News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys
Showers
61°
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys

‘Like a scene from Criminal Minds’: Neighbors of Gilgo Beach killings suspect shocked by the arrest

Locals told News 12 that they are riveted by the new developments.

News 12 Staff

•

Jul 15, 2023, 5:48 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Neighbors of accused Gilgo Beach killer Rex Heuermann have been left shocked by his arrest in the infamous cold case.

The 59-year-old was arrested in New York City on Thursday, more than a year after a police task force explored his possible connection to the crimes.

Prosecutors say DNA evidence and cellphone data point to the architect and father of two as a suspect in the murders of Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman and Amber Costello.

Authorities say he is also the prime suspect in the 2007 disappearance and death of a fourth woman, Maureen Brainard-Barnes.

Heuermann’s house on 1st Avenue in Massapequa Park remains an active crime scene as law enforcement officials continue carrying out boxes filled with his belongings.

Locals told News 12 that they are riveted by the new developments.

“It looks like a scene from a movie like 'Criminal Minds.' It's right here. So crazy,” said resident Paige Pagano.

“He's some sick guy if it's true,” said Louise Colle.

Plainedge resident Juliana Hagmaier was 10 years old when the first body was unearthed along Ocean Parkway in 2010.

“I remember never being able to go to Gilgo because my parents were nervous,” she said.

Onlookers in Massapequa Park say they hope the arrest will give the victim’s families a long-awaited sense of closure.

“I'm just happy that there's finally going to be accountability and people are not just wondering who's next,” said Bay Shore resident Mayda Vargas.

RELATED: Family of Gilgo Beach victim hopes arrest of suspect is beginning of closure

Top Stories

00:35
LIhicksvilleincidentkk_2026-11-22-08-25-32

Multiple people sprayed with unknown substance in Hicksville

01:39
LI THUMB

STORM WATCH: A coastal storm brushes by tonight, another storm arrives on Thanksgiving

AP26326613179542

Issue with automation system causes Delta flight delays

00:28
li12pmbolsmithtownmotorcyclecrash_2026-11-22-12-09-55

Smithtown man seriously injured after crash ejects him from motorcycle

00:40
925925960 4511392052410961 5635118598767585566 n

Crash into utility pole brings down wires, sparks brush fire in Riverhead

02:09
RTLIHuntingtonBudgetLatestJRGaertner1030pm_2026-11-21-22-39-06

Huntington budget approved by default after board members miss meeting

00:35
LIbillyjoelbikekk_2026-11-22-06-34-56

Billy Joel's 'Madison Square Garden' Triumph fetches $577K at auction, over 50 times estimate

AP26324782783218

Roundup weed killer cancer claims lead to court-approved $7.25B settlement

01:18
image

FBI investigating possible hack of major criminal justice database

00:28
LIrockypointraidkk_2026-11-22-06-34-41

Patchogue woman arrested in Rocky Point massage parlor raid following community complaints

00:28
Pedestrian killed

Pedestrian struck and killed on LIE in Manorville

00:15
ShootingArrest

4 men arrested following shooting in Mastic

00:27
underage drinking arrest beer police car lights OTS copy

Flanders man seen swerving on Hampton Bays road charged with DWAI

00:21
GENERIC POLICE LIGHTS

Vape bandit sought in South Farmingdale smoke shop burglary

00:08
student loans

New York State opens applications for 2 student loan forgiveness programs

01:32
NCC Stabbing Arrest MS 112026_2026-11-20-17-05-23

Police say gang-related attack led to stabbing inside Nassau Community College cafeteria

01:23
LI 10PM FRI_Holiday Lights Jones_ajc_2026-11-20-22-09-08

Magic of Lights returns to Jones Beach, bringing holiday displays and family fun

01:33
LI 5PM FRI_Adoption_ajc_2026-11-20-17-41-57

Ten children officially adopted at the National Adoption Day Celebration at Long Island Aquarium

00:30
LI 5PM FRI_ ICE  LAWSUIT_ajc_2026-11-20-17-43-47

Nassau County joins lawsuit challenging Hochul's ICE cooperation ban

01:52
taracollapse1120_2026-11-20-16-54-08

NYC excavation oversight examined following Brooklyn building collapse

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices