Taxing Long Island
News12 New York
Download the App
Where to Watch
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files
Stony Brook Medicine

Gilgo investigation moves to next stage as investigators retrieve potential evidence from suspect's home

Attorney Fred Klein is not involved directly in the case. But he says investigators will now have to search each item they took out and possibly do forensic testing on it.

Joe Arena

Jul 25, 2023, 10:37 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Police say they have a massive amount of potential evidence to go through following a 12-day search at the suspected Gilgo Beach serial killer's home.

The crime scene at Rex Heuermann's Massapequa Park house closed Tuesday afternoon.

LIVE BLOG: Gilgo Beach Murders

Attorney Fred Klein is not involved directly in the case. But he says investigators will now have to search each item they took out and possibly do forensic testing on it.

He says the items that could be the most beneficial are anything that could provide a DNA sample or belongings from the victims.

"Clothes, jewelry, identification cards, preferably with their photographs on them - serial killers are known to keep these items helps them relive the pleasure of the killing," Klein says.

MORE: Suffolk DA: Search of accused Gilgo Beach serial killer's home ends, massive amount of material taken


Canines assisted in the investigation at Heuermann's home and they could possibly be used again, according to Mike Gould, former lieutenant and commanding officer of the police K-9 Unit.

Gould says dogs could be seen at other locations across Long Island like Gilgo Beach as the investigation continues.

MORE: Court documents: Police pursue DVDs, cameras as potential evidence in Gilgo investigation


"There come to a point of diminishing returns," Gould says. "Everything degrades so in 100 years from now there is not gonna be any odor so there's a fine point when a dog can actually detect an odor.”

WATCH: DOCUMENTARY AND BACKGROUND INFORMATION - Gilgo Beach: Unsolved

Klein says digging is not routine even in a homicide investigation so he believes there was some additional evidence that gave them probable cause to look into the backyard of the home.

MORE: Was Rex Heuermann an imminent threat to public safety in days before his arrest?


More Stories

Top Stories

02:06
LIHousefireupdated_2026-05-03-08-20-35

House fire in Commack consumes house and two cars

02:04
CX Headlines 4.png LI (1)

Cool and breezy overnight; warmer temperatures ahead and possible midweek rain for Long Island

00:53
RUDY GIULIANI GENERIC

Rudy Giuliani hospitalized in critical condition

00:39
53LIbrushfire_2026-05-03-22-05-13

Brush fire spreads through Morewood Park in Smithtown

00:21
li5pmbol2026dwisubaru_2026-05-03-18-08-39

West Babylon man arrested for DWI after he allegedly crashed into fence, police say

00:49
li5pmlimarathontom_2026-05-03-17-13-53

Racers cross finish line at Long Island Marathon with smiles

00:36
assault arrest

Man accused of striking person with wine bottle at East Hampton pizzeria

10:54
LIPOWERANDPOLITICSA_2026-05-03-17-50-48

Power & Politics: Hofstra Exec. Dean of Suburban Studies, Real Estate Broker discuss Levittown growing pains; Billions of dollars missing from school funding

00:28
53parkwaycrashupdate_2026-05-03-20-08-04

8 injured in Northern State Parkway crash

NJ United Airlines

Unruly passenger detained after altercation on United flight at Newark Airport

01:51
li5pmbolstabbings_2026-05-02-14-36-43

Police identify suspect accused of fatal Island Park, Valley Stream stabbings

00:58
li12pmbolstepsbrookville_2026-05-03-12-09-26

Families across Nassau come together for first 'Steps Toward Tomorrow' Walk 

00:35
RTLISouthernStateDWIVO10pm_2026-05-02-22-14-00

Pickup truck overturns on Southern State Parkway following 3-vehicle crash; driver arrested for DWI

01:48
Wren Folo MS 043026_2026-04-30-17-11-17

Bankruptcy filing reveals long list of creditors owed money by Wren Kitchens

2b8aab6d-4c68-4fd6-a9ef-2956748d78e1

Jake’s 58 Casino reopens after delayed opening on Kentucky Derby

02:09
spirit airlines

Airlines step in to help Spirit passengers amid travel disruptions

00:40
li5pmboltobaycarshow_2026-05-02-17-30-25

1,000 classic cars participate in Long Island's largest car show

00:32
RTLILifeAngelsTournamentVO10pm_2026-05-02-22-14-55

Poker tournament held in Woodbury to support people facing financial struggles

00:27
52bethpagecrash_2026-05-02-06-08-49

Teen bicyclist struck by car

00:51
LIPOKEMONTARGET050212P_2026-05-02-12-21-44

Westbury Target store hosts Pokémon fan experience

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices