Condemned Plainview home goes up in flames hours before it was expected to be torn down

The fire ultimately destroyed two homes and severely damaged a third, and officials say this was the second fire at the location in less than two years.

News 12 Staff

Oct 19, 2021, 10:21 AM

Updated 911 days ago

Share:

A fire in Plainview ripped through a home that was scheduled to be torn down just hours later.
The fire ultimately destroyed two homes and severely damaged a third, and officials say this was the second fire at the location in less than two years.
A fire at the same house in January 2020 killed a 65-year-old woman whose mother owns the property. The house was later condemned and remained in disrepair, according to a petition filled by the Town of Oyster Bay in June, seeking to have it demolished.
The town wrote that the house was in “dangerous condition” and posed a “threat to the general public.”
A settlement was later reached allowing the owner to have the house torn down herself.
The house was set to be taken down at 10 a.m. Saturday but the fire broke out at around 4:30 a.m. on the same day.
Nassau Chief Fire Marshal Michael Uttaro says the circumstances surrounding the fire are strange, especially since utilities were turned off.
However, he would not say if the fire was suspicious. He says an investigation is still ongoing.
Neighbors are suspicious of the owner’s son, who they say was always in the condemned property.
The son, Vito, told News 12 over the phone that he was using a propane stove inside the home on the evening before the fire.
“I had it on because I was making eggs because I got hungry,” Vito says. “I go to the backyard, and I saw light, then I saw it was on fire. I didn’t go back inside the house, and I called the fire department.”
Uttaro says Vito is being interviewed by investigators.


More from News 12
2:00
Police: Man’s wallet blocks bullet during Coram shooting; suspect wanted

Police: Man’s wallet blocks bullet during Coram shooting; suspect wanted

1:31
Cloudy skies, breezy conditions and rain on Long Island

Cloudy skies, breezy conditions and rain on Long Island

0:44
NuHealth holds breast cancer screenings at Plainview-Old Bethpage Library

NuHealth holds breast cancer screenings at Plainview-Old Bethpage Library

0:49
Suffolk Sheriff’s Office holds 1st wellness conference at Suffolk Community College

Suffolk Sheriff’s Office holds 1st wellness conference at Suffolk Community College

0:13
Police probe shooting incident at Patchogue home

Police probe shooting incident at Patchogue home

1:55
Police: Drunk driver hits patrol car at scene of DWI crash; Suffolk officer hurt

Police: Drunk driver hits patrol car at scene of DWI crash; Suffolk officer hurt

0:23
West Islip man sentenced to 8 1/3 to 25 years for stealing millions from Williston Park school

West Islip man sentenced to 8 1/3 to 25 years for stealing millions from Williston Park school

0:25
Police: Man threw cellphone, injured officer responding to disturbance on road in Valley Stream

Police: Man threw cellphone, injured officer responding to disturbance on road in Valley Stream

0:19
Police: Suspect wanted for shooting at car in Riverhead

Police: Suspect wanted for shooting at car in Riverhead

1:09
The East End: Hamptons Handpoured

The East End: Hamptons Handpoured

2:06
Dozens of layoffs could be coming to Hicksville School District

Dozens of layoffs could be coming to Hicksville School District

1:45
Great Neck Plaza residents concerned about residential complex proposal

Great Neck Plaza residents concerned about residential complex proposal

1:52
Find fun, interactive activities for family and friends at Main Street Board Game Café in Huntington

Find fun, interactive activities for family and friends at Main Street Board Game Café in Huntington

1:40
Hungry students left with few options as eateries at Nassau Community College suddenly shut down

Hungry students left with few options as eateries at Nassau Community College suddenly shut down

2:08
Alleged Gilgo Beach serial killer appears in court; judge works to set trial date

Alleged Gilgo Beach serial killer appears in court; judge works to set trial date

0:37
North Babylon HS gives away dresses, suits ahead of prom season

North Babylon HS gives away dresses, suits ahead of prom season

0:22
Central Islip man sentenced to 22 years in prison for raping daughter

Central Islip man sentenced to 22 years in prison for raping daughter

1:45
Long Island pizzerias come together to raise funds for family of slain detective

Long Island pizzerias come together to raise funds for family of slain detective

0:30
Hempstead man pleads guilty, gets 8 years for drug trafficking

Hempstead man pleads guilty, gets 8 years for drug trafficking

0:19
Nassau Legislature approves 2 new outdoor fields for Mitchel Athletic Complex

Nassau Legislature approves 2 new outdoor fields for Mitchel Athletic Complex