Port Jefferson family was told their son was in jail in phone scam; nearly lost $15,000

The caller told Vigliarolo that her son, 27-year-old Tyler, had been arrested for driving through a stop sign while on his cellphone and hitting a pregnant woman with his car.

News 12 Staff

Feb 19, 2023, 5:18 PM

Updated 516 days ago

Share:

A Port Jefferson family nearly lost $15,000 to phone scammers claiming to be their son in jail.
On Friday morning, Sharon Vigliarolo received a phone call from a man identifying himself David Bell, who claimed to be her son’s public defender. The caller told Vigliarolo that her son, 27-year-old Tyler, had been arrested for driving through a stop sign while on his cellphone and hitting a pregnant woman with his car.
Vigliarolo was prepared to send $15,000 to get her son out of jail but grew suspicious after hearing the caller tell her he’d send someone to her home to pick up the money.
"Your parent mode kicks in and you're not thinking straight. All you're worried about is getting your son or daughter out of jail,” she said.
Prior to that phone call, Vigliarolo’s mother also received a call about the alleged incident from a scammer she believed was Tyler.
The family was convinced their son had committed the crime until Tyler used FaceTime to call them and prove he was not behind bars.
"When I was on the phone with my dad, he's like ‘aren't you in jail?’ I said no. He said, ‘it's OK you're in jail.’ I said, ‘I am not in jail.’ I FaceTime them and they're like, ‘oh my god, he is at home,” said Tyler. "They were all obviously upset and terrified when I FaceTimed them. The look on their face when they saw me in bed was out of this world."
The Vigliarolo family filed a police report about the incident. They said Suffolk police are aware of this scam. News 12 has also received several reports of people falling victim to the same scam across the county.
Private investigator Don Longo holds public lectures on phone scams. Although these situations are stressful, he says people should be prepared when someone asks for money over the phone.
"The bad guys are smart – you need to be smarter,” he said. "We need to take time to verify and confirm before we jump into those things. But again, the bad guys know that it's an emotional thing."


More from News 12
0:49
Global technology outage causes flight delays, cancellations on Long Island

Global technology outage causes flight delays, cancellations on Long Island

2:06
Sun, clouds and an isolated afternoon shower on Long Island

Sun, clouds and an isolated afternoon shower on Long Island

0:15
Police: Senior woman hit by car, seriously injured in Commack parking lot

Police: Senior woman hit by car, seriously injured in Commack parking lot

0:19
Police: Dirt bike rider killed in East Patchogue crash

Police: Dirt bike rider killed in East Patchogue crash

1:41
 Officials: COVID-19 has hit high levels in several states, including Connecticut

Officials: COVID-19 has hit high levels in several states, including Connecticut

2:29
Long Island residents face a myriad of issues due to global tech outage

Long Island residents face a myriad of issues due to global tech outage

0:29
Police: Motorcyclist killed after striking NICE bus in Lynbrook

Police: Motorcyclist killed after striking NICE bus in Lynbrook

0:41
Prosecutors: Driver had BAC twice the legal limit during fatal Deer Park nail salon crash

Prosecutors: Driver had BAC twice the legal limit during fatal Deer Park nail salon crash

2:21
Massive technology outage impacts LaGuardia Airport

Massive technology outage impacts LaGuardia Airport

0:28
Police: Hauppauge crash causes fuel spill on Motor Parkway

Police: Hauppauge crash causes fuel spill on Motor Parkway

0:35
North Merrick Library hosts Pokémon event with cards, crafts and characters

North Merrick Library hosts Pokémon event with cards, crafts and characters

2:01
‘You do have shared vulnerabilities.’ Security experts explain risks associated with global IT outage

‘You do have shared vulnerabilities.’ Security experts explain risks associated with global IT outage

1:30
Students take part federal court program in Central Islip

Students take part federal court program in Central Islip

A massive tech outage is causing worldwide disruptions. Here's what we know

A massive tech outage is causing worldwide disruptions. Here's what we know

5:00
Tech expert weighs in on Microsoft outage impacts across the globe

Tech expert weighs in on Microsoft outage impacts across the globe

Northwell Health activates emergency operations center amid technology outage, NYU Langone remains open

Northwell Health activates emergency operations center amid technology outage, NYU Langone remains open

Prosecutors: Bellport woman indicted for alleged hit-and-run crash that killed volunteer firefighter

Prosecutors: Bellport woman indicted for alleged hit-and-run crash that killed volunteer firefighter

2:27
Food Truck Friday: Roxy's Ice Cream Truck

Food Truck Friday: Roxy's Ice Cream Truck

13:51
'I’m not supposed to be here tonight.' Donald Trump recounts assassination attempt

'I’m not supposed to be here tonight.' Donald Trump recounts assassination attempt

0:38
Resilient North Babylon HS grad gets 5-figure donation from restaurant’s grand opening earnings

Resilient North Babylon HS grad gets 5-figure donation from restaurant’s grand opening earnings