News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Taxing Long Island
Mostly Cloudy Night
74°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Taxing Long Island

Body of 1 of 2 missing kayakers recovered in Shinnecock Bay

Two kayaks were found in the Marsh early Sunday morning.

Bob Doda

and

Roberto Torres

Nov 2, 2025, 10:08 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Southampton police say they recovered the body of one of the two kayakers who had gone missing Saturday in Shinnecock Bay.

According to a release by the police department, the body of 27-year-old Shane Garcia was found after New York State Police and the Southampton Town Marine Patrol Units had located "an area of interest" during their search on Sunday.

The search for the second missing kayaker, Aaron Montemarano, will resume early Monday morning, the department said.

Garcia was reported missing by his girlfriend “who stated he had gone kayaking earlier in the day and had not returned.”

Officers found his work van parked at the end of Shinnecock Avenue in Hampton Bays.

According to an earlier release by Southampton police:

“Mr. Garcia sent a picture to his girlfriend of himself and his friend Aaron Montemarano while kayaking in Shinnecock Bay near Ponquogue Bridge. A search of Shinnecock Bay and the surrounding area yielded negative results...Mr. Montemarano is believed to have been in the company of Mr. Garcia at the time he went missing.”

A U.S. Coast Guard boat crew actively searched the area on Sunday with partner agencies.

“It was reported that local responders located two kayaks and a debris field in the marsh area earlier this morning,” a Coast Guard spokesperson said in a statement to News 12.

Anyone with information is urged to call Southampton Town Police Department Detective Division at 631-728-3400 or the tip hotline at 631-728-3454 | crimetips@southamptontownny.gov.

Top Stories

00:48
2bayshore

Bay Shore High School art teacher arrested for allegedly stalking former student he had sexual relationship with

01:35
F P1 PM 1

Scattered showers and brief thunderstorm remain possible into early Friday morning

01:52
LIDaniellaScamArtistKK_2026-09-03-17-42-57

Queens woman accused of posing as a police officer from India to scam Hicksville woman out of nearly $1M

01:23
edromainescreengrabCM_2026-09-03-18-18-11

Suffolk County Executive Ed Romaine delivers 2026 State of the County address

01:46
Dealership Damage MS 090326_2026-09-03-22-08-47

Driver crashes through Medford car dealership to steal another vehicle

01:35
Coach Hit Kid MS 090326_2026-09-03-17-10-15

Youth football coach charged after alleged assault of child at MetLife Stadium

01:58
Flock MS 090326_2026-09-03-17-11-09

Flock Safety no-show at Suffolk public safety meeting

00:29
LILevittownEvictionKK_2026-09-03-17-22-51

Man arrested after hourslong barricade situation in Levittown

01:58
Liver Donation MS 090326_2026-09-03-17-24-45

Former News 12 reporter finds living liver donor after desperate call for help

00:34
93024LIHEMPSTEADSTABBING5_2024-09-30-17-07-12

DA: Glen Cove man admits killing mother-in-law after she left daughter's birthday celebration

00:24
former office indicted

Former NYPD officer from Valley Stream accused of injuring woman in hit-and-run

00:29
93hofstra_2026-09-03-12-15-08

Hofstra University union members review summary of agreement as deadline looms

00:29
Molloy Life Saver MS 050426_2026-05-04-17-18-47

Molloy University makes Time Magazine’s best colleges in the nation list

01:08
93footballnoon_2026-09-03-12-09-45

Port Jefferson granted special hearing with Section XI over varsity football program

00:36
CREDIT: AP Photo/Manu Fernandez

Gloria Steinem, a potent voice of US feminism and co-founder of Ms. Magazine, has died

04:05
ATLANTIC SEASON

Could the Atlantic have NO hurricanes for the first time on record?

00:24
drowning

Man found dead after going for swim off Shelter Island hotel dock

00:25
BURGLARY

Man wanted for entering building through underground tunnels, stealing keys

01:40
93LIroadtrip_2026-09-03-07-01-09

Walk through history at Sagtikos Manor in Bay Shore

02:05
93taxingLI_2026-09-03-06-54-20

New study shows spike in tourist spending on Long Island

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices