News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Taxing Long Island
Stony Brook Medicine
Vote 2026: Long Island primaries

Police: Fire at Medford animal sanctuary kills man and multiple cats

Animal rescue teams went to the scene to secure the area with fencing and assist with the surviving cats.

Cecilia Dowd

and

Jon Dowding

Mar 31, 2025, 10:09 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A fire at a Medford home that serves as an animal sanctuary killed a man and multiple cats, police say.

The fire broke out on Dourland Road in Medford around 7:15 a.m., authorities said.

Neighbors tell News 12 the flames from the fire looked uncontrollable.

"It was as bad as I'd ever seen in a long time. It's like a woods fire,” said Fred Mack, of Medford. “I didn't think they were gonna put it out, that's how bad it was."

Police said 65-year-old Christopher Arsenault died in the fire.

Arsenault’s home was the site of “Happy Cat Sanctuary,” a cat rescue that Arsenault’s friends say was his world.

“He gave everything to these animals,” said Lisa Jaeger, a Happy Cat Sanctuary board member. "He gave his life to save these cats. He actually went back in the house when it was burning to get the cats out."

The cause of the fire is under investigation.

Some cats did survive, though the exact number of deceased and living is unclear.

Sanctuary board members tell News 12 at least 100 cats may have died in the fire while between 150 to 200 survived.

Suffolk SPCA Peace Officer Michael Cusumano says the SPCA is working with other animal rescues to coordinate the rescue efforts of the surviving cats.

"Try to find a good home for all the animals, have them safely removed, have them cared for, have them checked by a medical facility,” he said.

Back in 2016, News 12 got a look at the sanctuary.

Arsenault started caring for cats in 2007 after his son died in a motorcycle crash.

Frank Floridia, of the Strong Island Animal Rescue League, said the sanctuary was Arsenault’s life’s work.

"Chris had a great heart. He was a good guy. He dedicated his life to the animals," he said.

Other animal rescues, like Hearts of Love Cat Rescue & Adoption, also stepped in to lend a helping hand in any way they can.

"For Chris's legacy, for what he worked all his life for, to help animals,” said Dawn Donaghey, of Hearts of Love Cat Rescue & Adoption.

The sanctuary was in the process of moving cats upstate to a new location prior to the fire.

Rescue workers say Jaeger’s Run Animal Rescue, North Fork Country Kids, and Strong Island Animal Rescue are the main entities working to foster and rehabilitate the cats.

Find out how you can support their efforts and donate to the Happy Cat Sanctuary here.

More Stories

Top Stories

02:16
LI 5PMCeciliaRexNutsBoltsKK_2026-06-17-17-13-33

‘You are a coward.’ Judge sentences Gilgo Beach killer to life in prison without parole

02:00
F P2 PM 1(151)

Scattered shower and brief thunderstorm chance Thursday on Long Island

05:49
TierneyInterviewKK_2026-06-17-17-49-57

EXCLUSIVE: Suffolk DA speaks on Gilgo Beach case after Rex Heuermann sentenced to life in prison

01:51
LI 10PM WED_Teen Takeover_ajc_2026-06-17-22-10-57

Deer Park teen hospitalized after alleged assault at park as police warn of teen takeovers

02:29
LI5PMJuliaStatementsKK_2026-06-17-17-14-16

Family members deliver emotional victim impact statements during Rex Heuermann's sentencing

00:52
LI 5PM WED_JD Vance_ajc_2026-06-17-17-22-04

Vice President Vance attacks Rep. Suozzi during Nassau County visit, backs GOP challenger LiPetri

00:31
LI 10PM WED_Powder in Class_ajc_2026-06-17-22-15-07

17 students hospitalized in Roosevelt charter school chemical release

02:16
Screenshot 2026-06-17 172945

What to know ahead of the Knicks Championship Parade

01:42
LI 5PMStrawberryFestKK_2026-06-17-18-01-01

Mattituck Strawberry Festival returns for 71st year, bringing sweet treats and community support

01:26
LI 5PM WED_Attempted Kidnapping_ajc_2026-06-17-17-23-34_17-16-33,17

Man arrested after allegedly trying to steal car with 2 children inside

li10pmbol2026budgetrevotes_2026-06-16-22-29-42

Long Island 2026 school budget revote results

AP26168502462566

Luigi Mangione will assert psychiatric defense in murder case in UnitedHealthcare CEO's killing

Dad Rocks Sponsored Adventureland 2024

Is your dad awesome? Long Island tell us why your dad rocks!

02:15
617popupbagels_2026-06-17-07-51-19

PopUp Bagels opens new Westhampton Beach location

00:29
LIKIDSINCAR617_2026-06-17-05-37-55

Man arrested for trying to steal car with 2 kids inside in Brentwood

00:22
america dmv

DMV unveils license plate marking America’s 250th anniversary

01:43
617GARDENGUIDE_2026-06-17-05-52-35

Try these garden tips for your container plants to make them grow healthier and save you money

01:45
617whatscooking_2026-06-17-05-39-08

What’s Cooking: Grilled American wagyu ribeye steak

00:54
LIICECONTRACT617_2026-06-17-05-11-50

Islip Town renews contract with ICE for shooting range

01:50
RTLIBayvilleMayorWriteInElectDRodriguez1030pm_2026-06-16-22-56-48

Bayville voters write in mayoral candidates after no one files to run

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices