Pronoun lawsuit sparks dueling protests outside Port Jefferson Station elementary school

The lawsuit claims that a teacher in the Brookhaven-Comsewogue Union School District forced a fifth-grade girl to use male pronouns against her will.

News 12 Staff

Mar 7, 2023, 1:19 AM

Updated 412 days ago

Share:

There were dueling protests Monday outside Norwood Avenue Elementary School in Port Jefferson Station in the wake of a lawsuit that claims a fifth-grade girl was forced by a teacher to use male pronouns against her will.
The family of the student filed the lawsuit against Brookhaven-Comsewogue Union School District, which claims the girl was later bullied and expressed suicidal feelings.
In response, the district superintendent Jennifer Quinn, who is also named as a defendant in the lawsuit, wrote last week, "The district will not and cannot respond to the unproven allegations made in those reports - we will not litigate this matter in the press. What the district will do is vigorously defend itself and allow the judicial process to unfold as is appropriate."
Moms for Liberty and supporters of their cause say the child was being groomed and indoctrinated by her teacher. They say the topic of sexual and gender identity does not belong in elementary school and the teacher named in the lawsuit should be fired.
The other group of protesters were led by the LGBT Network says the teacher did everything right and should be supported.
"They're the ones indoctrinating our kids and our communities with hate and that is not OK and we're not going to allow it," says David Kilmnick, of the LGBT Network. "Not in our town, not on our Long Island, not ever."
Brianna Richardson, of Moms for Liberty, says that their cause has nothing to do with LGBT rights.
"This all has to do with the fact that children need to be protected in schools, they do not deserve to be groomed, indoctrinated or anything like that," Richardson says.
The protests took place ahead of a school board meeting that both groups attended.
During the meeting, the superintendent addressed the issue.
"I do understand there is a lot of information in the news and a lot of it is extremely serious," Quinn said. "I understand your child is the most important thing in the world. Your children are extremely important to us. That's why we're here. I'm hoping at the end of this we will at least come to an understanding."
Quinn also said just because there is a lawsuit, that does not mean the accusations are accurate.
The school district would not discuss the teacher's job status citing pending litigation.


More from News 12
0:43
Police: Illegal guns found inside Old Bethpage home; couple charged with criminal weapons possession

Police: Illegal guns found inside Old Bethpage home; couple charged with criminal weapons possession

1:55
Sunny and mild Monday for Long Island

Sunny and mild Monday for Long Island

0:21
Fire razes Mount Sinai home

Fire razes Mount Sinai home

0:48
Nonprofit environmental group hosts discussion on climate change at Jones Beach event

Nonprofit environmental group hosts discussion on climate change at Jones Beach event

0:24
Prosecutors: Bellport man pleads guilty to hit-and-run that seriously injured pedestrian

Prosecutors: Bellport man pleads guilty to hit-and-run that seriously injured pedestrian

1:08
Oldest Men’s Senior Baseball League player honors surgeon who saved his career

Oldest Men’s Senior Baseball League player honors surgeon who saved his career

Matt Rempe and Rangers’ fourth line comes up big in Game 1

Matt Rempe and Rangers’ fourth line comes up big in Game 1

1:17
Annual ‘Spring Dust Off’ car show to take place in Point Lookout

Annual ‘Spring Dust Off’ car show to take place in Point Lookout

1:56
Authorities: Nassau County police officer attacked by 2 men, pit bull in East Rockaway

Authorities: Nassau County police officer attacked by 2 men, pit bull in East Rockaway

0:36
Southampton police: Man arrested in Riverside machete attack that injured 24-year-old

Southampton police: Man arrested in Riverside machete attack that injured 24-year-old

1:10
Lawmakers in Albany pass $237 billion state budget, restore school funding

Lawmakers in Albany pass $237 billion state budget, restore school funding

0:28
Man who set himself on fire outside Trump trial dies of injuries, police say

Man who set himself on fire outside Trump trial dies of injuries, police say

Knicks beat 76ers 111-104 in Game 1 of playoffs. Brunson and Hart score 22 points and backups star

Knicks beat 76ers 111-104 in Game 1 of playoffs. Brunson and Hart score 22 points and backups star

Andersen, Noesen help Hurricanes push past Islanders 3-1 to open 1st-round NHL playoff series

Andersen, Noesen help Hurricanes push past Islanders 3-1 to open 1st-round NHL playoff series

0:42
'A Dream Prom Boutique' ensures Nassau high schoolers have prom of their dreams

'A Dream Prom Boutique' ensures Nassau high schoolers have prom of their dreams

0:43
Huntington’s Blue Line Deli & Bagels gives away free bagels to customers ahead of Islanders postseason

Huntington’s Blue Line Deli & Bagels gives away free bagels to customers ahead of Islanders postseason

0:18
Car crashes into back of oil truck in Long Beach

Car crashes into back of oil truck in Long Beach

0:19
Authorities: RV catches fire at park in Shirley

Authorities: RV catches fire at park in Shirley

0:28
Police: Levittown woman arrested for driving drunk with 2 children in vehicle

Police: Levittown woman arrested for driving drunk with 2 children in vehicle

2:05
Long Island native ID’d as person who set himself on fire outside Trump trial in Manhattan

Long Island native ID’d as person who set himself on fire outside Trump trial in Manhattan