Lawsuit: Mattituck father alleges son was abused at Smithtown group home

A Suffolk County father is suing a local group home, alleging that his teen son with autism was abused.

News 12 Staff

Aug 3, 2021, 9:44 PM

Updated 986 days ago

Share:

A Suffolk County father is suing a local group home, alleging that his teen son with autism was abused.
Michael Schuch, of Mattituck, says his 19-year-old son Michael Jr. has autism, is nonverbal and requires 24-hour care.
The teen lives at the Developmental Disabilities Institute in Smithtown.
Schuch says he went to visit his then-17-year-old son for lunch at DDI last year and saw that Michael Jr. had cuts and scratches all over his arms.
"It was getting to me, irking me. He's nonverbal as you can tell, he can't say anything but ‘Let's go Mets,' and 'I want a grilled cheese,’” says Schuch.
The father says he filed a complaint with the group home and received a response six months later. Schuch tells News 12 the institute told him they found security camera footage of several staff members and his son.
“One staff member was pouring water over his head as water torture to make him stop doing things like asking for food, basically for behavior modification,” says Schuch. "Sometimes I'll go to bed and literally almost to tears thinking about my boy."
Schuch says soon after this, DDI stopped answering his questions, which prompted him to hire a lawyer to sue the institute and find out who allegedly mistreated his son.
Schuch’s lawyer Brad Gerstman says, "Apparently the person who put the scratches into Michael Jr. is not the same person who waterboarded Michael Jr. So now you have two individuals in the home, of which we don't know who they are.”
The CEO of DDI declined to go on camera, but issued a statement responding to the allegations against the institute, saying in part, "We are pleased that the Schuch family continues to entrust the care of their son to DDI… DDI has been transparent and cooperative to ensure any claim is fully investigated and appropriately addressed."
Schuch says his son is still living at DDI while he searches for a new home to help him.
The Mattituck man hopes his lawsuit will shine a light on any more possible cases of mistreatment at the group home. His lawyers say they've also contacted the police.


More from News 12
1:56
Police: Student, 17, charged with multiple felonies for bringing unloaded gun and bullets to school

Police: Student, 17, charged with multiple felonies for bringing unloaded gun and bullets to school

2:29
Mostly sunny with highs near 70 for Tuesday; chance for rain by midweek

Mostly sunny with highs near 70 for Tuesday; chance for rain by midweek

2:23
State budget makes no change to foundation school aid; governor signals changes coming in 2026

State budget makes no change to foundation school aid; governor signals changes coming in 2026

1:43
Police: Several people hurt in Garden City bus crash

Police: Several people hurt in Garden City bus crash

1:32
Nassau Community College professors call on state to step in to help school survive

Nassau Community College professors call on state to step in to help school survive

0:58
Police: Man spray-painted antisemitic messages at homes, Jewish center in East Meadow

Police: Man spray-painted antisemitic messages at homes, Jewish center in East Meadow

1:56
State officials: More chemical drums could be buried beneath Bethpage baseball field

State officials: More chemical drums could be buried beneath Bethpage baseball field

1:33
Groundbreaking ceremony marks beginning of Jake's 58 Casino's $210M expansion project

Groundbreaking ceremony marks beginning of Jake's 58 Casino's $210M expansion project

1:32
Nassau residents deliver petition with more than 1,600 signatures against proposal to deputize residents

Nassau residents deliver petition with more than 1,600 signatures against proposal to deputize residents

Police: Driver arrested for fatal Brentwood hit-and-run

Police: Driver arrested for fatal Brentwood hit-and-run

0:26
Police: Central Islip business cited for violation after State Liquor Authority investigation

Police: Central Islip business cited for violation after State Liquor Authority investigation

1:39
Paws & Pals: Dogs up for adoption at Almost Home Animal Rescue

Paws & Pals: Dogs up for adoption at Almost Home Animal Rescue

4:39
Guide: Ways to help you identify and deal with work burnout

Guide: Ways to help you identify and deal with work burnout

1:49
Officials: Fire dispatcher's wife alerts him about blaze at their Centereach home

Officials: Fire dispatcher's wife alerts him about blaze at their Centereach home

0:32
State police: Trooper conducting traffic stop rear-ended on Meadowbrook State Parkway

State police: Trooper conducting traffic stop rear-ended on Meadowbrook State Parkway

0:52
Paws of War service dogs attend candlelight remembrance vigil in Farmingdale

Paws of War service dogs attend candlelight remembrance vigil in Farmingdale

2:04
CDC: Most women do not get a mammogram because of financial difficulties

CDC: Most women do not get a mammogram because of financial difficulties

0:38
'Pearls of Wisdom' tea event in Riverhead aims to empower young Black women

'Pearls of Wisdom' tea event in Riverhead aims to empower young Black women

0:52
Splish Splash hosts 8th annual Polar Plunge fundraiser for Special Olympics athletes

Splish Splash hosts 8th annual Polar Plunge fundraiser for Special Olympics athletes

0:24
Police: Car crashes onto guardrail, overturns on LIE in Brentwood; driver injured

Police: Car crashes onto guardrail, overturns on LIE in Brentwood; driver injured