• Haunted Tri-State
  • Taxing Long Island
  • News 12 New York
  • Download the App
  • Where to Watch
  • Vote 2025
  • Local
  • Crime
  • Weather
  • beWell
  • Crime Files
  • The East End
  • Stony Brook Medicine
Sunny
49°
  • Vote 2025
  • Local
  • Crime
  • Weather
  • beWell
  • Crime Files
  • The East End
  • Stony Brook Medicine

Main

  • Vote 2025
  • Local
  • Crime
  • Weather
  • beWell
  • Crime Files
  • The East End
  • Stony Brook Medicine

News

  • Consumer
  • Crime
  • Education
  • Environment
  • Long Island Events
  • Immigration
  • Local
  • Power & Politics
  • Sports
  • Weather

Sections

  • Stony Brook Medicine
  • School Closings/Delays
  • Long Island Birthday Smiles
  • Food & Fun
  • What's Cooking
  • Garden Guide
  • Just Married on Long Island
  • Hometown Heroes on Long Island
  • Long Island Honor Roll
  • Made on Long Island
  • Scholar Athlete
  • Noticias Univision 41
  • Numbers & Links
  • Kane in Your Corner
  • Team 12 Investigates
  • Turn to Tara
  • The Cost Of
  • Taxing Long Island

Choose Your Region

  • The Bronx
  • Brooklyn
  • Connecticut
  • Hudson Valley
  • Long Island
  • New Jersey
  • Westchester

Be the first to know

Topics you care about, straight to your inbox

Your email address

Main

  • Vote 2025
  • Local
  • Crime
  • Weather
  • beWell
  • Crime Files
  • The East End
  • Stony Brook Medicine

News

  • Consumer
  • Crime
  • Education
  • Environment
  • Long Island Events
  • Immigration
  • Local
  • Power & Politics
  • Sports
  • Weather

Sections

  • Stony Brook Medicine
  • School Closings/Delays
  • Long Island Birthday Smiles
  • Food & Fun
  • What's Cooking
  • Garden Guide
  • Just Married on Long Island
  • Hometown Heroes on Long Island
  • Long Island Honor Roll
  • Made on Long Island
  • Scholar Athlete
  • Noticias Univision 41
  • Numbers & Links
  • Kane in Your Corner
  • Team 12 Investigates
  • Turn to Tara
  • The Cost Of
  • Taxing Long Island

Default

Be the first to know

Topics you care about, straight to your inbox

Your email address
  • Haunted Tri-State
  • Taxing Long Island
  • News 12 New York
  • Download the App
  • Where to Watch

Gilgo Beach: Secrets in the Sand - How police say a pizza crust led to a break in the Gilgo Beach cold case

Eleven bodies buried at a local beach. See how police say a pizza crust led to a break in an infamous cold case.

News 12 Staff

•

Nov 17, 2023, 7:12 PM

•

Updated 702 days ago

Share:

More Stories

2:06
Crime Files: Sins of a Serial Killer

Crime Files: Sins of a Serial Killer

147ds ago

0:58
Massacre in the Mansion

Massacre in the Mansion

160ds ago

1:39
'Blood & Betrayal: The Nathan Carman Case'

'Blood & Betrayal: The Nathan Carman Case'

174ds ago

1:35
'Blood & Providence: Shootout in Jersey City'

'Blood & Providence: Shootout in Jersey City'

181ds ago

0:50
Compulsion to Kill: The Charles Cullen Murders

Compulsion to Kill: The Charles Cullen Murders

195ds ago

1:26
Twisted Justice: The Josette Wright Story

Twisted Justice: The Josette Wright Story

202ds ago
2:06
Crime Files: Sins of a Serial Killer

Crime Files: Sins of a Serial Killer

147ds ago
0:58
Massacre in the Mansion

Massacre in the Mansion

160ds ago
1:39
'Blood & Betrayal: The Nathan Carman Case'

'Blood & Betrayal: The Nathan Carman Case'

174ds ago
1:35
'Blood & Providence: Shootout in Jersey City'

'Blood & Providence: Shootout in Jersey City'

181ds ago
0:50
Compulsion to Kill: The Charles Cullen Murders

Compulsion to Kill: The Charles Cullen Murders

195ds ago
1:26
Twisted Justice: The Josette Wright Story

Twisted Justice: The Josette Wright Story

202ds ago
Eleven bodies buried at a local beach. See how police say a pizza crust led to a break in an infamous cold case.
More Crime Files stories


More from News 12
1:58
Bay Shore High School employee put on administrative leave during Suffolk County police investigation

Bay Shore High School employee put on administrative leave during Suffolk County police investigation

2:26
Sweater weather with temps in the high 50s for Long Island; coastal storm chance next week

Sweater weather with temps in the high 50s for Long Island; coastal storm chance next week

0:25
7 arrested in raids at multiple cannabis businesses in Suffolk

7 arrested in raids at multiple cannabis businesses in Suffolk

0:24
4 people hurt, 2 seriously, in Great River crash

4 people hurt, 2 seriously, in Great River crash

1:39
Suffolk police officers, Central Islip firefighters rescue 2 women from house fire

Suffolk police officers, Central Islip firefighters rescue 2 women from house fire

2:25
1 person in critical condition, 2 seriously injured in Freeport apartment building fire  

1 person in critical condition, 2 seriously injured in Freeport apartment building fire  



Info

  • Newsletter
  • Send Photos/Videos
  • Contact
  • About Us
  • News Team
  • News 12 New York

Follow Us

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram

More Resources

  • Altice USA
  • Optimum
  • Advertise on News 12
  • Careers
  • Content Removal Policy

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Ad Choices
  • Privacy Manager

© 2025 N12N, LLC