Taxing Long Island
News12 New York
Download the App
Where to Watch
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files
Stony Brook Medicine
LIRR Strike?

Police: Suspect arrested in deadly Shirley hit-and-run

According to police, the crash occurred as two men from Mastic Beach parked their car on the side of William Floyd Parkway.

Logan Crawford

Jan 31, 2026, 9:10 AM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Police say a man has been arrested in connection with a Shirley hit-and-run that left one person dead and another injured on Thursday night.

According to police, two men from Mastic Beach parked their car on the side of the busy William Floyd Parkway in a narrow shoulder to change a flat tire just before 7 p.m.

Investigators say 51-year-old Jonathan Shaver, of Rocky Point, crashed his black Honda into their vehicle before fleeing the scene.

The incident happened during one of the busiest times of the day for this road as Long Islanders drove home from work.

Police say Edgar Mejia, 31, was pronounced dead at the scene. His brother, Omar, was rushed to Stony Brook University hospital in critical condition.

According to court records, Shaver pleaded not guilty at his arraignment Saturday in First District Court in Central Islip. His bail was set at $50,000 cash, $100,000 insured bond or $250,000 partially secured surety bond.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:55
nwesink

Lanes reopen as crews work to repair sinkhole on LIE in Melville

02:56
FP Weekend

Partly sunny today with a summer feel for Long Island this weekend

00:33
LIKIDNAPINDICT515_2026-05-15-05-11-41

Man indicted for kidnapping 4-year-old from Patchogue laundromat

03:01
DJI 20260515054859 0006 D

Extremely limited LIRR service to Penn Station as Amtrak crews make repairs following fire near terminal

02:51
515lirrinterview_2026-05-15-06-40-13

Still no agreement between MTA, LIRR unions as strike deadline looms

01:56
515braintumorstory_2026-05-15-07-35-19

Southampton woman turns brain tumor diagnosis into mission to help others

00:32
LIMEASLESUPDATE515_2026-05-15-05-40-44

Nassau restaurant that served customer with measles reopens

00:49
515eastendreal_2026-05-15-06-31-35

The East End: J & S Reeve Cottages

00:19
LIGCFERRY515_2026-05-15-05-52-44

Glen Cove to let NYC Water Taxi use ferry terminal in case of LIRR strike

01:54
LIRR Poss. Strike MS 051426_2026-05-14-17-42-13_17-04-45,01

MTA’s shuttle‑bus backup plan could add an hour to commutes, test run shows

01:31
Teen Car Chase MS 051426_2026-05-14-17-10-28

Prosecutors: 15-year-old charged with attempted murder after high-speed chase through Port Washington and Manhasset

01:30
LI 5PM THURS_CareUnhoused_ajc_2026-05-14-17-19-55

‘They treat me like family’: Northwell Health's Street Medicine Team brings hope to Long Island’s unhoused

01:30
LI 5PM THURS_VFW_ajc_2026-05-14-17-12-31

East End American Legion hopes to expand membership and continue renovations

lirrLI5WA_2025-09-16-19-10-17

LIRR strike imminent: How to navigate your commute

02:24
Shakira

FIFA announces Super Bowl-style World Cup final halftime show featuring Madonna, Shakira and BTS

00:24
Screenshot 2026-05-14 122153

NYU Langone subpoenaed for information on transgender youth

01:39
dji mimo 20260514 060506 20260514060506 1778753167330 photo

Long Island Rail Road strike could put strain on our already busy roads

00:21
BUS CRASH

6 children onboard bus crash in Plainview, no injuries reported

00:34
513burglaryli_2026-05-13-12-06-33

North Valley Stream home ransacked while owner enjoys family vacation

01:06
LI 5PM WED_Gary Lawrence_ajc_2026-05-13-17-24-06

Jury finds Gary Lawrence not guilty in his second murder trial

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices