News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Vote 2026: Long Island elections
Clear
59°
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Vote 2026: Long Island elections

Officials warn of 'lost pet scams' as Valhalla family searches for missing dog

Jessica Grassi and her family have been looking everywhere for her pet, putting up flyers and signs around their home in Valhalla and beyond. Grassi has gotten messages, but they’re raising some major red flags

Melanie Palmer

•

Oct 7, 2026, 5:36 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

There's an urgent warning about scammers taking advantage of pet owners during very stressful times.

A woman in Valhalla says she's being flooded with concerning messages while trying to find her missing dog.

“It's been my worst nightmare. She’s my everything," said Jessica Grassi.

That everything for Grassi is her dog, Pinto. The 4-year-old dog is a source of comfort during difficult times.

“I kind of pressured my parents into letting me get her because I wasn’t feeling good. She came and two days later, I was in the hospital for a week and diagnosed with an autoimmune disease, and I get infusions. Pinto sits with me and comforts me throughout them," Grassi explained.

However, she hasn’t seen Pinto in over a month.

“On Sept. 6, she was in my backyard with my mom, going to the bathroom. Our backyard is fenced in and fireworks went off. She got scared and just freaked out and took off under the gate," Grassi told News 12.

Since then, Grassi and her family have been looking everywhere, putting up flyers and signs around their home in Valhalla and beyond.

Grassi has gotten messages, but they’re raising some major red flags.

“A lot of them have the same approach. They say, 'My neighbor found her. I'll give you her address if you send me money.' It's always like Bitcoin, or gift cards or Venmo," said Grassi.

On top of that, they include pictures, even videos that she says appear to be AI-generated.

Officials say these kinds of cases are becoming more common. In fact, News 12’s Walt Kane just did a report on an uptick in scams like this.

Just days ago, police in Norwalk, Connecticut put out an alert on Facebook.

"A missing pet is an emotional and stressful situation and scammers know that. Take a moment to verify before sending money or personal information," read part of the post.

Grassi's search continues for her Pinto. She says the dog has a black stripe on her back. Grassi urges people to reach out with legitimate information.

Top Stories

01:27
10 7 Remembrance MS 100726_2026-10-07-17-09-17

Jewish community reflects on Oct. 7 anniversary with remembrance, grief, and hope

02:21
F P1 PM 1

Comfortable and breezy this evening; tracking Isaias-related rain early next week

01:54
TTTjaredskatboard_2026-10-07-18-04-09

Hempstead family gets guarantee memorial skate park will stay after Turn to Tara investigation

Suozzi Lepetri

Submit Your Questions: Congressional District 3 debate between Suozzi and LiPetri

841099528 1570047338495180 3237226976080133719 n

Juvenile humpbacks freed from Fire Island sandbars after hourslong stranding

00:30
LI 5PM WED_Starbucks Closed_ajc_2026-10-07-17-11-38

Starbucks closes Islip location as multiple Long Island stores shut down

01:48
LIEldarDVAbuseKK_2026-10-07-17-13-17

Elderly abuse cases rise in Suffolk County as officials plan awareness panel

01:42
LI 5PM WED_Necklace Scam_ajc_2026-10-07-17-08-40

Nassau police arrest 2 in alleged jewelry theft scam; Residents urged to stay alert

01:40
LIMailTheftPKGKK_2026-10-07-17-26-07

Security concerns persist as mail theft complaints top 800,000 nationwide

00:23
LIFreeportGuiltyPleaKK_2026-10-07-17-33-38

Man pleads guilty after coverup attempt in fatal Freeport hit-and-run

00:31
LIcornerstoneKK_2026-10-07-12-27-17

Town of Huntington approves Cornerstone Melville project special permit

00:57
IMG 9067

Valmont Survivors Park opens in Commack, honoring cancer survivors and loved ones

00:31
LIburglarykk_2026-10-07-12-44-13

Police searching for man caught on camera stealing from Island Park catering business

00:20
Stabbing investigation

Man stabbed, woman stabs self in Melville domestic incident

00:25
LISEXOFFENDERARREST107_2026-10-07-05-10-48

Sex offender from Bethpage arrested for child sex abuse materials

01:07
2021 TRI (1)

Hurricane Isaias again? A 2020 Deja vu on the 2026 list.

00:57
107huntingtonleafblower_2026-10-07-08-10-20

Town of Huntington rejects resolution to limit gas-powered leaf blowers

02:40
107richvote2026_2026-10-07-05-46-49

Skipping debates: Why some Long Island congressional candidates are staying off the stage

00:28
107disney_2026-10-07-06-40-58

Planning a Disney trip? Ticket, annual pass prices just spiked

00:18
LB FIRE

Unattended candle likely to blame for Long Beach apartment fire

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices