Police: Inwood man threatened to open fire at Yeshiva children’s camp

Nicola Pelle has been charged with making a terroristic threat, four counts of criminal possession of a weapon, and two counts of criminal possession of a firearm.

News 12 Staff

Aug 18, 2020, 3:51 PM

Updated 1,367 days ago

Share:

Police say an Inwood man in possession of multiple guns has been arrested and accused of making a terroristic threat toward a Yeshiva children's camp.
Police say the call was made by 58-year-old Nicola Pelle, of Inwood, who claimed about 500 students were not wearing masks. While police were en route to the call, they say Pelle called again and threatened to get a gun and shoot the individuals at the location if the police didn't get there.
Nassau Police Commissioner Patrick Ryder says Pelle said, "If I've got to go out there with a friggin' machine gun and shoot all these people, I will."
During the investigation, the defendant identified himself as the caller and he was placed under arrest without incident.
Following the arrest, police say Pelle was found to possess a valid Nassau County pistol permit, five handguns, rifles and shotguns which included two assault weapons. Ryder says one gun was illegal under state law. All weapons were seized as evidence.
Pelle was arraigned on charges including making a terroristic threat, four counts of criminal possession of a weapon, and two counts of criminal possession of a firearm. Bail was set at $10,000 bond or $5,000 cash.
In a strange twist, within an hour of returning home after posting bail, Pelle was taken away in an ambulance.
Neighbors and friends say Pelle has had lung surgery because of lung cancer. One neighbor says he is on oxycodone, which has made him "not himself."
 
 


More from News 12
2:07
Nassau County doctor convicted of illegally prescribing around 93,000 mg of oxycodone to 1 patient

Nassau County doctor convicted of illegally prescribing around 93,000 mg of oxycodone to 1 patient

1:37
Partly sunny Friday; warmer temps to kick off next week

Partly sunny Friday; warmer temps to kick off next week

1:44
Massapequa couple latest to be charged in connection with Jan. 6 Capitol riot

Massapequa couple latest to be charged in connection with Jan. 6 Capitol riot

New York Rangers beat Carolina Hurricanes 5-3 to advance to Eastern Conference Final

New York Rangers beat Carolina Hurricanes 5-3 to advance to Eastern Conference Final

0:36
Commack man takes stand in civil trial claiming he was strip-searched by Suffolk police

Commack man takes stand in civil trial claiming he was strip-searched by Suffolk police

1:39
Long Islanders take part in No Mow May to help lawns flourish, aid early season pollinators

Long Islanders take part in No Mow May to help lawns flourish, aid early season pollinators

2:04
Food Pantry on NCC campus sees surge following shutdown of cafeteria

Food Pantry on NCC campus sees surge following shutdown of cafeteria

1:10
Blood drive held in honor of former Patchogue fire chief exceeds expectations

Blood drive held in honor of former Patchogue fire chief exceeds expectations

0:38
Environmental experts come together to address water concerns on Long Island

Environmental experts come together to address water concerns on Long Island

0:39
Suffolk Water Authority urges water conservation ahead of summer months

Suffolk Water Authority urges water conservation ahead of summer months

0:53
Copiague LIRR station now fully ADA accessible

Copiague LIRR station now fully ADA accessible

0:31
Police: 20-year-old Brooklyn driver dead following crash on Meadowbrook Parkway

Police: 20-year-old Brooklyn driver dead following crash on Meadowbrook Parkway

2:20
Suffolk police: 17 people arrested in one week during Operation Smoke Out

Suffolk police: 17 people arrested in one week during Operation Smoke Out

5:35
Road Trip Close to Home hits the 200 episode milestone!

Road Trip Close to Home hits the 200 episode milestone!

0:23
2 men arrested for selling tobacco products to minors in Levittown

2 men arrested for selling tobacco products to minors in Levittown

0:30
Medford man convicted of transporting 3 people who crossed into U.S. illegally

Medford man convicted of transporting 3 people who crossed into U.S. illegally

0:19
4 people wanted for stealing over $5,000 of merchandise from Macy's

4 people wanted for stealing over $5,000 of merchandise from Macy's

0:30
New screening can identify preeclampsia risk sooner in pregnancy

New screening can identify preeclampsia risk sooner in pregnancy

4:12
The East End: Explore the North Fork on 2 wheels via East End Bike Tours

The East End: Explore the North Fork on 2 wheels via East End Bike Tours

1:57
Get inspired with a visit to the Heckscher Museum of Arts

Get inspired with a visit to the Heckscher Museum of Arts