Taxing Long Island
News12 New York
Download the App
Where to Watch
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files
Stony Brook Medicine
LIRR Strike

Grand jury declines to charge Guttenberg police officer in 2024 death

Investigators reviewed evidence, including witness statements, 911 calls, police radio transmissions, body‑worn camera footage, surveillance video, photographs and autopsy results.

Pedro Carmona

Mar 26, 2026, 7:09 AM

Updated

Share:

A state grand jury has decided not to file criminal charges against a Guttenberg police officer following its review of a fatal encounter that occurred in the township in November 2024.

The civilian who died during the incident was identified as Brandon Lee Ortega, 26, of Mexia, Texas. After hearing testimony and reviewing evidence, the grand jury voted “no bill” on March 23, concluding no criminal charges should be brought against Officer Brandon Sauerwald.

Investigators reviewed extensive evidence, including witness statements, 911 calls, police radio transmissions, body‑worn camera footage, surveillance video, photographs and autopsy results.

According to investigators, Guttenberg police officers were called to the area of 68th Street and Bellevue Avenue at about 11:02 p.m. on Nov. 12, 2024, after a report of a disturbance. A property owner told officers he had rented a room to a woman who never arrived and instead encountered two men and a woman attempting to enter the property. An argument followed, and one man was reported to have displayed a blue firearm.

Officers searched the area and later located Ortega near 7000 John F. Kennedy Boulevard East.

Police said Ortega ran from Officer Sauerwald and attempted to carjack a vehicle during the brief chase. After the attempt failed, the driver followed Ortega as the officer continued pursuit.

Police said Ortega climbed over a railing and fell about 68 feet. Emergency responders arrived, but Ortega was pronounced dead at the scene. A firearm with a black grip and metallic blue coloring was recovered, authorities said.

Video from police body‑worn cameras, surveillance cameras and related 911 calls is being released to the public.

Members of Ortega’s family were given an opportunity to review the recordings before their release.

The Attorney General’s Office said the grand jury’s decision concludes the criminal review of the incident.

Top Stories

02:09
FC4(22)

STORM WATCH: Prepare for a wet, breezy and cool weekend with travel impacts

02:01
Board Issues MS 052226_2026-05-22-22-04-54

Hempstead Schools appeals voting results and puts two workers on administrative leave

02:38
Abuse Folo MS 052226_2026-05-22-17-11-56

Court documents reveal disturbing details of alleged abuse prior to 7-year-old Bayport girl’s death

Jones Beach Event Rescheduled

Jones Beach drone show rescheduled due to weather

01:48
IMG 6977

Two women charged after police uncover alleged brothel in Dix Hills home

01:45
MDW Biz Impact MS 052226_2026-05-22-17-13-59

Rainy Memorial Day weekend threatens turnout at Long Island businesses

00:35
Screenshot 2026-05-22 175508

1 person dead, 30 injured following shipyard explosion on Staten Island

AP26141697300440

Trump administration rule to force foreigners in the US to apply for a green card abroad

LaGuardia

LaGuardia Airport runway reopens after sinkhole repairs causing severe delays

00:35
CW26-101 (1)

Emaciated dog found with mouth bound shut by rubber band in Port Jefferson Station

02:02
LIPDDWIAX522_2026-05-22-05-18-19

2 Suffolk police officers nearly hit by alleged drunk driver in Wyandanch

00:28
LIEBIKEAX522_2026-05-22-05-05-29

10-year-old boy seriously hurt in Lake Ronkonkoma e-bike crash

00:18
o

Medford Memorial Day parade canceled due to lack of participation

00:25
LIDISTRACTION522_2026-05-22-05-37-09

Man arrested for stealing money from woman in distraction scheme in Suffolk

01:50
522foodtruck_2026-05-22-06-23-57

Food Truck Friday: Boxcar Burgers

00:18
522icearrestsuffolk_2026-05-22-05-17-04

ICE arrests man from El Salvador for sex crime against child in Suffolk County

02:42
CPS Issues MS 052126_2026-05-21-17-05-29

Questions mount in death of Bayport 7-year-old

01:32
LIJennaRonkBirdsKK_2026-05-21-23-09-56

Date set for Lake Ronkonkoma fireworks show despite community concerns

00:26
LIBayShoreKK_2026-05-21-23-08-46

Bay Shore man pleads guilty to raping, sex trafficking numerous victims

01:37
LILoganArraignmentKK_2026-05-21-17-59-37

Suffolk woman charged with criminal mischief after statue of Jesus' head removed at East Islip church

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices