Deliberations in Brancato murder trial start over

A mistrial was avoided Thursday in the murder trial of Lillo Brancato Jr. after juror number 12 was dismissed from the case for taking notes during testimony and doing research at home. The jury, which

News 12 Staff

Dec 19, 2008, 12:32 AM

Updated 5,695 days ago

Share:

A mistrial was avoided Thursday in the murder trial of Lillo Brancato Jr. after juror number 12 was dismissed from the case for taking notes during testimony and doing research at home.
The jury, which began deliberating Wednesday, started over Thursday. Brancato agreed to allow an alternate juror, Ms. Rodriguez, to substitute for the original juror, Marvin Gittens, who was dismissed. If Brancato had said no to the substitution, a mistrial would have been declared.
The jurors reviewed evidence Thursday afternoon after an emotional day in court Wednesday night. After the presiding judge dismissed the jury on Wednesday, the sister of slain Police Officer Daniel Enchautegui jumped up and faced Brancato, saying that she cannot look at him any longer. The woman then tried to leave the courtroom, but was held back by her children, who were also present at the hearing.
Brancato faces a second-degree murder charge in the shooting death of Enchautegui, who was killed after he tried to stop Brancato and Steven Armento from allegedly breaking into the home of his Pelham Bay neighbor in 2005.
Armento has already been convicted of murder in the officer?s death and sentenced to life in prison.
?Regardless of whose side you?re on, it?s a New York City police officer that?s dead,? says PBA President Pat Lynch.
AP wire reports contributed to this article.
Closing arguments delivered at actor's Bronx trial Brancato takes stand at murder trial Allegeddrug dealer testifies at Brancato trialWitness:Brancato was addicted to drugs in 2005Clericalmix-up puts Brancato trial on holdDoctortestifies in Lillo Brancato Jr. trial


More from News 12
1:41
Police: Small aircraft crashes at MacArthur Airport, killing 2

Police: Small aircraft crashes at MacArthur Airport, killing 2

1:31
Cloudy, comfortable with seasonal temps; tracking an unsettled pattern this week

Cloudy, comfortable with seasonal temps; tracking an unsettled pattern this week

1:49
Democratic delegates from LI give support to VP Harris to be presidential nominee

Democratic delegates from LI give support to VP Harris to be presidential nominee

1:36
3 men face murder charges in strangulation of North Amityville man

3 men face murder charges in strangulation of North Amityville man

1:32
Long Island special needs group receives bike donation

Long Island special needs group receives bike donation

0:34
Town of Hempstead Councilman Chris Carini laid to rest in Farmingdale

Town of Hempstead Councilman Chris Carini laid to rest in Farmingdale

1:49
Democratic delegates from LI give support to VP Harris to be presidential nominee

Democratic delegates from LI give support to VP Harris to be presidential nominee

0:24
Duck Donuts to offer BOGO deal Tuesday for National Sprinkle Day

Duck Donuts to offer BOGO deal Tuesday for National Sprinkle Day

3:04
Nassau Legislature Rules Committee votes to move forward with transferring operations of Nassau Coliseum to Las Vegas Sands

Nassau Legislature Rules Committee votes to move forward with transferring operations of Nassau Coliseum to Las Vegas Sands

0:37
Annual LI golf outing raises funds for those struggling with mental health, substance abuse

Annual LI golf outing raises funds for those struggling with mental health, substance abuse

1:32
Surf session held for adults and kids with disabilities

Surf session held for adults and kids with disabilities

0:17
Police: Valley Stream man slashed woman with knife at deli

Police: Valley Stream man slashed woman with knife at deli

1:43
Long Islanders have mixed reaction to President Biden’s announcement on presidential run

Long Islanders have mixed reaction to President Biden’s announcement on presidential run

0:46
President Biden announces end of 2024 bid for presidency; endorses VP Kamala Harris for pick

President Biden announces end of 2024 bid for presidency; endorses VP Kamala Harris for pick

1:48
Main Street Long Island: Showcasing the best of Great Neck

Main Street Long Island: Showcasing the best of Great Neck

0:17
Man wanted for breaking into Macy’s at Green Acres Mall

Man wanted for breaking into Macy’s at Green Acres Mall

0:16
Police: 2 men wanted for stealing from car in Ronkonkoma

Police: 2 men wanted for stealing from car in Ronkonkoma

2:08
National and local lawmakers stunned by Biden's decision not to seek reelection

National and local lawmakers stunned by Biden's decision not to seek reelection

2:03
How the new Democratic nominee will be selected ahead at the national convention

How the new Democratic nominee will be selected ahead at the national convention

Officials release statements following President Biden's decision to end reelection bid

Officials release statements following President Biden's decision to end reelection bid