Man found guilty of killing Farmingdale woman in 2002 has conviction overturned

A man who has served over 17 years in prison after being found guilty of killing a Farmingdale woman in 2002 has had his conviction overturned by a federal court.

News 12 Staff

Aug 21, 2019, 10:06 PM

Updated 1,760 days ago

Share:

A man who has served over 17 years in prison after being found guilty of killing a Farmingdale woman in 2002 has had his conviction overturned by a federal court.
The justices threw out the murder conviction, saying Paul Scrimo's constitutional rights were violated during his trial in May 2002.
Scrimo has challenged his conviction for years. In his latest challenge, Scrimo's attorney Randall Unger argued that three key defense witnesses were not allowed to testify at trial.
In the decision, the justices agreed writing, "We conclude that the trial court's exclusion of three defense witnesses violated Scrimo's constitutional right to present a complete defense. Accordingly, we reverse and remand the judgment of the district court."
The judges also noted DNA under the victim's fingernails belonged to another man.
Scrimo was convicted in the killing of floral designer Ruth Williams, who was strangled in her Farmingdale apartment in April 2000.
Unger says the conviction was based on testimony of a sole witness, who claimed Scrimo killed Williams because she had called his wife "fat and ugly."
Williams' brother tells News 12 the appeals court judges were wrong to overturn Scrimo's conviction, calling it a bitter disappointment.
Scrimo won't be released from prison until prosecutors decide whether to seek a retrial. A spokesperson for Nassau Districy Attorney Madeline Singas says her office is reviewing the decision but has not decided whether to retry the case.
Scrimo was serving 25 years to life in prison when the appeals court decided to toss out the conviction.
 


More from News 12
0:49
Officials: Fire displaces 18 from Hempstead home with illegal subdivisions

Officials: Fire displaces 18 from Hempstead home with illegal subdivisions

2:01
Pleasant Father’s Day with mix of sun and clouds on Long Island

Pleasant Father’s Day with mix of sun and clouds on Long Island

0:35
Police: Man accused of driving drunk in East Meadow with 13-year-old boy inside car

Police: Man accused of driving drunk in East Meadow with 13-year-old boy inside car

0:42
Hundreds participate in 45th annual Shelter Island 10K & 5K Run/Walk

Hundreds participate in 45th annual Shelter Island 10K & 5K Run/Walk

1:20
Rapper Ja Rule performs at Mitchel Field as part of Nassau County’s Juneteenth celebration

Rapper Ja Rule performs at Mitchel Field as part of Nassau County’s Juneteenth celebration

0:31
Suffolk police: Motorcyclist seriously hurt in Bay Shore crash

Suffolk police: Motorcyclist seriously hurt in Bay Shore crash

1:46
‘We lost a brother.’ Friends, loved ones remember ‘Rookie of the Year’ firefighter at Hagerman FD

‘We lost a brother.’ Friends, loved ones remember ‘Rookie of the Year’ firefighter at Hagerman FD

1:34
Early voting begins on Long Island for Democratic primary elections

Early voting begins on Long Island for Democratic primary elections

All lanes clear on Southern State parkway following overturned vehicle crash

All lanes clear on Southern State parkway following overturned vehicle crash

Is your dad awesome? Long Island tell us why your dad rocks!

Is your dad awesome? Long Island tell us why your dad rocks!

0:27
Police: Owner of Huntington restaurant, 2 security guards arrested during State Liquor Authority compliance check

Police: Owner of Huntington restaurant, 2 security guards arrested during State Liquor Authority compliance check

2:07
New beach rules limiting access take effect after shooting in Long Beach

New beach rules limiting access take effect after shooting in Long Beach

2:04
Kevin Jonas undergoes surgery to remove common skin cancer; urges fans to get checked

Kevin Jonas undergoes surgery to remove common skin cancer; urges fans to get checked

2:15
Police: Woman arrested for motorcyclist hit-and-run in Patchogue

Police: Woman arrested for motorcyclist hit-and-run in Patchogue

2:15
Oakdale residents call for Islip officials to hold owners of former Dowling College more accountable

Oakdale residents call for Islip officials to hold owners of former Dowling College more accountable

2:07
Study: Food insecurity becomes growing problem for Long Islanders

Study: Food insecurity becomes growing problem for Long Islanders

0:41
Mastic Beach street renamed for teen who was killed 3 years ago

Mastic Beach street renamed for teen who was killed 3 years ago

1:49
Baldwin residents & businesses call on Liberty to reimburse them after water main break

Baldwin residents & businesses call on Liberty to reimburse them after water main break

0:27
Police: Man accused of exposing himself outside Westbury church

Police: Man accused of exposing himself outside Westbury church

2:37
Police: 16-year-old shot in Long Beach following chaotic night with massive crowds

Police: 16-year-old shot in Long Beach following chaotic night with massive crowds