Guide: Theater shows on Long Island

Do you want to see a theater show but don't want to travel into New York City? Look no further. Here is a guide for some shows playing on Long Island. Please check with the theater before heading out. Dates and times are subject to change.
NOTE: COVID-19 guidelines and protocols, such as masks or vaccine requirements, maybe in place. Please check with the theaters ahead of time.

UPCOMING SHOWS

Jan. 14-Feb. 4
The Sweet Deliah Swim Club

Theatre Three
412 Main St.
Port Jefferson
More Information 
Jan. 14-Feb. 19
Rocky

Cultural Arts Playhouse
170 Michael Drive
Syosset
More Information
Jan. 19-March 5
Dirty Rotten Scoundrels

John W. Engeman Theater
250 Main St.
Northport
More Information 
Jan. 27-Feb. 26
The Wedding Singer

The Gateway Performing Arts Center
215 South Country Road
Bellport
More Information
Feb. 3-19
Moon Over Buffalo

Studio Theatre’s Bayway Arts Center
265 E. Main St.
East Islip
More Information
Feb. 9-April 2
West Side Story

Argyle Theatre
Babylon
More Information 
Feb. 15-18
Branching Out

The Tilles Center
720 Northern Blvd.
Greenvale
More Information 
Feb. 18-March 18
Side by Side by Sondheim

Theatre Three
412 Main St.
Port Jefferson
More Information
Feb. 20-26
Cinderella

The Showplace at Bellmore Movies
222 Pettit Ave.
Bellmore
More Information
Feb. 22-25
Cinderella

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information
March 4-April 2
Ragtime The Musical

Cultural Arts Playhouse
170 Michael Drive
Syosset
More Information 
March 11-19
The Cat in the Hat

The Showplace at Bellmore Movies
222 Pettit Ave.
Bellmore
More Information
March 16-April 30
The Scarlet Pimpernel

John W. Engeman Theater
250 Main St.
Northport
More Information 
March 17-April 16
Clue

The Gateway Performing Arts Center
215 South Country Road
Bellport
More Information
March 18-April 2
Forever Plaid

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information
March 25-April 1
The Cat in the Hat

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information 
April 7-May 6
Pride & Prejudice 

Theatre Three
412 Main St.
Port Jefferson
More Information 
April 8
Winnie the Pooh

The Tilles Center
720 Northern Blvd.
Greenvale
More Information 
April 12
The Wizard of Oz

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information 
April 14-16
The Wizard of Oz

The Showplace at Bellmore Movies
222 Pettit Ave.
Bellmore
More Information 
April 27-June 18
Rock of Ages

Argyle Theatre
Babylon
More Information
May 18-June 2
The Sound of Music

John W. Engeman Theater
250 Main St.
Northport
More Information 
May 20-June 4
Mama Mia!

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information 
May 20-June 24
Something Rotten

Theatre Three
412 Main St.
Port Jefferson
More Information
July 6-Aug. 27
Grease

Argyle Theatre
Babylon
More Information 
July 13-Aug. 27
Jimmy Buffett’s Escape to Margaritaville

John W. Engeman Theater
250 Main St.
Northport
More Information
Did we miss your favorite show or theater? Click here and let us know!

PAST SHOWS

Nov. 11-12
Fiddler on the Roof

The Tilles Center
720 Northern Blvd.
Greenvale
More Information
Nov. 11-13
Willy Wonka

The Showplace at Bellmore Movies
222 Pettit Ave.
Bellmore
More Information
Nov. 4-Nov. 20
The Addams Family Musical

Studio Theatre’s Bayway Arts Center
265 E. Main St.
East Islip
More Information
Nov. 26
Willy Wonka

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information
Nov. 19-Dec. 4
Grumpy Old Men The Musical

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information
Dec. 10
Legally Blonde - The Musical

The Tilles Center
720 Northern Blvd.
Greenvale
More Information
Dec. 10-11
Jack Frost

The Showplace at Bellmore Movies
222 Pettit Ave.
Bellmore
More Information
Nov. 18-Dec. 18
Scrooge the Musical
Manes Studio Theatre of Long Island
141 S. Wellwood Ave.
Lindenhurst
More Information
Nov. 19-Dec. 18
The Wizard of Oz

CM Performing Arts Center
Oakdale
More Information 
Dec. 3-17
Jack Frost

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information
Dec. 17
Scrooge

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information  
Dec. 17-18
The Nutcracker

The Tilles Center
720 Northern Blvd.
Greenvale
More Information
Dec. 18
Scrooge

The Showplace at Bellmore Movies
222 Pettit Ave.
Bellmore
More Information
Dec. 17-23
Elf

Madison Theater at Molloy University
1000 Hempstead Ave.
Rockville Centre
More Information
Dec. 16-28
A Christmas Carol

The Gateway Performing Arts Center
215 South Country Road
Bellport
More Information
Dec. 27-29
Disney’s Beauty & the Beast

The Showplace at Bellmore Movies
222 Pettit Ave.
Bellmore
More Information
Nov. 12-Dec. 30
A Christmas Carol

Theatre Three
412 Main St.
Port Jefferson
More Information
Nov. 10-Jan. 1, 2023
Beauty & the Beast

Argyle Theatre
Babylon
More Information
Nov. 17-Jan. 1, 2023
A Christmas Story

John W. Engeman Theater
250 Main St.
Northport
More Information
Dec. 30-31
Disney’s Beauty & the Beast

Plaza Elmont
700 Hempstead Turnpike
Elmont
More Information
Jan. 6-Jan. 22
Nunsense

Studio Theatre's Bayway Arts Center
265 E. Main St.
East Islip
More Information