Family of Gilgo Beach victim hopes arrest of suspect is beginning of closure

The cousin of Jessica Taylor says the arrest of Rex Heuermann in three of the Gilgo murders gives her hope for long-awaited justice.

News 12 Staff

Jul 14, 2023, 9:15 PM

Updated 272 days ago

Share:

The families of the Gilgo Beach victims have been waiting for answers and an arrest for over a decade. They finally are now a step closer to closure.
Police officers arrested Rex Heuermann in three of the murders Wednesday night in New York City. He has been charged with first- and second-degree murder in the deaths of three Gilgo victims: Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman and Amber Costello.
Jessica Taylor, 20, was also among the Gilgo Beach bodies. Her torso was found in a wooded area in Manorville on July 26, 2003.
Additional remains of Taylor were discovered on March 29, 2011, along Ocean Parkway.
Her cousin, Jasmine Robinson, has spent two decades praying for an arrest in the case. She says the arrest of Heuermann gives her hope for long-awaited justice.
“I just want to say that I’m grateful for the hard work that’s been done,” Robinson says. “I’m grateful that today is happening.”
Robinson is now urging police to press on with the investigation of the Gilgo Beach murders and ultimately bring her cousin’s killer to justice.
WATCH: DOCUMENTARY AND BACKGROUND INFORMATION - Gilgo Beach: Unsolved
“I’m fighting for her because she can’t fight for herself,” Robinson says.
Robinson and her attorney, John Ray, say Friday’s arrest is just the beginning and gives them hope that there will be closure for all of the Gilgo victims and their families.


More from News 12
1:18
Half Hollow Hills School District parent arrested for making threat of mass harm against district

Half Hollow Hills School District parent arrested for making threat of mass harm against district

1:51
Partly sunny skies with spotty showers this afternoon; shower chance for the weekend

Partly sunny skies with spotty showers this afternoon; shower chance for the weekend

1:08
Police: Woman injured after shots fired into home in Mastic Beach

Police: Woman injured after shots fired into home in Mastic Beach

Police: Bronx man arrested for stealing over $12,000 in merchandise from multiple Home Depots in Nassau

Police: Bronx man arrested for stealing over $12,000 in merchandise from multiple Home Depots in Nassau

0:24
Police: Amityville man arrested for identity theft

Police: Amityville man arrested for identity theft

0:47
Long Island Restaurant Week: Lake View Grill, Legends, Dimon Estate

Long Island Restaurant Week: Lake View Grill, Legends, Dimon Estate

1:12
The East End: Take a tour of the The Shoppes at East Wind

The East End: Take a tour of the The Shoppes at East Wind

1:37
The Real Deal: How to save the next time you dine out

The Real Deal: How to save the next time you dine out

It's National Grilled Cheese Sandwich Day!

It's National Grilled Cheese Sandwich Day!

Guide: Long Island Public Golf Courses

Guide: Long Island Public Golf Courses

1:37
Exclusive: String of car thefts reported in North Babylon, West Babylon

Exclusive: String of car thefts reported in North Babylon, West Babylon

1:52
Police: Manager of La Perla Restaurant in Riverhead arrested following drug bust

Police: Manager of La Perla Restaurant in Riverhead arrested following drug bust

2:29
Multiple independent audits document a pattern of fiscal distress at Amityville schools

Multiple independent audits document a pattern of fiscal distress at Amityville schools

0:29
Suffolk DA: Bay Shore man, Central Islip woman indicted on sex trafficking, related charges

Suffolk DA: Bay Shore man, Central Islip woman indicted on sex trafficking, related charges

1:18
Servicemembers reunited with puppies they rescued overseas at Paws of War headquarters

Servicemembers reunited with puppies they rescued overseas at Paws of War headquarters

1:36
Caught on camera: Man stole package from delivery person at Babylon house

Caught on camera: Man stole package from delivery person at Babylon house

1:24
Police: Mother arrested for leaving 2 children unattended in a car near the Green Acres Mall

Police: Mother arrested for leaving 2 children unattended in a car near the Green Acres Mall

1:50
LIA Foundation, Optimum team up to support local small businesses

LIA Foundation, Optimum team up to support local small businesses

0:27
Police: Babylon man pointed gun at teen and his father

Police: Babylon man pointed gun at teen and his father

0:44
Long Island Restaurant Week: Carpaccio, Piccolo Ristorante, Stella Trattoria and Bar

Long Island Restaurant Week: Carpaccio, Piccolo Ristorante, Stella Trattoria and Bar