Former escort Nikkie Brass said Heuermann talked about the Gilgo killings during their meeting at a Port Jefferson restaurant in 2015.
"It didn't seem like a true crime fan who just knows information they've seen on TV and read it – seemed like somebody who was reliving it," says Brass.
LIVE BLOG: Gilgo Beach Murders
Brass went on to say that Heuerman then talked about how a killer could potentially get rid of the bodies by carrying burlap sacks through the marsh.