Recipients of anti-LGBTQ letters filled with threats fearful after learning Bayport man's sentence is reduced

In one letter, Robert Fehring wrote, "We were right there. They couldn't get a shot off at you. Too many cops. Very disappointed."

Thema Ponton

May 25, 2023, 2:46 AM

Updated 428 days ago

Share:

Some Long Islanders say they scared after another sentence reduction was given to a Bayport man in federal prison for making death threats.
LGBT Network President David Kilmnick say he can't believe that Robert Fehring's prison sentence has been reduced.
"I don't understand - based on what?," Kilmnick says. "You know, if they say based upon good behavior, that's because he doesn't have a computer and stamps at his disposal to send out more of these hate letters.
Kilmnick and others were the victims of anti-LGBTQ letters that sometimes contained death threats from Fehring.
Greater Sayville Chamber of Commere President Eileen Tyznar, who also was victim to Fehring's threats, says she "lost her breath" when she got an email from the Department of Justice telling her that the 74-year-old was getting some time off.
In a letter shared with News 12 Long Island by one of Fehring's victims, the Department of Justice says in part, "This notice is to inform you that Robert Fehring's release date has been changed. The inmate in now scheduled to be released on July 12, 2024."
Fehring was sentenced to 30 months in prison for sending hateful and threatening letters in the mail.
In one letter, which included photos of Kilmnick at a Pride event at Eisenhower Park, Fehring wrote, "We were right there. They couldn't get a shot off at you. Too many cops. Very disappointed."
"He took away three years of my life and my family's life where I had to look over my shoulder," Tyznar says.
Tyznar and Kilmnick caution that reduced sentences for hate crimes could serve as less of a deterrent for those committing them in the future.


More from News 12
2:05
Zillow report: 28 LI communities have million-dollar starter homes

Zillow report: 28 LI communities have million-dollar starter homes

1:32
Wonderful weekend ahead with shower chances early next week

Wonderful weekend ahead with shower chances early next week

0:25
Police: 5 officers injured while arresting man in West Hempstead

Police: 5 officers injured while arresting man in West Hempstead

1:22
Justin Timberlake to be arraigned again for DWI next week

Justin Timberlake to be arraigned again for DWI next week

2:01
Bay Shore Christian School parents left without answers as school owners move to shut down programs

Bay Shore Christian School parents left without answers as school owners move to shut down programs

2:04
Another huge turnout at the Feast of St. Rocco in Glen Cove

Another huge turnout at the Feast of St. Rocco in Glen Cove

1:58
LI program gets kids & parents ready to start school

LI program gets kids & parents ready to start school

1:28
Local Summer Olympics watch party happening in Copiague

Local Summer Olympics watch party happening in Copiague

2:02
Brooklyn man facing assault charges, accused of driving into pedestrians outside Eastern Suffolk BOCES

Brooklyn man facing assault charges, accused of driving into pedestrians outside Eastern Suffolk BOCES

0:18
Sen. Schumer announces $24 million in federal funding to revitalize downtown Riverhead

Sen. Schumer announces $24 million in federal funding to revitalize downtown Riverhead

0:36
Ceremony honors 24 students at NYU Grossman Long Island School of Medicine

Ceremony honors 24 students at NYU Grossman Long Island School of Medicine

1:44
The Real Deal: How to save on expenses amid rising costs in New York

The Real Deal: How to save on expenses amid rising costs in New York

0:33
State report: Long Island has lowest percentage of bridges in poor condition

State report: Long Island has lowest percentage of bridges in poor condition

1:40
Food Truck Friday: The Cone Depot

Food Truck Friday: The Cone Depot

0:20
Suffolk police officers help woman deliver baby in Amityville

Suffolk police officers help woman deliver baby in Amityville

3:44
Deer Park teen blacklisted by bank after falling for a fake check scam

Deer Park teen blacklisted by bank after falling for a fake check scam

1:18
Farm owner: 2 goats, 3 sheep dead after toxic bushes were thrown into pen on East End

Farm owner: 2 goats, 3 sheep dead after toxic bushes were thrown into pen on East End

1:59
Police: Scammers falsely reporting damage on people's properties before damaging it further

Police: Scammers falsely reporting damage on people's properties before damaging it further

1:46
'It’s just treacherous.' Calls for change grow along busy Nassau road amid multiple crashes

'It’s just treacherous.' Calls for change grow along busy Nassau road amid multiple crashes

1:41
Teens learn skills needed to become firefighters at Camp Fahrenheit 516

Teens learn skills needed to become firefighters at Camp Fahrenheit 516