Taxing Long Island
News12 New York
Download the App
Where to Watch
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files
Stony Brook Medicine

'There's this and then there's the rest.' Easter shopping brings crowds to Arthur Avenue

Both customers and businesses say tradition is just as big a pull as the quality of food.

Greg Thompson

Apr 2, 2026, 5:44 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

With Easter Sunday still a few days away, crowds have already begun to fill Arthur Avenue.

"I've got to follow my mother," said Dominic Gandiosi, who had come from Long Island to shop. "She comes here and this is what we got to do. It has to be here, it has to be on Arthur Avenue, it's not Easter."

Lines formed both inside and outside many food stores on the famous stretch.

"It is the busiest time," said Anthony Biancardi, the co-owner of Biancardi's Meats. "It's like Christmas. Christmas and Easter - about the same.'

Over at Madonia Bakery, clerk Sarah Pepa said that because of the volumes of some orders, "we have to turn people away, so it's getting a little bit crazy."

Despite the long distances some traveled, many, including Pat DiPietrantonio, who lives in Florida, said shopping on Arthur Avenue for the holidays has "been part of my life."

"There's this and then there's the rest," said New Jersey resident Vinny Schiraldi. "Why not just come here, bear the traffic, find a parking spot and get what you need?"

Most stores and customers said lamb was a must-get, with cheese, breads and pastry shops also seeing big lines.

"It's a little bit of nostalgia, going back to our roots," said Tom Tomij, who came from Connecticut with multiple members of his family.

"The people, the service, the what you get, the family feel, you can't beat that," agreed Schiraldi.

Business owners said they shared the feeling, looking forward to seeing familiar faces and making new friends year after year.

"Everyone that walks through that door, they might be a stranger, but by the time they leave, they're getting a Christmas card from us," said Jerome Raguso, the owner of Gino's Pastry Shop.

"People, they love a good product, but they love a product with a good story," added Carlo Carciotto, who has taken over Casa Della Mozzarella from his father, an immigrant who started it.

With many businesses also being passed down from generations, the current owners tell News 12 that spikes in business like the ones they get during the holidays are key to keeping their parents' and grandparents' dreams alive.

"There's good, there's bad, there's snowstorms in January and you do nothing, and the holidays, you try and make it up a little bit," said Biancardi.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:53
MTNJCliftonTruckUpate0413_2026-04-13-22-26-54

Truck remains lodged in Clifton building as engineers plan complex removal

02:42
RizzoSM

Near-record high temperatures are expected today through Thursday with strong sun

01:30
Image (60)

Where did the MetLife Stadium logo go?

00:28
4142026NJtrump_2026-04-14-07-23-16

Cardinal Tobin calls Trump AI image as Jesus deeply offensive to millions of believers

00:26
AP25199640311719

Princeton University to ban electric scooters and skateboards across much of campus

00:57
crane accident

Worker dies after 'boom lift' topples off flatbed truck in Clifton

00:30
Screenshot 2026-04-14 053030

New Jersey sports legend Dick Vitale announces new cancer diagnosis, remains hopeful

00:18
EaglesBanded12p_2026-04-10-12-31-28

Bald eagle population soars from one nest to more than 250 nesting pairs across New Jersey

UESSchool

Bomb threat reported at Moorestown Upper Elementary School deemed not credible

00:37
RTNJWBerlinPDShotBodyCamVO10pm_2026-04-13-22-05-16

New video released of deadly 2025 police-involved shooting in West Berlin

01:47
REtomgoosehoboken413_2026-04-13-22-22-12

Geese, be gone! Hoboken calls in the dogs to chase away geese

02:02
REJennibears413_2026-04-13-22-23-49

Oakland family shares home with mama bear, 4 cubs

fingerprint crime scene tape

NYC man identified as victim killed in Chick-fil-A shooting 

00:43
REkurtjp413_2026-04-13-22-38-54

Jersey Proud: Hackensack High School students bring calm and color to children’s ER with art

00:29
developing copy

New law to limit how much landlords in NJ can charge for application fees

fatal crash - mon copy (1)

Lakewood teen killed, another critically injured in crash with USPS tractor-trailer in Hamilton

00:34
LI5PMBailJumperfromNJKK_2026-04-13-18-25-48

Bail jumper extradited from Colorado after he was caught while applying for corrections job

HandcuffsLights

Multiagency crackdown targets illegal ATV, dirt bike riders in Trenton area

handcuffs computer

Toms River man pleads guilty to distributing child sexual abuse material

00:21
deadly shooting

One dead, one in critical after shooting at Egg Harbor rehab facility

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices