News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys
Foggy
53°
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys

Comptroller warns second home tax could raise less than expected

The report says that before adjusting factors, the tax could raise almost exactly $500 million from a little over 11,200 properties. However, it estimates the tax would likely be between $340 million and $380 million once real‑world factors are considered.

Heather Fordham

•

May 1, 2026, 5:23 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

New York City’s executive budget is now officially late as Mayor Zohran Mamdani works to close a multibillion‑dollar deficit without cutting core services.

The Council agreed to extend the budget deadline to May 12, giving negotiators more time to address a gap that exceeds $5 billion.

Among the proposals under consideration is a pied‑à‑terre tax, a surcharge on second homes valued at $5 million or more.

Supporters, including the mayor and Gov. Kathy Hochul, have said the measure could generate roughly $500 million annually and affect about 13,000 properties, many of them high‑rise apartments that sit vacant for much of the year.

A new analysis from City Comptroller Mark Levine suggests the revenue would likely fall short of those expectations.

The report says that before adjusting factors, the tax could raise almost exactly $500 million from a little over 11,200 properties. However, it estimates the tax would likely be between $340 million and $380 million once real‑world factors are considered, including how many units are rented and how property owners might change their behavior to avoid the surcharge.

“There are examples of other states and localities where similar taxes have been proposed and enacted, and it hasn’t lived up to revenue expectations,” said Matt Cammarata, a New York City tax attorney.

Cammarata said one of the biggest legal challenges could center on how the city determines the value of the homes subject to the tax.

“If they’re using property‑tax assessed value, I think the question will be, 'Is that accurate?'” he said. “And do taxpayers who are potentially subject to the tax have the opportunity to present opposing valuations that would potentially reduce the tax? I think that’s an area where there could be a lot of controversy, depending on how value is defined in the law.”

The comptroller’s report is based on earlier versions of the legislation. Lawmakers have not yet released final language detailing how the tax would be structured.

Top Stories

02:16
LI THUMB

STORM WATCH: A coastal storm brushes by tonight, another storm arrives on Thanksgiving

02:09
RTLIHuntingtonBudgetLatestJRGaertner1030pm_2026-11-21-22-39-06

Huntington budget approved by default after board members miss meeting

00:35
LIbillyjoelbikekk_2026-11-22-06-34-56

Billy Joel's 'Madison Square Garden' Triumph fetches $577K at auction, over 50 times estimate

01:18
image

FBI investigating possible hack of major criminal justice database

00:28
LIrockypointraidkk_2026-11-22-06-34-41

Patchogue woman arrested in Rocky Point massage parlor raid following community complaints

00:28
Pedestrian killed

Pedestrian struck and killed on LIE in Manorville

00:15
ShootingArrest

4 men arrested following shooting in Mastic

00:27
underage drinking arrest beer police car lights OTS copy

Flanders man seen swerving on Hampton Bays road charged with DWAI

00:21
GENERIC POLICE LIGHTS

Vape bandit sought in South Farmingdale smoke shop burglary

00:08
student loans

New York State opens applications for 2 student loan forgiveness programs

01:32
NCC Stabbing Arrest MS 112026_2026-11-20-17-05-23

Police say gang-related attack led to stabbing inside Nassau Community College cafeteria

01:23
LI 10PM FRI_Holiday Lights Jones_ajc_2026-11-20-22-09-08

Magic of Lights returns to Jones Beach, bringing holiday displays and family fun

01:33
LI 5PM FRI_Adoption_ajc_2026-11-20-17-41-57

Ten children officially adopted at the National Adoption Day Celebration at Long Island Aquarium

00:30
LI 5PM FRI_ ICE  LAWSUIT_ajc_2026-11-20-17-43-47

Nassau County joins lawsuit challenging Hochul's ICE cooperation ban

01:52
taracollapse1120_2026-11-20-16-54-08

NYC excavation oversight examined following Brooklyn building collapse

00:49
Nassau coat drive

Annual coat drive kicks off in Nassau County

00:44
ERASE Racism Hofstra Event

Nassau high school students participate in anti-racism conference

01:56
IMG 3056

FourLeaf Credit Union hosts 18th annual turkey drive to help LI families ahead of Thanksgiving

00:15
Stacey Sikes

Stacey Sikes makes history as first female president of the Long Island Association

02:05
Huntington Harbor Walk

Huntington Harbor Walk project advances with new waterfront improvements

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices