News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Taxing Long Island
Mostly Cloudy Night
69°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Taxing Long Island

Family of Farmingdale HS student files summons and complaint against bus company, driver following fatal crash

The complaint was filed against Regency Transportation and 59-year-old Lisa Schaffer, of Centereach, who has been identified as the driver.

Jon Dowding

Sep 28, 2023, 6:45 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

The family of a Farmingdale student involved in last week’s fatal bus rollover in Orange County has filed a summons and complaint against the bus company and driver.

The complaint was filed against Regency Transportation and 59-year-old Lisa Schaffer, of Centereach, who has been identified as the driver.

The crash killed the Farmingdale High School band director and a former teacher who was serving as a chaperone. Multiple students were also injured and are expected to be OK.

The survivor is a 14-year-old girl from the high school. Andrew Finkelstein, a managing partner at Jacoby & Meyers represents the survivor and her family.

He said thankfully, she's out of the hospital, but she suffered broken bones in her face and will require surgery.

The long-term mental and emotional effects of the crash, however, won't easily heal.

As the process for the civil lawsuit continues, Finkelstein says they need to learn more about what happened.

"We're looking at really why did this happen, but more importantly, it was both predictable and preventable,” he said. “It should have been prevented with early recognition of either a driver that shouldn't have been driving or a mechanical problem with the vehicle."

An exact cause for the crash is still under investigation, but attorneys say the cause was either mechanical or human error.

"We know that the bus, if it was in proper working order, or alternatively, if the driver was driving appropriately, the bus doesn't leave the highway and go down a ravine and this tragedy doesn't happen," said Finkelstein.

Her attorney also says they've been contacted by a few other survivors as well.

After filing this notice and complaint, attorneys for the family and the survivor must await a response from the defendants before moving forward with the lawsuit.

Finkelstein says they currently don’t have evidence of negligence on the part of the Farmingdale Union Free School District. This could change, however, as new evidence may surface.

Top Stories

01:50
IMG 6045

Mastic, Shirley and Mastic Beach communities seeking solutions as traffic becomes 'unbearable' in the area

02:22
F P2 PM 1 1

Warmer temperatures before showers going into the weekend across Long Island

Flock Part 1 MS 081726_2026-08-17-17-18-23

Suffolk County delays contract with Flock, extends deal with ShotSpotter

01:38
Gambling Issues MS 091626_2026-09-16-17-41-49

Mobile sports betting becomes NY's No. 2 gaming revenue source as problem gambling calls rise

01:49
Egg Donation MS 091626_2026-09-16-17-38-33

Long Island food banks receive 972,000 eggs through settlement, helping families facing food insecurity

01:39
LIReducedRefsKK_2026-09-16-17-52-03

Brentwood students train to become referees amid LI officiating shortage

00:12
UNLAWFUL SURVEILLANCE

Police seek man who put cellphone up woman’s dress in Riverhead

01:34
blaise waldman

Children of NY woman killed in 1974 speak out after advances in DNA, genealogy identify her killer

Federal Reserve

Federal Reserve hikes key rate for 1st time in 3 years

00:18
TEENDRIVERS_2026-09-16-16-51-09

National survey names New York best state for teen drivers

00:37
916pokemoncardsLI_2026-09-16-12-14-36

Hundreds line up at Levittown Best Buy to buy new Pokémon cards

00:34
916animalcrueltyyLI_2026-09-16-12-06-52

Wheatley Heights man accused of confining underweight, flea-infested dog to basement

00:36
44ac4eae-b1bd-439e-9e04-fdf3effee9a5

Former NYC corrections officer from Freeport sentenced for illegally collecting military leave pay

00:22
LISayvilleFireKK_2026-09-16-12-13-11

One person injured after car engine fire on Sunrise Highway

01:30
Screenshot 2026-09-16 130347

Tom Hiddleston and Hayley Atwell bring Much Ado About Nothing to Broadway

00:24
Screenshot 2026-09-16 125752

House passes bill requiring AM radio in all new cars sold nationwide

00:19
e-bike crash MONITOR copy

16-year-old e-bike rider injured in Hicksville crash

00:24
LIFoliageReportKK_2026-09-16-12-18-57

I LOVE NY releases fall foliage report, highlights top leaf-peeping places

01:01
9162026haunted_2026-09-16-07-18-09

Visitors report voices, footsteps and shadowy figures at historic Milleridge Inn

00:24
north merrick fire

2 people displaced following fire at North Merrick home

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices