Fire at Mill Pond House on West Shore Road in Oyster Bay deemed suspicious by police

A historic home in Oyster Bay that dates back to the 1660s was gutted by a fire that has been deemed suspicious by police. The flames broke out Saturday night at the Mill Pond House in Oyster Bay.

News 12 Staff

Mar 24, 2014, 12:56 AM

Updated 3,734 days ago

Share:

A historic home in Oyster Bay that dates back to the 1660s was gutted by a fire that has been deemed suspicious by police.
The flames broke out Saturday night at the Mill Pond House in Oyster Bay. It took about 100 firefighters nearly an hour to douse the blaze.
Investigators say the home was vacant, and they believe the fire was not accidental. News 12 Long Island has learned that it marks the second fire at the house in just a week.
Sources say that the fire hydrant closest to the house wasn't working. A hydrant down the road had to be used to extinguish the fire.
The Town of Oyster Bay purchased the Mill Pond House back in 2008 for $1.9 million. The five-bedroom, 334-year-old home is one of the oldest structures in Oyster Bay.
Deputy Town Supervisor Leonard Genova says Town Supervisor John Venditto had the home boarded up after the first fire, and extra patrols were placed near the house.
Genova says the town wanted to make significant improvements to restore the home, but the renovations would have been costly.
The town's building commissioner will examine the home on Monday to determine if it is salvageable.
Nassau County Fire Marshall and Arson-Bomb Squad detectives are investigating. They're asking anyone with information to call Crime Stoppers at 1-800-244-TIPS.


More from News 12
2:39
LI shooting club links Rex Heuermann to Manorville, aiding police in Gilgo Beach murders investigation

LI shooting club links Rex Heuermann to Manorville, aiding police in Gilgo Beach murders investigation

2:34
Mostly sunny and warm Thursday, chance for Friday evening storms

Mostly sunny and warm Thursday, chance for Friday evening storms

1:54
Stony Brook University study finds connection between 9/11 toxins and dementia

Stony Brook University study finds connection between 9/11 toxins and dementia

1:49
April earthquake possibly to blame for broken church elevator in Hempstead Village

April earthquake possibly to blame for broken church elevator in Hempstead Village

0:25
Town officials attempt to save Central American Day Festival in Brentwood

Town officials attempt to save Central American Day Festival in Brentwood

1:46
Some New Yorkers fear consequences of growing marijuana at home

Some New Yorkers fear consequences of growing marijuana at home

2:23
PSEG LI crew frees bird stuck in wires behind Shirley home

PSEG LI crew frees bird stuck in wires behind Shirley home

1:31
Indian-American fans torn between nations as Cricket World Cup wraps up in Nassau

Indian-American fans torn between nations as Cricket World Cup wraps up in Nassau

2:15
Eisenhower Park to reopen to the public Thursday, including all 3 golf courses and Aquatic Center

Eisenhower Park to reopen to the public Thursday, including all 3 golf courses and Aquatic Center

0:41
NY attorney general: Long Island to get over $16 million from settlement reached with e-cig maker Juul

NY attorney general: Long Island to get over $16 million from settlement reached with e-cig maker Juul

2:15
New York launches Mobile ID to digitize driver’s licenses, non-driver IDs. Here’s how to get it.

New York launches Mobile ID to digitize driver’s licenses, non-driver IDs. Here’s how to get it.

0:19
Nassau PD: Woman assaulted police officer outside UBS Arena

Nassau PD: Woman assaulted police officer outside UBS Arena

0:25
Rockville Centre to fly flags at half-staff in honor of officer killed in off-duty crash

Rockville Centre to fly flags at half-staff in honor of officer killed in off-duty crash

0:25
Police: Mom, 2 young children hit by car in Aquebogue

Police: Mom, 2 young children hit by car in Aquebogue

0:46
Students in East Islip display smashed cars on front lawn of high school for drunk driving awareness

Students in East Islip display smashed cars on front lawn of high school for drunk driving awareness

1:28
Garden Guide: This is why your plants are blooming better than usual this year

Garden Guide: This is why your plants are blooming better than usual this year

1:35
What's Cooking: Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace's lemon iced almond biscotti

What's Cooking: Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace's lemon iced almond biscotti

21:13
Kane In Your Corner: Victims of the System

Kane In Your Corner: Victims of the System

Is your dad awesome? Long Island tell us why your dad rocks!

Is your dad awesome? Long Island tell us why your dad rocks!

2024 Cricket World Cup on Long Island - Special Coverage

2024 Cricket World Cup on Long Island - Special Coverage