News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Taxing Long Island
Sunny
71°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Taxing Long Island

No release for John Alite, former mob hitman accused of extortion and loansharking

Englishtown Councilman and former hitman for the Gambino Crime family, John Alite, is headed back to jail to await trial. During a detention hearing in Passaic County, a judge denied his attorney's request to go home.

Chris Keating

Jun 24, 2026, 12:52 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A judge in Passaic County has sent John Alite back to a jail cell until the start of his trial on charges of loansharking and extortion.

The Englishtown councilman also holds convictions from his past for murder and money laundering as a former member and hitman for the Gambino crime family.

Superior Court Judge Imre Karaszegi stated that, based on the evidence surrounding the alleged crimes, there would be an escalating danger and a risk for potential witness intimidation if Alite were freed.

During a detention and probable cause hearing, the state argued that Alite had threatened two victims who were slow to pay back $150,000 in loans. Those loans carried a 7% monthly rate and 80% for the year.

In phone calls to those victims, Alite allegedly told the two victims that he "guts people like fish" and "Don't think that can't happen to you."

"We know from the defendant's own words that he is not a changed man. He told the victims that, in this case," Deputy State Attorney General Heather Hausleben said.

However, his defense says Alite never actually harmed anyone after making those calls and hasn't been in trouble with the law in 15 years.

"Were there phone calls during that time? Sure. Were they pleasant? No, they weren't pleasant. He wanted his money," said defense attorney Sean Barnes.

Barnes later defended his client, saying, "The fact remains, for 15 years, John Alite has been in the community for 15 years with no issue. Not so much as a parking ticket in 15 years."

Alite can appeal the judge's decision to have him stay in jail.

The state will now send the case to the grand jury for consideration.

Top Stories

01:59
IMG 6038

Islip Town Board to hold public hearing on proposal to prohibit battery energy storage system project in Hauppauge

01:30
F P1 PM 1

A fall feel to the air with below average temperatures today on Long Island

00:20
OperationSanta_2026-09-15-12-21-05

'Tis the season! Children can start sending letters to Santa as USPS opens annual program

02:18
LISTATESUFFOLKSUNRIS91526_2026-09-15-08-31-22

State, Suffolk leaders to propose widening Sunrise Highway to Exit 59

00:56
LI 10PM WED_MoneyWorries_ajc_2026-05-06-22-09-02

More New Yorkers could save up to $500 a year on utility bills under expanded state program

01:34
Screenshot 2026-09-15 061311

2026-27 Snowfall Outlook: The El Niño recipe, Part 2

01:23
LI 5PM MON_Unionale Homicide_ajc_2026-09-14-17-03-17

Homicide investigation underway after man found dead in Uniondale

01:37
LITAXINGLI91526_2026-09-15-05-53-12

Long Island ranked nation’s strongest seller’s housing market, study finds

00:24
motorcycle fatal

Motorcyclist killed in crash with SUV in New Cassel

00:19
e-bike crash MONITOR copy

Teen e-bike rider hurt in collision with pickup truck in Massapequa Park

00:25
LIMARQUEEGRANT915_2026-09-15-05-40-29

Roosevelt school receives $40K grant to construct new marquee

01:42
li10pmboljeremyregents_2026-09-14-22-08-10

NY students won't need Regents exams to graduate starting in 2028

01:37
li10pmwanderingpagekarina_2026-09-14-22-21-31

Latina business owner creates a literacy hub for diverse voices

01:36
Screenshot 2026-09-14 13182775676

1 dead after vehicle crashes into toll booth area at entrance to Sunken Meadow State Park

01:26
LI 5PM MON_Gas  Station Robbery_ajc_2026-09-14-17-07-32

Exclusive: Police search for man in connection to knifepoint robbery at Rockville Centre gas station

01:19
SHIRLEY DOG

Police search for person who abandoned malnourished dog in Shirley

01:45
Bellport Issues MS 091426_2026-09-14-17-11-33

Community raises safety concerns after arrest, police presence at Bellport HS

00:20
LIISLANDERSCAP91426_2026-09-14-12-34-03

NY Islanders announce new captain to lead the squad

00:54
26C0594800 A

Suffolk police release video of illegal street racing on LIE service road in Yaphank that led to 4 arrests

00:25
LISSSPCARFIRE91426_2026-09-14-12-34-06

Car bursts into flames on Southern State Parkway in Islip

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices