News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Taxing Long Island
Clear
71°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Taxing Long Island

Trial underway for former Bay Shore teacher accused of sexually abusing students

A jury heard opening statements in the trial of Thomas Bernagozzi, the former Bay Shore teacher accused of sexually abusing students.

Cecilia Dowd

Jan 20, 2026, 5:33 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

The trial for a former Bay Shore teacher accused of sexually abusing students got underway on Tuesday.

Thomas Bernagozzi is criminally charged in connection with the alleged sexual abuse of two children.

Prosecutors said the abuse started when the victims were 4 and 8 years of age. He is also accused of possessing inappropriate negatives of a third child at his home.

Prosecutor MacDonald Drane told jurors that Bernagozzi saw an opportunity to take advantage of young boys for his own sexual gratification.

Drane said Bernagozzi was “the cool teacher” and the teacher all the kids wanted.

Bernagozzi allegedly took the boys to the beach, a local pool, sports games and "showered them with gifts."

Drane said the defendant was “revered” and took advantage of that status to build a relationship with the two purported victims and their parents.

Drane described the defendant’s alleged “ruse” of tricking the victims into thinking that was happening was normal. He said there are no “innocent explanations” for his actions.

Defense attorney Steven Politi said his client vehemently denies the charges “with every fiber of his being.”

Politi told jurors that Bernagozzi “was targeted by these men for the singular purpose of making money,” a reference toward legal action against the Bay Shore School District.

Prosecutors have said in the past that there are "scores" of children who were victims of Bernagozzi, but said he was not charged in connection with them because the alleged abuse did not fall within the statute of limitations.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:57
TrumpVisit813_2026-08-13-18-15-21_18-06-58,14

Security tightens ahead of President Trump rally at Nassau Police Academy

01:51
F P1 PM 1

Partly cloudy overnight ahead of a nice end to the week on Long Island

01:45
SouthamptonPermit813_2026-08-13-18-08-05

Southampton Village reverses year-round beach parking permit proposal

00:31
dc9dee1c-d28d-4a52-810a-c1f18b7e1979

Glen Cove police ID two people they say interfered with traffic stops on illegal e-bikes

01:40
LI 10PM THUR_Sayville Film_ajc_2026-08-13-22-20-51

Sayville International Film Festival debuts on Long Island

00:43
LI 5PM THUR_Pawdorf Folo_ajc_2026-08-13-18-10-26

Wantagh pet boarding facility under investigation following dog’s death

00:29
5PMCreekRescueKK_2026-08-13-17-27-52

Man airlifted from woods after getting lost looking for model airplane

01:38
LI 5PM THURS_Safety Push Alert_ajc_2026-08-13-17-15-27

Suffolk County leaders push safe driving in road work zones after fatal Nesconset crash

00:29
LIGuiltyKK_2026-08-13-18-46-52_18-15-01,09

Suffolk contractor pleads guilty to attempted grand larceny for stealing over $90K from customers

00:26
813hicksvillelarceny_subclip_2026-08-13-12-39-39

Hicksville man charged with grand larceny after stealing $9.5K, promising debt relief

00:30
hit and run arrest

Truck driver arrested for hitting mom and toddler, leaving the scene

00:17
LIExpresswayOverturnKK_2026-08-13-12-29-24

Car overturns on Seaford-Oyster Bay Expressway

00:21
LIRalphsTheft_2026-08-13-18-40-29

Brooklyn woman accused of stealing nearly $12K from Melville Ralph’s owner

00:26
OMAS PRIDE 1

Pet food brand recalls more than 600 bags of raw dog food over salmonella risk

MANGIONETOPLEADGUILTY

Luigi Mangione expected to plead guilty in federal case in UnitedHealthcare killing, AP source says

00:27
LIDWIPLEA813_2026-08-13-05-18-21

Man pleads guilty to high-speed fatal DWI crash in Freeport

OREO Twist, Lick, Vote Horizontal

Oreo is launching a chicken and waffles cookie; fans to decide if it comes back

00:37
aacb4e8c-71fc-4786-8be5-cc9343cbeadd

Crews repair water main break that caused large Smithtown sinkhole

Domino-Group-Shot

Domino’s launches new Detroit-style pizza shaped like its logo

00:17
BIRD AND BAO

Popular Patchogue Asian-fusion restaurant closing

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices