Taxing Long Island
News12 New York
Download the App
Where to Watch
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files
Stony Brook Medicine

Sag Harbor mayor refuses to step down amid calls from board members to resign

Mayor Tom Gardella first came under fire in March when he made a controversial comment from his personal Instagram account on a post of a Texas woman, Rebecca Chavez, and her wife dancing to a song.

Tara Rincon

Apr 15, 2026, 5:14 AM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

The Sag Harbor Village Board is asking Mayor Tom Gardella to step down after an investigation into his social media activity found more concerning comments.

As News 12 has reported, Gardella came under fire last month when he made a comment from his personal Instagram account on a post of a Texas woman, Rebecca Chavez, and her wife dancing to a song.

“What’s that thing in the background? A guy a girl? Some creature?,” the Mayor wrote.

The further investigation by the board cites other activity from Gardella’s social media reported by residents, including a time when he said, “Homeless? Sag Harbor? Are you serious?? You need to see a psychiatrist,” under a post about DOGE cuts.

The Mayor publicly apologized at a village meeting after the incident in early March.

In a statement to News 12, Gardella says he has no intention of resigning.

More Stories

Top Stories

02:57
REtrainderrailment41426_2026-04-14-19-14-56

Route 3 reopens after CSX freight train derailment in North Bergen

02:26
Dave HX Record Compare

Spring sizzle: Possible record-breaking heat expected on Wednesday

00:58
Wright

Exclusive: Energy Secretary Chris Wright discusses the future of tri-state power, gas prices and the AI surge

01:57
Screenshot 2026-04-15 063105

Tractor-trailer removed after crashing into Clifton building and sparking fire

Messi Jersey Giveaway-2

American Dream to give away signed Messi jersey as part of World Cup celebration

00:17
2f4cd1aa-7d66-4031-b6b3-76a861751d31

Legislation proposed to double SALT deduction cap for married couples filing jointly

00:28
HRHUpdate8am_2026-04-15-09-03-19

Jersey City hospital withdraws shutdown application amid closure controversy

Usher Chris Brown

Usher and Chris Brown bring the 'R&B Tour' to MetLife for two-night event

02:26
Screenshot 2026-04-15 063845

Independence on Wheels: One man’s daily battle for an accessible commute

00:15
4152026NJchildinjured_2026-04-15-06-39-46

Child critically injured after crash sends car into pole in Union

00:19
Screenshot 2026-04-15 061743

Driver escapes injury after train strikes car and leaves vehicle pinned in Helmetta

00:27
FATAL ASSAULT CANDEM_2026-04-15-05-32-36

Detectives seek timeline of victim’s final days in Camden homicide case

00:22
boil water advisory

South Brunswick students told to bring water to school following main break

01:50
REjennileoniafire41426_2026-04-14-22-24-21

Leonia considers lithium-ion-battery restrictions after e-scooter fire

01:45
REchristrentonshoting41426_2026-04-14-17-36-53

5 people shot in Trenton in the last week, including 1 fatal

01:22
7bb683e9-4a2d-422d-bf18-f0c7433b73d7

Record-breaking heat expected across the tri-state Wednesday

01:36
415whatscooking_2026-04-15-07-28-07

What’s Cooking: Golden beet salad

00:40
RTNJJerseyProud04142026VO10pm_2026-04-14-22-20-38

Jersey Proud: Berkeley Heights teen pulls of 'prom-posal' on friend who works for rescue squad

00:56
MTNJTransitWorldCup0414_2026-04-14-22-29-15

Round-trip NJ Transit tickets to MetLife during World Cup will reportedly cost $100 or more

JANKOWSKI BLURRED

Garfield man tried to lure 2 children into his vehicle, prosecutor says

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices