Taxing Long Island
News12 New York
Download the App
Where to Watch
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files
Stony Brook Medicine
LIRR Strike

Neighbors of accused Gilgo serial killer say they've had anxiety, problems sleeping

Psychologist Stephen Taylor says he recommends leaning on one another during times filled with fear.

Joe Arena

Jul 18, 2023, 10:15 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Neighbors of the accused Gilgo Beach serial killer says their initial shocker from the arrest has now turned into anxiety.

The search of Rex Heuermann's Massapequa Park home continues with no end in sight. Those who live nearby say it's something they are having to cope with.

LIVE BLOG: Updates on the case as they happen

MORE: GILGO MURDERS: Investigators collecting evidence from accused Gilgo serial killer’s South Carolina property 

Lori Garigiulo says she had a hard time sleeping the first night she realized an alleged serial killer was living in her neighborhood.

"I couldn't sleep, and it did help to talk to people about it," Garigiulo says.

Paul Correa, who raised his daughter just around the corner from Heuermann's home, says he has been feeling a lot of anxiety since police have camped out at the suspect's home.

"Everyone's in an uproar right now," Correa says. "I can't believe that this guy was in our neighborhood hiding out and it's been going on for over 10 years - it's insane."

WATCH: DOCUMENTARY AND BACKGROUND INFORMATION - Gilgo Beach: Unsolved

MORE: Car crashes to workers comp: Court records offer glimpse into Gilgo Beach murder suspect's past

Psychologist Stephen Taylor says he recommends leaning on one another during times filled with fear.

"Anytime there's something that's traumatic in your immediate vicinity and your neighborhood, it brings it to you in a way that maybe you thought you were isolated," Taylor says.

MORE: 'I can move on.' Sister of Gilgo victim says she is grateful for some closure

Taylor says it's important for neighbors to put things into perspective. He says that people can't live in fear because what happened was "very specific" and "very rare."

MORE: How police used a revived tip to make break in Gilgo Beach murder investigation

He says the most important thing for people in the community to do is to check in with each other as the investigation in Massapequa Park continues.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:42
LIRR Strike

LIVE LIRR UPDATES: Talks between LIRR unions, MTA resume on day 3 of strike; MTA chairman says agencies have made progress

02:43
WEB LI P1AM TODAY

Heat Alert: It will feel like summer as parts of Long Island reach the 90s

04:13
low res strike

LIRR strike in effect: How to navigate your commute

00:27
drowning

Teen drowns while swimming with friends off Shelter Island

00:28
518centerportcrash_2026-05-18-08-27-31

Driver entrapped after SUV crashes into Centerport fire station

01:53
518madeonlongisland_2026-05-18-06-18-16

Made on Long Island: The Gluten Free Treat Shop

01:50
5182026WCthecost_2026-05-18-08-09-28

The Cost Of: Cars

00:20
SUV

Police search for driver who hit jogger in Sayville, drove off

00:25
statue

Hate Crimes Unit investigating damaged Jesus statue at a Suffolk church

00:45
Screenshot 2026-05-17 053537

Man charged with murder in death of Bellport woman found unresponsive at Speedway gas station

00:19
LIOverdoseArrest_2026-05-17-06-24-32

Hempstead man arrested during police investigation into fatal overdose

02:12
nwesink

Lanes reopen as crews work to repair sinkhole on LIE in Melville

SEXUAL ABUSE ARREST MONITOR copy

USPS employee from Moriches accused of sexually abusing 15-year-old inside vehicle

00:20
LI_10PM_Tunnels Amtrak_ajc_2026-05-15-22-14-16

Amtrak says Penn Station service expected to resume as crews repair fire damage near terminal

01:38
li5pmbol2026loganportwashington_2026-05-15-17-33-10

Exclusive: Bullet from police chase strikes Port Washington woman's car

00:31
516farmingdale_2026-05-16-12-37-52

LIRR strike complicates finals week travel plans for Farmingdale State College students

SyossetBurglaryTN

Queens man accused of stealing more than $200K worth of items from Syosset home

news12

Connecticut Department of Health urges shellfish safety from imported products amid hepatitis A investigation

Harvey Weinstein

Harvey Weinstein rape retrial ends in mistrial as jury deadlocks

00:22
GRAND LARCENY police Monitor copy

Bellport man accused of spending over $260K stolen from employer on Onlyfans

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices