News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Vote 2026: Long Island elections
Clear
45°
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Vote 2026: Long Island elections

Seaford church hopes to get stolen items back after Deer Park man arrested

James Vollaro, 58, was arrested on Wednesday after removing the items from Maria Regina Church, according to the Nassau County Police Department.

Mike Smollins

•

Oct 9, 2026, 10:14 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A Seaford church remains without some of its religious items after a Deer Park man allegedly stole sacramentals from the building.

James Vollaro, 58, was arrested on Wednesday after removing the items from Maria Regina Church, according to the Nassau County Police Department.

The Rev. Jason Grisafi said the stolen items included an altar cross, other crosses and statues, some of which have more than physical value.

"These have a type of religious value to them that goes beyond just a material value," Grisafi said.

Grisafi said the items were used for prayer services and private devotions and that many parishioners pray with them and see it as way of connecting to them spiritually. He said the altar cross meant a great deal to him because he got it while on a Pilgrimage to Jerusalem.

Police said Vollaro was located at his home and arrested after the incident. He was charged with grand larceny and will return to First District Court in Hempstead on Oct. 21.

Grisafi said he was grateful to parishioners for reporting the stolen items. He added that they have not been recovered, but he remains hopeful.

"For those other items that were part of those shrine areas, there's really not much to do to replace them," Grisafi said. "They're kind of irreplaceable. If they're found, great, we'll put them back. If not, new people with new prayers will bring things forward."

Top Stories

01:40
li5pmboljennaparties_2026-10-31-17-04-10

Nassau police bust multiple Halloween house parties with underage drinking

01:20
p3

Cool, crisp and dry conditions continue on Long Island heading into November

02:08
li5pmbol2026soceerjeremy_2026-10-31-17-16-10

One day after father's death, Farmingdale soccer player lifts team to county finals

Vote 2026

Voter Guide 2026: Long Island election voting guide

AP26295681390773

Survey reveals New York's favorite Halloween candy

00:35
li12pmbolhicksville_2026-10-31-13-02-27

Nassau police search for suspect in Hicksville gas station burglary, $1,500 cigarette theft

01:30
li5pmbolhalloweenstory_2026-10-30-18-32-41

Long Island officials urge safety on Halloween night

Paleoart 2511

Stony Brook-led team discovers first known fruit-eating dinosaur nicknamed 'Hell Chicken'

00:49
abuseddograllyCM_2026-10-30-22-10-25

Sound Beach dog recovering after severe neglect in animal cruelty case

00:37
LImassapequalewdness_2026-10-31-06-11-14

Police searching for suspect accused of exposing himself to 3 teenage girls in Massapequa Park

00:27
ROBBERY ARREST copy

16-year-old arrested after police say she robbed teen of bag, sprayed substance in face

01:17
LI 10PM FRI_Sayville Haunt_ajc_2026-10-30-22-13-00

Sayville couple transforms home into haunted carnival for a cause

01:28
LI 10PM FRI_Supermarket Open_ajc_2026-10-30-22-21-02

New supermarket opens in downtown Hempstead, bringing fresh food access to residents

00:26
Screenshot 2026-10-30 170025

Brooklyn man charged in Central Islip arson that killed family pets

01:23
bd8ba7f6-ea90-491a-9412-d01d5f91c4f3

The moon, Jupiter and Mars share the early November morning sky

00:38
li5pmboldaylights_2026-10-30-17-45-19

Daylight saving time ends this Sunday

02:08
Scholar Athlete Digital Banner 2023 600x340

Scholar Athlete: Sean Grossman, Port Jefferson HS

01:52
cf22dff0-fea9-4bdb-97b9-ca46a637115f

State police stepping up Halloween patrols of Nissequogue River State Park

02:50
Screenshot 2026-10-30 173607

Turn to Tara investigation sparks new NY law to fight human trafficking

01:37
LI 5PM FRI_Phantom Pharmacy_ajc_2026-10-30-17-15-09

Long Island 'phantom pharmacies' tied to alleged $8 million fraud scheme, investigators say

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices