News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Taxing Long Island
Stony Brook Medicine
Celebrating America's 250th

Greenlawn family's dream vacation turns into nightmare after booking rental home

Jacqueline Shumack and her husband, Gareth, along with four other families, spent over $6,000 for what was supposed to be a luxurious New Year’s getaway.

Kevin Vesey

Feb 24, 2025, 10:22 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A Greenlawn family’s dream vacation turned into a nightmare when their booked rental home in Pennsylvania’s Pocono Mountains left them with a shattered holiday and no help from the platform that handled their booking.

Jacqueline Shumack and her husband, Gareth, along with four other families, spent over $6,000 for what was supposed to be a luxurious New Year’s getaway. They booked the property through VRBO, an online vacation rental service, confident they had found the perfect spot for their retreat.

However, when they arrived, they were horrified by the condition of the home.

Instead of the luxury mansion shown in online photos, the group found a property with moldy mini-fridges, as well as exposed wiring and gas lines, making it unsafe to stay.

“We get to the property and it is, we’re like in shock,” said Jacqueline.

“I'm a father of three, and I didn’t feel safe having my kids in that space at all," says Gareth.

With safety concerns mounting, the family immediately left the property, forcing them to find alternative accommodations.

The family turned to VRBO for help, but the response was not what they expected.

The platform sent them an email describing the home’s condition as having a “minor issue,” suggesting they contact the property owner directly to discuss a refund.

The Shumacks did just that, but the property owner refused to provide compensation.

"I don’t want anyone to go through this, and I’d really like my $6,000 back," Jacqueline Shumack expressed.

VRBO responded with a statement, assuring that an investigation into the case is ongoing.

A spokesperson emphasized the company’s commitment to the safety and well-being of travelers, saying, “Vrbo has a full-time Trust & Safety team that reviews cases when health and safety concerns are reported."

Despite this, the family has yet to receive a refund.

They are now hoping their credit card company can reverse the charge and help them recover their lost funds.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:44
li10pmnorthmassapequajeremy_2026-06-29-22-09-37

Nassau police investigate family disturbance that injured 1 in North Massapequa

02:18
A Heat(3)

HEAT ALERT: Dangerous heat builds this week along with a few thunderstorm chances

01:43
li10pmboldaniellaheat_2026-06-29-22-05-29

'Heat waves are the leading cause of weather-related deaths,’ Long Island doctor warns

01:58
Choking Death MS 062926_2026-06-29-17-05-55

Merrick mother charged in toddler’s death

mfcu-2026-06-29-2 original

Hewlett man accused of defrauding $2.5M from Medicaid to buy Bentley, Range Rover and mansion

01:30
li5pmbolheatmelanie_2026-06-29-17-14-35

Long Island leaders, doctors warn of dangerous heat coming this way

01:51
li5pmbolbullyingmassapequa_2026-06-29-17-09-31

Students and parents speak out about bullying at Massapequa

01:07
APJFK

JetBlue pilot reports hitting drone as plane approached JFK airport to land

00:25
LI5PMSSPAxUpdateKK_2026-06-29-17-10-04

Police searching for driver who fled crash that killed 4-year-old on Southern State Parkway

01:31
dji mimo 20260629 051038 20260629051037 1782724928954 photo (1)

Teen stabbed to death outside apartment building in Hempstead; suspect on the run

00:47
BayportCarCrash629_2026-06-29-12-33-46

25-year-old man charged with DWAI after crash in Bayport

00:51
IslandiaEquestrian629_2026-06-29-12-43-05

Northwell Health and Pal-O-Mine Equestrian team up to host a day of wellness for cancer survivors

00:22
6AM LONG ISLAND MANUAL RECORD06292026_2026-06-29-06-11-43

Man found dead after fatal crash on Robert Moses Causeway

00:17
4a964378-1afe-4c8e-8bcc-00371d73c81c

Possible hand grenade found in East Setauket garden

02:02
RTLIValleyStreamKidUberedToJFKJRGaertner10pm_2026-06-28-23-09-23

'I didn't know where my son was.' 11-year-old boy with autism takes Uber to JFK Airport without parents knowing

00:16
PatchogueCarFire629_2026-06-29-07-11-01

Car burst into flames in Patchogue

01:53
MOLIBEHRSBOUT62926_2026-06-29-05-57-12

Made on Long Island: Behr's Boutique in Syosset

01:47
LICOSTOFJULY62926_2026-06-29-05-34-22

The Cost Of: July 4th barbecue

00:49
RTLIRepublicAirportDogRecuesVOSOTVO10pm_2026-06-28-23-10-07

Meet Jalen, Bridges, OG, Hart and KAT: Rescue puppies named after NY Knicks NBA Finals champions

01:54
RTLIMedfordSchoolCulinaryGardenKRobledo10pm_2026-06-28-23-10-38

From garden beds to classrooms: Medford elementary school expands farm-based learning

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices