Guide: Where to go pumpkin picking on Long Island

Looking to go pumpkin picking this fall season? Check out some of these locations on Long Island.

News 12 Staff

•

Oct 13, 2023, 8:30 AM

•

Updated 435 days ago

NASSAU COUNTY

Atlantic Nursery & Garden Shop

250 Atlantic Ave.
Freeport, NY 11520
(516) 378-7357
Website
Info: Located near the Nautical Mile, Atlantic Nursery & Garden Shop has been family-owned and operated since 1929 and boasts and a wide selection of pumpkins to pick.

Hicks Nurseries

100 Jericho Turnpike
Westbury, NY 11590
(516)-334-0066
Website
Info: After meeting Otto the Ghost, people can search Hicks’ large pumpkin patch for the perfect pumpkin.

The Dee’s Nursery & Florist

69 Atlantic Ave.
Oceanside, NY 11572
(516) 678-3535
Website
Info: The Oceanside nursery brings fall fun to Long Islanders and large pumpkin patches to look through.

SUFFOLK COUNTY

Albert H. Schmitt Family Farms

6 Bagatelle Road
Dix Hills, NY 11746
(631) 549-FARM
Website
Info: The 1-acre pumpkin pitch is packed with pumpkins from the farm’s patches in the back.

Andrew Family Farm and Greenhouse

1038 Sound Ave.
Wading River, NY 11792
(631) 929-5963
Website
Info: There are a variety of pumpkins at the 3-acres patch, which features pumpkins cut off the vine and trucked in from their other locations.

The BBGG Farm & Nursery

625 North Country Road
St. James, NY 11780
(631) 862-9182
Website
Info: There is 5-acres pumpkin patch full of pumpkins grown at the farm and nearby farms.

Benner’s Farm

56 Gnarled Hollow Road
Setauket, NY 11733
(631) 689-8172
Website
Info: People can look for their favorite gourds through the farm’s half acre plot of pumpkins.

Borella’s Farm Stand

485 Edgewood Ave.
St. James, NY 11780
(631) 862-7330
Website
Info: The farm has eight acres of pumpkins for Long Islanders to look through.

Brightwaters Farms

1624 Manatuck Blvd.
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 665-5411
Website
Info: Families can search for the perfect pumpkin at Brightwaters Farms.

Elwood Pumpkin Farm

1500 East Jericho Turnpike
Huntington, NY
(631) 368-8626
Website
Info: One of Suffolk County’s western most farms, Elwood Pumpkin Farm boasts 11-acres of white pumpkins, speckled swan gourds.

Fink’s Country Farm

6242 Middle Country Road
Wading River, NY 11792
(631) 886-2272
Website
Info: For over 50 years, Fink’s Country Farm has delivered fall fun to Long Islanders with their 3-acres U-Pick pumpkin fields and various seasonal activities.

Glover Farms

633 Victory Ave.
Brookhaven, NY 11719
(631) 286-7876
Website
Info: Long Islanders can pick the perfect pumpkin in Glover’s 15-acre U-Pick field.

Lenny Bruno Farms

740 Wading River Road
Manorville, NY 11949
(631) 591-3592
Website
Info: Lenny Bruno Farms boats 8-acres of pumpkins in their U-Pick farm.

Lewin Farms

812 Sound Ave.
Calverton, NY 11933
(631) 929-4327
Website
Info: Lewin Farms is currently in its fourth generation of providing Long Islanders acres of fresh produces, pumpkins and gourds. People can look for pumpkins in their 60-acre field.

May’s Farm Stand

6361 NY-25A
Wading River, NY 11792
(631) 929-6654
Website
Info: People can look for pumpkins in their acre and a half farm.

Niegocki Farms

604 Mount Sinai Coram Road
Mount Sinai, NY 11766
Website
Info: Niegocki Farms is a farm stand selling organically grown produce and pasture raised meats. Farm also offers educational programs for children.

Organics Today Farm

169 Washington St.
East Islip, NY 11730
(631) 480-6497
Website
Info: The quaint organic farm is known for their heirloom tomatoes and vegetables. During the fall, the Long Islanders look for pumpkins in their 3-acre fields.

Pantaleons Farm

445 NY-25A
East Setauket, NY 11733
(631) 608-8331
Website
Info: Local farm stand that offers the best quality in plants to decorate your home so that it can look spectacular.

Schmitt’s Farm

26 Pinelawn Road
Melville, NY 11747
(631) 271-3276
Website
Info: For over 50 years, Schmitt Farm’s hosts the annual fall festival every weekend leading up to Halloween. During the festivities, people can look through the large selection of pumpkin in their U-Pick patch.

Waterdrinker Family Farm & Garden

663 Wading River Road
Manorville, NY
(631) 878-8653
Website
Info: Not only does the farm offer seasonal activities, all year round it offers gardening help.

White Post Farms

250 Old Country Road
Melville, NY
(631) 351-9373
Website
Info: People can browse through White Post Farms’ large pumpkin patch for the perfect pumpkin.

Woodside Nursery and Garden Center

134 East Woodside Ave.
North Patchogue, NY 11772
(631) 758-1491
Website
Info: Long Islanders will find large and small pumpkins from the nursery’s five acre farm.

NORTH FORK

Gabrielsen’s Country Plant Farm

200 Herricks Lane
Jamesport, NY 11947
(631) 722-3259
Website
Info: The Jamesport farm’s Herricks Lane location boasts a 1 ½ acre pumpkin field, which features traditional and specialty pumpkins and gourds.

Harbes Family Farm

Multiple Locations
Website
Info: With three locations, including Riverhead, Mattituck and Jamesport, Harbes Family Farm has acres of farmland full of pumpkins and gourds.

Krupski’s Farm

38030 Route 25
Peconic, NY 11958
(631) 734-7841
Website
Info: Krupski’s Farm boasts more than 50 acres of farmland spanning three fields. Long Islanders can walk through their 1.5-acres U-Pick field.

Stakey’s Pumpkin Farm

270 West Lane
Aquebogue, NY 11931
(631) 722-3467
Website
Info: This East End farm has 26-acres of U-Pick pumpkins.

SOUTH FORK

Fairview Farm

19 Horsemill Lane
Bridgehampton, NY 11932
(631) 537-6154
Website
Info: The South Fork farm offers a variety of fruits and vegetables, but Long Islanders can browse the farm’s pumpkin patch for the perfect pumpkin.

Hank’s Pumpkintown

240 Montauk Highway
Water Mill, NY 11976
(631) 726-4667
Website
Info: Hank’s Pumpkin has over 420 acres of crops spread throughout its South Fork location and 48 of those acres are dedicated to pumpkins. From small to extra-large pumpkins on the vine, this farm will be the place to find the perfect pumpkin.

Seven Ponds Orchard

65 7 Ponds Road
Water Mill, NY 11976
(631) 726-8015
Website
Info: Besides being known for their apples, Seven Ponds Orchard offers a wide selection of pumpkin and season gourds.

The Milk Pail

50 Horsemill Lane
Water Mill, NY 11976
(631) 537-2565
Website
Info: There are more than 55 varieties of pumpkins and gourds are available. Other Activities: Marketplace, live entertainment

Did we miss one? Click here to let us know your favorite!