Bay Shore teen charged with murder in brother's stabbing death

<p>A Bay Shore teen accused of fatally stabbing his younger brother was arraigned for second degree murder Saturday.</p>

News 12 Staff

Aug 25, 2018, 10:10 AM

Updated 2,148 days ago

Share:

A Bay Shore teen accused of fatally stabbing his younger brother was arraigned Saturday on a charge of second-degree murder.
Police say Robert Rivera, 19, stabbed his 17-year-old brother Brian Castillo in the neck while Castillo was playing video games. It happened just after 7 p.m. Saturday in a bedroom of a home on North Thompson Street.
Officials say the victim ran out of the house, saw his father outside, and said, “Look what Robert did to me." The assistant district attorney says Castillo then collapsed on the lawn and died.
Prosecutors say after Rivera took off on foot after the stabbing. He was found by police about 20 minutes later, and was arrested.
Prosecutors say Rivera admitted to stabbing his brother and gave a full, videotaped confession.
But Rivera's lawyer denies the charges and asked the court to give Rivera a psychiatric evaluation.
There is no word yet on a possible motive, but on his way to court Rivera told News 12 his brother threatened him.
Rivera is expected to be back in court Aug. 30, once the results of his psychiatric evaluation come back.


More from News 12
2:16
STORM WATCH: Warm temps with scattered showers and storms through Saturday

STORM WATCH: Warm temps with scattered showers and storms through Saturday

2:25
PSEG Long Island holding 'Power to Feed' food drive in South Setauket

PSEG Long Island holding 'Power to Feed' food drive in South Setauket

0:14
Man wanted for stealing $1,800 worth of medicine from Medford store

Man wanted for stealing $1,800 worth of medicine from Medford store

2:24
Food Truck Friday: Angie’s Empanadas

Food Truck Friday: Angie’s Empanadas

1:34
The Real Deal: How to beat inflation with a summer spending plan

The Real Deal: How to beat inflation with a summer spending plan

0:32
Police: Former Hempstead church leader arrested for sexual abusing, raping girl

Police: Former Hempstead church leader arrested for sexual abusing, raping girl

1:56
Benefit concert held to expand memorial for those who died from 9/11-related illnesses

Benefit concert held to expand memorial for those who died from 9/11-related illnesses

0:14
Whole Foods store opening at Huntington shopping center next Wednesday

Whole Foods store opening at Huntington shopping center next Wednesday

0:24
Police: 16-year-old saved 2 teen swimmers in distress near Point Lookout Town Beach

Police: 16-year-old saved 2 teen swimmers in distress near Point Lookout Town Beach

0:50
Shootout For Soldiers fundraiser in Massapequa Park hopes to raise $185,000 for veteran organizations

Shootout For Soldiers fundraiser in Massapequa Park hopes to raise $185,000 for veteran organizations

2:13
Neighbors of suspected Gilgo Beach killer say quiet block has grown crowded since arrest

Neighbors of suspected Gilgo Beach killer say quiet block has grown crowded since arrest

2:06
Coram man sentenced to 25 years to life for trying to kill Suffolk police officer

Coram man sentenced to 25 years to life for trying to kill Suffolk police officer

0:23
Police: Child dies days after being found unconscious in North Haven pool

Police: Child dies days after being found unconscious in North Haven pool

1:41
Wedding dress giveaway held for military brides and first responders

Wedding dress giveaway held for military brides and first responders

0:29
Lindenhurst man indicted on child porn charges

Lindenhurst man indicted on child porn charges

0:26
Elmont man to serve 25 years to life in prison after admitting to fatally strangling woman

Elmont man to serve 25 years to life in prison after admitting to fatally strangling woman

1:43
New York Marine Rescue Center releases seal pup at Tiana Beach in Hampton Bays

New York Marine Rescue Center releases seal pup at Tiana Beach in Hampton Bays

0:46
Red tail hawk crashes into News 12 studio building in Bethpage

Red tail hawk crashes into News 12 studio building in Bethpage

2:12
Best Beaches: We are at Coopers Beach in Southampton

Best Beaches: We are at Coopers Beach in Southampton

0:30
Police: Hicksville man arrested for striking man with knife over parking dispute in Franklin Square

Police: Hicksville man arrested for striking man with knife over parking dispute in Franklin Square