Anthony Oddone freed on $500K bail after conviction in death of Andrew Reister is overturned

A Farmingville man who was convicted in the death of an off-duty Suffolk County corrections officer was freed on bail today as he awaits a new trial. Anthony Oddone walked out of Suffolk County Criminal

News 12 Staff

Dec 24, 2013, 3:22 AM

Updated 3,823 days ago

Share:


A Farmingville man who was convicted in the death of an off-duty Suffolk County corrections officer was freed on bail today as he awaits a new trial.

Anthony Oddone walked out of Suffolk County Criminal Court this afternoon to cheers from his relatives after an unnamed supporter posted $500,000 cash bail for him. He said he was thankful for the support he's received before a white SUV whisked him away.

Oddone had been behind bars since 2008 on a manslaughter conviction for the death of officer Andrew Reister, who had been moonlighting as a bouncer at the Southampton Publick House when he was killed.

Prosecutors had claimed that Oddone choked Reister to death during a bar brawl. Oddone was found guilty in Reister's death, but an appeals court overturned the verdict earlier this year on a technicality.

In court today, prosecutors argued that Oddone has a long criminal history and has been deemed an extreme flight risk in the past by probation officers. The district attorney's office had asked for $5 million cash bail or $15 million bond because of Oddone's tendency to run from the law.

Oddone's attorneys disputed that he's a flight risk. The judge set bail at $500,000 cash or $1 million bond because Oddone does not have a valid passport.

Oddone is still facing manslaughter charges, which carry up to 17 years behind bars if he's found guilty again. His attorneys say he'll be staying with his mother in upstate Orange County while the Suffolk County District Attorney's Office prepares the new case.

Oddone must appear in court in February for a hearing.

Riester's family packed half of the courtroom today for the proceeding, but the family declined to speak to the media afterward.


More from News 12
2:39
LI shooting club links Rex Heuermann to Manorville, aiding police in Gilgo Beach murders investigation

LI shooting club links Rex Heuermann to Manorville, aiding police in Gilgo Beach murders investigation

1:46
Mostly sunny and warm Thursday, chance for Friday evening storms

Mostly sunny and warm Thursday, chance for Friday evening storms

1:31
Indian-American fans torn between nations as Cricket World Cup wraps up in Nassau

Indian-American fans torn between nations as Cricket World Cup wraps up in Nassau

2:15
New York launches Mobile ID to digitize driver’s licenses, non-driver IDs. Here’s how to get it.

New York launches Mobile ID to digitize driver’s licenses, non-driver IDs. Here’s how to get it.

0:41
NY attorney general: Long Island to get over $16 million from settlement reached with e-cig maker Juul

NY attorney general: Long Island to get over $16 million from settlement reached with e-cig maker Juul

0:19
Nassau PD: Woman assaulted police officer outside UBS Arena

Nassau PD: Woman assaulted police officer outside UBS Arena

0:25
Rockville Centre to fly flags at half-staff in honor of officer killed in off-duty crash

Rockville Centre to fly flags at half-staff in honor of officer killed in off-duty crash

0:25
Police: Mom, 2 young children hit by car in Aquebogue

Police: Mom, 2 young children hit by car in Aquebogue

0:46
Students in East Islip display smashed cars on front lawn of high school for drunk driving awareness

Students in East Islip display smashed cars on front lawn of high school for drunk driving awareness

1:28
Garden Guide: This is why your plants are blooming better than usual this year

Garden Guide: This is why your plants are blooming better than usual this year

1:35
What's Cooking: Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace's lemon iced almond biscotti

What's Cooking: Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace's lemon iced almond biscotti

2:12
Exclusive: Never-before-seen photos show Rex Heuermann around the time of the Gilgo Beach killings

Exclusive: Never-before-seen photos show Rex Heuermann around the time of the Gilgo Beach killings

2:05
JetBlue to begin nonstop service from MacArthur Airport to 3 Florida destinations

JetBlue to begin nonstop service from MacArthur Airport to 3 Florida destinations

1:35
Future of Brentwood's annual Central American Festival in limbo after Town of Islip denies permit request

Future of Brentwood's annual Central American Festival in limbo after Town of Islip denies permit request

21:13
Kane In Your Corner: Victims of the System

Kane In Your Corner: Victims of the System

0:24
Police: 3-year-old girl pulled from pool in Central Islip

Police: 3-year-old girl pulled from pool in Central Islip

0:38
Police: Possible human remains discovered at construction site at Eagle Rock Apartments in Woodbury

Police: Possible human remains discovered at construction site at Eagle Rock Apartments in Woodbury

0:41
Medford’s first library celebrated at grand opening

Medford’s first library celebrated at grand opening

Is your dad awesome? Long Island tell us why your dad rocks!

Is your dad awesome? Long Island tell us why your dad rocks!

2024 Cricket World Cup on Long Island - Special Coverage

2024 Cricket World Cup on Long Island - Special Coverage