARY AND BACKGROUND INFORMATION - Gilgo Beach: Unsolved
However, collecting that evidence is a painstaking process, especially when there is so much to sift through. Police said Heuermann lived in his Massapequa Park home with his wife, two kids, and at least four pets.
“It’s probably the most difficult part of the whole process because if you don't collect properly, you're not going to be able to get any results, even after you analyze whatever you've got,” said Dr. Kobilinsky. “The other thing is you cannot overwhelm a laboratory with thousands and thousands of items.”
Investigators have entered Heuermann’s DNA into a statewide database to see if there are any connections between him and other unsolved cases. If there is a match, Dr. Kobilinsky said it is possible that police would know by now.
Police expect to continue searching Heuermann’s home through the weekend. They have also executed search warrants at his Amityville storage units and his property in South Carolina.

'Even more work to be done.' Police say they have chance to accelerate investigation with suspect behind bars

Detectives had been investigating Heuermann for more than a year prior to his arrest, but they said he was watching them too.
According to court documents, Heuermann searched more than 200 times over a 15-month span for details on the investigation into the murders of four Gilgo Beach victims. Prosecutors said he also repeatedly viewed hundreds of photos of the victims and their families.
Now that they have their suspect behind bars, police have a chance to ramp up their investigation and gather even more evidence.
“There were many things that could not be done because, had they been done, Rex Heuermann would have been tipped off,” said New York State Police Troop Commander Major Steve Udice. “Now that Rex Heuermann has been arrested, there's probably even more work to be done in the way of search warrants, that you're well aware of being executed, and interviews that are going to be conducted of different people, including family members.”
The investigation by the Gilgo Beach task force has focused on four victims, but police recovered seven other bodies in that area in 2010. Suffolk DA Tierney said they will continue to investigate those murders and look for potential connections to Heuermann.


More from News 12
2:40
Pilot, passenger from Virginia identified as victims in MacArthur Airport crash

Pilot, passenger from Virginia identified as victims in MacArthur Airport crash

1:48
Scattered showers possible through Thursday ahead of a sunny weekend

Scattered showers possible through Thursday ahead of a sunny weekend

0:23
Police: Third teen arrested for causing $600K in damage to Shelter Island home

Police: Third teen arrested for causing $600K in damage to Shelter Island home

1:43
Roosevelt man accused of series of crimes that resulted in injuries to 2 Nassau County officers

Roosevelt man accused of series of crimes that resulted in injuries to 2 Nassau County officers

0:36
Police: 2 men arrested for running construction scam targeting older adults in Floral Park

Police: 2 men arrested for running construction scam targeting older adults in Floral Park

1:50
New Mental Health Clinic Opens at NUMC

New Mental Health Clinic Opens at NUMC

0:18
Police: 3 men wanted for stealing $6,000 worth of sunglasses in Lake Grove

Police: 3 men wanted for stealing $6,000 worth of sunglasses in Lake Grove

0:20
Big Lots to close stores nationwide, including 2 locations on Long Island

Big Lots to close stores nationwide, including 2 locations on Long Island

0:16
Riverhead police chief announces departure from department

Riverhead police chief announces departure from department

1:48
Made on Long Island: Long Island Meal Prep in West Hempstead

Made on Long Island: Long Island Meal Prep in West Hempstead

0:43
Toys for Tots Foundation helps campers celebrate Christmas in July

Toys for Tots Foundation helps campers celebrate Christmas in July

0:42
Long Island Ducks to host first ever Chicken Nugget Championship on Friday

Long Island Ducks to host first ever Chicken Nugget Championship on Friday

1:49
Democratic delegates from LI give support to VP Harris to be presidential nominee

Democratic delegates from LI give support to VP Harris to be presidential nominee

AP survey: Harris has enough delegate support to become the Democratic Party nominee

AP survey: Harris has enough delegate support to become the Democratic Party nominee

0:29
Founder of Island Harvest Linda Breitstone dies at age 73

Founder of Island Harvest Linda Breitstone dies at age 73

0:34
Town of Hempstead Councilman Chris Carini laid to rest in Farmingdale

Town of Hempstead Councilman Chris Carini laid to rest in Farmingdale

0:37
Annual LI golf outing raises funds for those struggling with mental health, substance abuse

Annual LI golf outing raises funds for those struggling with mental health, substance abuse

1:32
Surf session held for adults and kids with disabilities

Surf session held for adults and kids with disabilities

0:17
Police: Valley Stream man slashed woman with knife at deli

Police: Valley Stream man slashed woman with knife at deli

1:43
Long Islanders have mixed reaction to President Biden’s announcement on presidential run

Long Islanders have mixed reaction to President Biden’s announcement on presidential run