Outside counsel warned Oyster Bay officials against backing Singh’s loans

<p>Former Oyster Bay Deputy Town Attorney Fred Mei testified Wednesday that it was former Oyster Bay Town Supervisor John Venditto&rsquo;s idea to use the town&rsquo;s credit worthiness to back Harendra Singh&rsquo;s personal loans.</p>

News 12 Staff

Apr 18, 2018, 4:02 PM

Updated 2,221 days ago

Share:

Jonathan Sinnreich, who serves as the Town of Oyster Bay’s outside legal counsel, testified in the Mangano-Venditto corruption trial Wednesday that he told town officials on multiple occasions that a municipality cannot legally provide a guarantee for a personal loan.
Sinnreich says Oyster Bay's 2010 plan to guarantee a $1.5 million loan for restaurateur Harendra Singh was "grossly illegal and inappropriate" and says he warned of the public embarrassment the town could face if Singh defaulted on the loan.
Sinnreich told prosecutors that he relayed his concerns in writing to former Deputy Town Attorney Fred Mei, and verbally to then-Town Supervisor John Venditto and then-Deputy Supervisor Len Genova. 
"I thought it was clearly unconstitutional and legally could not be done," Sinnreich testified.
In a February 2010 email presented as evidence, Sinnreich writes to Mei that he can't endorse any plan that provides a guarantee, and in turn leaves the town financially responsible for Singh's personal loan repayment.
"You know that, if I could, I would try to find a way to bless this deal, but I just can't do it," the email states.
Later in the month, he writes to Mei and Genova about his concern that a Singh default would leave the town, and by extension, its taxpayers on the hook.
"How could we ever explain or justify the loss of public funds?" he wrote.
Mei testified Wednesday that using the town’s creditworthiness to benefit Singh’s personal loans was “John Venditto's idea." 
Mei and Singh both testified that after Sinnreich refused to back the plan, the town brought in attorneys from the law firm Rivkin Radler to develop a workaround of the state law. Singh ultimately got that first town-backed loan, and many more in the years to come – totaling more than $20 million. In 2016, the town was forced to raise taxes by more than 11 percent after its credit rating sunk to junk bond status following Singh's arrest.
Sinnreich says it wasn't clear what the town was actually getting in exchange for backing Singh's loan. He says Mei told him that Singh would cater something called the “Supervisor's golf outing.”
Sinnreich called the idea of the catering job serving as a justification for backing the loan "ridiculous." He returns to the stand Thursday.


More from News 12
2:28
How did a Nassau County doctor overprescribe highly addictive pain pills, despite strict laws in place?

How did a Nassau County doctor overprescribe highly addictive pain pills, despite strict laws in place?

1:56
Mostly cloudy Saturday; sunshine returns this week

Mostly cloudy Saturday; sunshine returns this week

0:26
Principal: Student approached by van full of men in ski masks in Selden

Principal: Student approached by van full of men in ski masks in Selden

2:06
Homeowners asked to check home security video after string of Nassau County break-ins

Homeowners asked to check home security video after string of Nassau County break-ins

1:58
Montauk Music Festival rocks the East End

Montauk Music Festival rocks the East End

0:51
Plainview-Old Bethpage hosts basketball team from Israel impacted by Oct. 7 attacks

Plainview-Old Bethpage hosts basketball team from Israel impacted by Oct. 7 attacks

1:24
Nassau County high school seniors take part in aerial simulation exercise

Nassau County high school seniors take part in aerial simulation exercise

1:53
Toys for Tots make contribution to Promise of Hope Foundation to honor fallen Detective Jonathan Diller

Toys for Tots make contribution to Promise of Hope Foundation to honor fallen Detective Jonathan Diller

0:24
Police: Hempstead man exposed, touched himself inappropriately at Roosevelt Field Mall

Police: Hempstead man exposed, touched himself inappropriately at Roosevelt Field Mall

2:29
Museum of American Armor hosting 10th anniversary of World War II Encampment weekend

Museum of American Armor hosting 10th anniversary of World War II Encampment weekend

0:40
Town of Hempstead launches rain barrel pilot program in five town parks

Town of Hempstead launches rain barrel pilot program in five town parks

1:55
12-year-old prodigy set to become Malverne High School’s youngest graduate

12-year-old prodigy set to become Malverne High School’s youngest graduate

0:24
Police: 2 men arrested for stealing copper wire, burglarizing Jericho business

Police: 2 men arrested for stealing copper wire, burglarizing Jericho business

0:23
FDA approves first self-test for cervical cancer

FDA approves first self-test for cervical cancer

1:08
East End: Kick off party to the summer showcasing the beauty of the region

East End: Kick off party to the summer showcasing the beauty of the region

1:07
The East End: Calissa in Water Mill

The East End: Calissa in Water Mill

1:36
The Real Deal: How to navigate the buying, renting market in New York

The Real Deal: How to navigate the buying, renting market in New York

1:19
Nassau County doctor convicted of illegally prescribing around 93,000 mg of oxycodone to 1 patient

Nassau County doctor convicted of illegally prescribing around 93,000 mg of oxycodone to 1 patient

1:44
Massapequa couple latest to be charged in connection with Jan. 6 Capitol riot

Massapequa couple latest to be charged in connection with Jan. 6 Capitol riot

0:30
 Police: Deer Park teen charged after making threats, bringing BB gun to Frost Middle School

Police: Deer Park teen charged after making threats, bringing BB gun to Frost Middle School