Neighbors say homeowner’s son was at condemned Plainview house that burned down almost every day

Neighbors say the house, which was condemned due to a previous fire, should have had a fence around it to keep people off the property

News 12 Staff

Oct 20, 2021, 2:30 AM

Updated 914 days ago

Share:

A Plainview house fire that left several people homeless could have easily been prevented, neighbors say.
They say the house, which was condemned due to a previous fire, should have had a fence around it to keep people off the property.
Instead, neighbors say the homeowner’s adult son, Vito Punzi, was constantly inside the house that burned down.
Punzi told News 12 Monday that he was inside his mother’s condemned home, cooking with a propane stove before the house burned to the ground at around 4:30 a.m. Saturday.
News 12 tracked Punzi at a house in Levittown. He said he lived in “both places” when asked if he was living at the house in Plainview.
Punzi said “I can’t answer you” when he was asked if he was living at the Plainview house part time.
The home that burned down on Audrey Avenue had been deemed unlivable and was scheduled to be torn down following a separate fire in January 2020 that killed Punzi’s sister.
Neighbors say Punzi continued to show up at the house almost every day.
“You would say to yourself, how is he going in and out of the house,” says Justin Bolobanic. “How is this allowed? There should have been a perimeter set up around for not being able to enter.”
According to the Town of Oyster Bay, every legal effort was made to seal off the home.
A spokesperson for the town wrote: “This is private property. Following the initial fire, the house was secured in the typical fashion of boarding and securing it from those trying to enter. It is incumbent upon the homeowner to keep it secured as they still maintain ownership of the property.”
The town says the pandemic had caused district courts to close. That’s why the demolition was pushed back.


More from News 12
0:43
Police: Illegal guns found inside Old Bethpage home; couple charged with criminal weapons possession

Police: Illegal guns found inside Old Bethpage home; couple charged with criminal weapons possession

1:52
Sunny and mild Monday for Long Island

Sunny and mild Monday for Long Island

0:24
Prosecutors: Bellport man pleads guilty to hit-and-run that seriously injured pedestrian

Prosecutors: Bellport man pleads guilty to hit-and-run that seriously injured pedestrian

1:08
Oldest Men’s Senior Baseball League player honors surgeon who saved his career

Oldest Men’s Senior Baseball League player honors surgeon who saved his career

1:17
Annual ‘Spring Dust Off’ car show to take place in Point Lookout

Annual ‘Spring Dust Off’ car show to take place in Point Lookout

1:56
Authorities: Nassau County police officer attacked by 2 men, pit bull in East Rockaway

Authorities: Nassau County police officer attacked by 2 men, pit bull in East Rockaway

0:36
Southampton police: Man arrested in Riverside machete attack that injured 24-year-old

Southampton police: Man arrested in Riverside machete attack that injured 24-year-old

1:10
Lawmakers in Albany pass $237 billion state budget, restore school funding

Lawmakers in Albany pass $237 billion state budget, restore school funding

0:28
Man who set himself on fire outside Trump trial dies of injuries, police say

Man who set himself on fire outside Trump trial dies of injuries, police say

Knicks beat 76ers 111-104 in Game 1 of playoffs. Brunson and Hart score 22 points and backups star

Knicks beat 76ers 111-104 in Game 1 of playoffs. Brunson and Hart score 22 points and backups star

Andersen, Noesen help Hurricanes push past Islanders 3-1 to open 1st-round NHL playoff series

Andersen, Noesen help Hurricanes push past Islanders 3-1 to open 1st-round NHL playoff series

0:42
'A Dream Prom Boutique' ensures Nassau high schoolers have prom of their dreams

'A Dream Prom Boutique' ensures Nassau high schoolers have prom of their dreams

0:43
Huntington’s Blue Line Deli & Bagels gives away free bagels to customers ahead of Islanders postseason

Huntington’s Blue Line Deli & Bagels gives away free bagels to customers ahead of Islanders postseason

0:18
Car crashes into back of oil truck in Long Beach

Car crashes into back of oil truck in Long Beach

0:19
Authorities: RV catches fire at park in Shirley

Authorities: RV catches fire at park in Shirley

0:28
Police: Levittown woman arrested for driving drunk with 2 children in vehicle

Police: Levittown woman arrested for driving drunk with 2 children in vehicle

1:13
CDC: Children ER visits increased last 3 years for accidental Melatonin ingestion

CDC: Children ER visits increased last 3 years for accidental Melatonin ingestion

2:05
Long Island native ID’d as person who set himself on fire outside Trump trial in Manhattan

Long Island native ID’d as person who set himself on fire outside Trump trial in Manhattan

0:37
Officials: Wildlife rehabilitator took raccoons into her Merrick home without required rabies license

Officials: Wildlife rehabilitator took raccoons into her Merrick home without required rabies license

1:42
FBI on alert as Jewish Long Islanders prepare to celebrate Passover

FBI on alert as Jewish Long Islanders prepare to celebrate Passover