Prosecutors: DNA shows teacher guilty of rape

Prosecutors say DNA evidence can prove the guilt of an East Setauket teacher accused of raping a bartender in February. Michael Wachholder, on leave from his job as a gym teacher at Arrowhead Elementary

News 12 Staff

Jun 16, 2009, 11:59 PM

Updated 5,515 days ago

Share:

Prosecutors say DNA evidence can prove the guilt of an East Setauket teacher accused of raping a bartender in February.
Michael Wachholder, on leave from his job as a gym teacher at Arrowhead Elementary School, was arrested for allegedly raping and attacking a female bartender in the back of Secrets Lounge in Mt. Sinai. He pleaded not guilty to the charges.
Prosecutors say a DNA profile ties Wachholder to the crime.
?The only people that have that profile are the defendant or those paternally related to him - father, brother, son, and they weren't there for this rape,? prosecutor Carl Borelli says.
Wachholder's attorney, Jim O'Rourke, had previously stated in court that the real attacker was an acquaintance of his client. However, prosecutors say their DNA profile test excludes that man.
O?Rourke says he wants an independent analysis of the DNA evidence.
Wachholder's bond was increased to $1 million because of the new evidence. He faces up to 25 years on the top charge of first-degree rape. He is due back in court June 26.


More from News 12
2:34
Pilot, passenger from Virginia identified as victims in MacArthur Airport crash

Pilot, passenger from Virginia identified as victims in MacArthur Airport crash

1:55
Warm and humid conditions today; storms possible tonight

Warm and humid conditions today; storms possible tonight

0:18
Police: 3 men wanted for stealing $6,000 worth of sunglasses in Lake Grove

Police: 3 men wanted for stealing $6,000 worth of sunglasses in Lake Grove

0:20
Big Lots to close stores nationwide, including 2 locations on Long Island

Big Lots to close stores nationwide, including 2 locations on Long Island

0:16
Riverhead police chief announces departure from department

Riverhead police chief announces departure from department

1:48
Made on Long Island: Long Island Meal Prep in West Hempstead

Made on Long Island: Long Island Meal Prep in West Hempstead

0:43
Toys for Tots Foundation helps campers celebrate Christmas in July

Toys for Tots Foundation helps campers celebrate Christmas in July

0:42
Long Island Ducks to host first ever Chicken Nugget Championship on Friday

Long Island Ducks to host first ever Chicken Nugget Championship on Friday

1:49
Democratic delegates from LI give support to VP Harris to be presidential nominee

Democratic delegates from LI give support to VP Harris to be presidential nominee

AP survey: Harris has enough delegate support to become the Democratic Party nominee

AP survey: Harris has enough delegate support to become the Democratic Party nominee

0:29
Founder of Island Harvest Linda Breitstone dies at age 73

Founder of Island Harvest Linda Breitstone dies at age 73

0:34
Town of Hempstead Councilman Chris Carini laid to rest in Farmingdale

Town of Hempstead Councilman Chris Carini laid to rest in Farmingdale

1:36
3 men face murder charges in strangulation of North Amityville man

3 men face murder charges in strangulation of North Amityville man

1:32
Long Island special needs group receives bike donation

Long Island special needs group receives bike donation

0:24
Duck Donuts to offer BOGO deal Tuesday for National Sprinkle Day

Duck Donuts to offer BOGO deal Tuesday for National Sprinkle Day

3:04
Nassau Legislature Rules Committee votes to move forward with transferring operations of Nassau Coliseum to Las Vegas Sands

Nassau Legislature Rules Committee votes to move forward with transferring operations of Nassau Coliseum to Las Vegas Sands

0:37
Annual LI golf outing raises funds for those struggling with mental health, substance abuse

Annual LI golf outing raises funds for those struggling with mental health, substance abuse

1:32
Surf session held for adults and kids with disabilities

Surf session held for adults and kids with disabilities

0:17
Police: Valley Stream man slashed woman with knife at deli

Police: Valley Stream man slashed woman with knife at deli

1:43
Long Islanders have mixed reaction to President Biden’s announcement on presidential run

Long Islanders have mixed reaction to President Biden’s announcement on presidential run