News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys
Clear
33°
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys

Slice of History: Islip deli serves up generations of flavor and community

Fast-forward nearly 120 years, and the deli is still serving the Islip community

Sep 4, 2025, 5:28 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A deli in the heart of Islip is doing more than just serving sandwiches, it’s dishing out history with every order. Once known as Nill’s Store, the beloved local spot opened its doors in 1912 and has been a cornerstone of the community ever since.

“It touches my heart, it really does,” said Kathleen Nill Sutter, whose grandparents first opened the store more than a century ago.

The smell of German specialties like sauerbraten and strudel once filled the neighborhood air, as Nill’s Store became known for its authentic home cooking.

“My grandmother was such a great cook,” Kathleen remembered.

Fast-forward nearly 120 years, and the deli is still serving the Islip community now under the stewardship of new owner John Boccone.

Despite the changes, Boccone is keeping the heart of the deli alive, while bringing in fresh energy and a new menu.

“It just has so much history,” Boccone said. “It’s a really nice, family-oriented community.”

The locals agree.

For Kathleen, her grandfather’s deli remains a special place. It’s not just a business it’s a living tribute to the family and the town that helped shape it.

“I love the new owner, John,” she said. “He is just like my grandfather, and I couldn’t ask for more than that.”

Top Stories

01:45
1118cecilia_subclip_2026-11-18-06-08-25_05-32-21,13

Sachem to hold first regular board of education meeting since stabbing incident

02:19
CX Headlines 4 (43)

Sunny and mild today on Long Island; near record warmth going into the weekend

mug

Man accused of stealing credit cards from lockers at 4 Nassau gyms

00:17
VET

New 24/7 emergency veterinary hospital opens in Carle Place

01:13
1118cooking_2026-11-18-05-31-28

What's Cooking: Pumpkin Pie

01:28
li10pmwesthempsteadgundaniella_2026-11-17-22-11-54

West Hempstead school officials outline new safety measures, task force after student brought gun to campus

00:28
903015590 18653094049052408 2903697968352615770 n

Rescued seal pup named Guppy returned to ocean after full recovery

01:08
li10pmantoinettehuntingtonbudget_2026-11-17-22-19-21

Town of Huntington fails to pass 18% tax increase

01:27
li5pmboldaniella_2026-11-17-17-14-55

Apple outages prompt warnings from tech experts on digital vulnerability

00:21
Police-involved shooting

Suffolk police shoot at man they say pointed BB gun at them in Farmingville

00:40
LI 5PM TUES_North Bayshore man guilty_ajc_2026-11-17-17-51-06

North Bay Shore man admits to raping 12-year-old girl, faces up to life in prison

00:18
li10pmbol9yearoldcarhit_2026-11-17-22-12-07

9-year-old hit by car seriously injured in West Babylon

01:29
5PM LI_Travel Troubles_ajc_2026-11-17-17-09-48

Holiday travel concerns grow because of disruptions as Thanksgiving rush approaches

00:26
LIteacherkilledkk_2026-11-17-17-16-02

2 men found guilty of murdering Bronx teacher they mistook for rival gang member

00:19
Stolen Tylenol MS 111726_2026-11-17-17-16-48

Suffolk police seeking 2 men who stole more than $1K worth of Tylenol from Huntington Station pharmacy

SCHOOL STABBING

Sachem East high schooler indicted for stabbing other student

download (1)

Classified communications network at the National Security Agency goes down, defense official says

02:09
Luke Albert

 Scholar Athlete: Luke Albert, Lindenhurst HS

01:42
Rob Free

LIRR President Rob Free reflects on career ahead of retirement

01:46
Macys Float TN

Eight new floats to debut as Macy’s Thanksgiving Day parade celebrates 100 years

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices