Focus of Selden murder-for-hire, incest case speaks with News 12

In 1986, Cheryl Pierson - a popular cheerleader at Newfield High School in Selden - was taken away in handcuffs, charged with hiring a classmate to kill her father. Now 30 years later, Pierson and her

News 12 Staff

Dec 30, 2016, 4:24 AM

Updated 2,763 days ago

Share:

In 1986, Cheryl Pierson - a popular cheerleader at Newfield High School in Selden - was taken away in handcuffs, charged with hiring a classmate to kill her father. Now 30 years later, Pierson and her husband sat down with News 12 Long Island to discuss the sexual abuse that led to her father's slaying.
On the morning of Feb. 5 1986, James Pierson was shot to death as he walked out the side door of his home on his way to work. Classmate Sean Pica had bought a shotgun and shot James Pierson in the back of his head.
The case attracted national attention and headlines, especially after it was revealed in court that Cheryl Pierson had been sexually abused by her father since she was 11 years old.
At the time, her mother was battling kidney disease and eventually died. Cheryl says the turning point came when she was 16 and realized her father was grooming her 8-year-old sister to be his next victim.
"Did I want to kill him myself? I did, I really did," Pierson told News 12. "I hated the man, but I loved him too. I just wished that it would just stop and we could just be a normal family."
Pierson was sentenced to six months in jail, but served just over three months. The prosecutors and the judge in the case stated they believed Pierson's story but said they could not condone her actions.
Her high school sweetheart Rob Cuccio, who had paid Pica $400 for the hit, got probation. Pica spent 16 years in prison.
Pierson and Cuccio have been married for 29 years and have two daughters. They say they are sharing the painful time of their life to help other victims of sexual abuse and incest.
The couple wrote a book called "Incest, Murder and a Miracle." The story will also be re-enacted on the TV series "ID Witness" on the Discovery Channel on Jan. 1.


More from News 12
1:50
Riverhead BOE approves plan to bring resource officers to schools

Riverhead BOE approves plan to bring resource officers to schools

2:02
Cloudy skies, muggy conditions and rain showers on Long Island

Cloudy skies, muggy conditions and rain showers on Long Island

0:27
Farmingdale parent files lawsuit in connection to deadly bus crash

Farmingdale parent files lawsuit in connection to deadly bus crash

4:23
Sen. Bob Menendez to resign from office Aug. 20 following corruption conviction

Sen. Bob Menendez to resign from office Aug. 20 following corruption conviction

0:26
Police: Suspect wanted for robbing Stop & Shop in East Meadow

Police: Suspect wanted for robbing Stop & Shop in East Meadow

0:28
Police: Suspect arrested for burglarizing Macy’s at Green Acres Mall multiple times

Police: Suspect arrested for burglarizing Macy’s at Green Acres Mall multiple times

0:18
Volunteers plant trees at Oakdale facility for people with developmental disabilities

Volunteers plant trees at Oakdale facility for people with developmental disabilities

1:45
Long Beach School Board renews talks to close elementary school following survey results

Long Beach School Board renews talks to close elementary school following survey results

0:23
Police: Third teen arrested for causing $600K in damage to Shelter Island home

Police: Third teen arrested for causing $600K in damage to Shelter Island home

2:01
Pilot, passenger from Virginia identified as victims in MacArthur Airport crash

Pilot, passenger from Virginia identified as victims in MacArthur Airport crash

1:04
Smithtown boy returns home from South Carolina after being stranded from global tech outage

Smithtown boy returns home from South Carolina after being stranded from global tech outage

1:59
Police: 2 men arrested for running construction scam targeting older adults in Floral Park

Police: 2 men arrested for running construction scam targeting older adults in Floral Park

1:38
Optimum donates $2,500 to Henry Viscardi School following wheelchair basketball game

Optimum donates $2,500 to Henry Viscardi School following wheelchair basketball game

1:43
Roosevelt man accused of series of crimes that resulted in injuries to 2 Nassau County officers

Roosevelt man accused of series of crimes that resulted in injuries to 2 Nassau County officers

1:50
New mental health clinic opens at NUMC

New mental health clinic opens at NUMC

0:18
Police: 3 men wanted for stealing $6,000 worth of sunglasses in Lake Grove

Police: 3 men wanted for stealing $6,000 worth of sunglasses in Lake Grove

0:20
Big Lots to close stores nationwide, including 2 locations on Long Island

Big Lots to close stores nationwide, including 2 locations on Long Island

0:16
Riverhead police chief announces departure from department

Riverhead police chief announces departure from department

1:48
Made on Long Island: Long Island Meal Prep in West Hempstead

Made on Long Island: Long Island Meal Prep in West Hempstead

0:43
Toys for Tots Foundation helps campers celebrate Christmas in July

Toys for Tots Foundation helps campers celebrate Christmas in July