Court documents: Records of burner phones, DNA from pizza crust helped lead to arrest of Gilgo Beach suspect

Rex Heuermann used two of the victims' phones after their deaths to check their voicemails and make taunting calls to their relatives, according to court documents.

Rachel Yonkunas,

News 12 Staff

and Carmen Grant

Jul 14, 2023, 9:23 PM

Updated 337 days ago

Share:

Court documents released Friday detail what finally led police to the suspected killer of at least three of the Gilgo Beach victims.
Police say they were able to ping Rex Heuermann's location using billing records for burner phones he allegedly used to talk with the victims , including Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman and Amber Costello, before they disappeared.
Rex Heuermann used two of the victims' phones after their deaths to check their voicemails and make taunting calls to their relatives, according to court documents.
Those calls were made in midtown Manhattan where Heuermann works.
LIVE BLOG: Updates on the case as they happen Investigators say another one of the victim's cellphones was last pinged near the suspect's home in Massapequa Park.
Neighbors were shocked to hear that the calls were made so close to their homes. “That just takes it to a whole another level,” says Jenna Datlo. “I mean, that’s just monstrous."
Heuermann is also the suspect in the death of a fourth woman, Maureen Brainard Barnes.
Authorities say Heuermann used a device to contact Brainard Barnes 16 different times in July 2007.
At one point, authorities believe the defendant used one of the cell phones from Barthelemy after she went missing to call the victim’s relative.
Cell phone records show that Heuermann made many of the calls to his alleged victims near his residence in Massapequa Park. He would travel to and from his job in Manhattan with a burner device.
Pings from cell phone towers from both Massapequa Park and midtown Manhattan were tracked back to Heuermann.
"All of our phones, as we go along, communicate with the cell towers," says TechRadar's U.S. Editor-in-Chief Lance Ulanoff. "It kind of creates a map of where of where we are."
In January, investigators obtained Heuermann's DNA from a discarded pizza crust. They say the DNA from it matched a hair found with the body of one of the victims.
WATCH: DOCUMENTARY AND BACKGROUND INFORMATION - Gilgo Beach: Unsolved
Investigators also obtained a search warrant for the suspect's email account. They say it revealed that between March 2022 and June 2023, the suspect searched more than 200 times for information on the victims' disappearances and the investigation into their murders.
The complete investigation into Heuermann consists of more than 300 subpoenas and search warrants.
Authorities say Heuermann also used a burner phone to create fake online accounts. One was allegedly used for an online dating service.
Another burner phone was used for Google search topics related to the Gilgo Beach cases, as well as topics that were sexual in nature.


More from News 12
1:40
Officials: Fire displaces 18 from Hempstead home with illegal subdivisions

Officials: Fire displaces 18 from Hempstead home with illegal subdivisions

2:13
Sunny, hot Monday kicks off scorching week on Long Island

Sunny, hot Monday kicks off scorching week on Long Island

0:33
Police: Man arrested in Montauk hit-and-run that left e-bike riders hurt

Police: Man arrested in Montauk hit-and-run that left e-bike riders hurt

0:29
Nassau police: 2 women charged in Franklin Square home burglary

Nassau police: 2 women charged in Franklin Square home burglary

0:35
Police: Man accused of driving drunk in East Meadow with 13-year-old boy inside car

Police: Man accused of driving drunk in East Meadow with 13-year-old boy inside car

Is your dad awesome? Long Island tell us why your dad rocks!

Is your dad awesome? Long Island tell us why your dad rocks!

2:02
 A potential heat wave is coming. These sunscreen tips can save your skin

A potential heat wave is coming. These sunscreen tips can save your skin

0:42
Hundreds participate in 45th annual Shelter Island 10K & 5K Run/Walk

Hundreds participate in 45th annual Shelter Island 10K & 5K Run/Walk

1:20
Rapper Ja Rule performs at Mitchel Field as part of Nassau County’s Juneteenth celebration

Rapper Ja Rule performs at Mitchel Field as part of Nassau County’s Juneteenth celebration

0:31
Suffolk police: Motorcyclist seriously hurt in Bay Shore crash

Suffolk police: Motorcyclist seriously hurt in Bay Shore crash

1:46
‘We lost a brother.’ Friends, loved ones remember ‘Rookie of the Year’ firefighter at Hagerman FD

‘We lost a brother.’ Friends, loved ones remember ‘Rookie of the Year’ firefighter at Hagerman FD

1:34
Early voting begins on Long Island for Democratic primary elections

Early voting begins on Long Island for Democratic primary elections

All lanes clear on Southern State parkway following overturned vehicle crash

All lanes clear on Southern State parkway following overturned vehicle crash

0:27
Police: Owner of Huntington restaurant, 2 security guards arrested during State Liquor Authority compliance check

Police: Owner of Huntington restaurant, 2 security guards arrested during State Liquor Authority compliance check

2:07
New beach rules limiting access take effect after shooting in Long Beach

New beach rules limiting access take effect after shooting in Long Beach

2:04
Kevin Jonas undergoes surgery to remove common skin cancer; urges fans to get checked

Kevin Jonas undergoes surgery to remove common skin cancer; urges fans to get checked

2:15
Police: Woman arrested for motorcyclist hit-and-run in Patchogue

Police: Woman arrested for motorcyclist hit-and-run in Patchogue

2:15
Oakdale residents call for Islip officials to hold owners of former Dowling College more accountable

Oakdale residents call for Islip officials to hold owners of former Dowling College more accountable

2:07
Study: Food insecurity becomes growing problem for Long Islanders

Study: Food insecurity becomes growing problem for Long Islanders

0:41
Mastic Beach street renamed for teen who was killed 3 years ago

Mastic Beach street renamed for teen who was killed 3 years ago