News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys
Sunny
61°
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys

New Mexico man arrested after firing shotgun at homes and cars in Butler

Local officers, supported by multiple K-9 units and drones, were deployed to surround the woods and secure the neighborhood.

Pedro Carmona

•

Nov 10, 2026, 8:09 AM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A New Mexico man is in custody and faces multiple weapons and property damage charges after allegedly firing eight shotgun rounds into parked vehicles and a home in Morris County early Sunday morning, sparking a multi-agency tactical search.

Garrett Brogan, 34, of Albuquerque, New Mexico, was taken into custody following a search through a wooded area near Washington Street in Butler, according to a joint statement from the Morris County prosecutor and Butler police.

Butler police responded to Washington Street around 2:51 a.m. on Sunday, Nov. 8, following reports of gunfire directed at local residences. Upon arrival, officers spotted the suspect fleeing into a nearby wooded area.

The Morris County Sheriff's Emergency Response Team and local officers, supported by multiple K-9 units and drones, were deployed to surround the woods and secure the neighborhood.

At approximately 4:40 a.m., tactical responders located Brogan in the woods and took him into custody without further incident. Investigators later recovered a shotgun and ammunition from the search area.

Investigators said Brogan had recently driven cross-country from New Mexico to New Jersey, staying at a hotel in Wayne before traveling to Butler.

Authorities allege that between Saturday night and early Sunday morning, Brogan drove to Washington Street and fired eight rounds, striking vehicles, including their windshields, and at least one home.

On Monday, Nov. 9, Brogan was formally charged with second-degree unlawful possession of a shotgun, third-degree criminal mischief and third-degree possession of a weapon for an unlawful purpose.

Top Stories

Screenshot 2026-11-10 1330075454

ICE detainer lodged against 16-year-old accused of bringing loaded handgun to Smithtown High School West

01:44
FM Temp 25k GFS

STORM WATCH: Rain and gusty winds Thursday into Friday with a developing nor'easter

00:28
wh

15-year-old West Hempstead student found with loaded gun in locker

HARBOR1

Vehicle crashes into Greenport Harbor Brewery in Peconic; driver airlifted to hospital

00:58
LIwishchildkk_2026-11-10-12-39-00

'I'm Pinocchio!' West Islip wish child with rare disorder meets his favorite character

Airplane and airlines

Breeze Airways discounts base airfares for its annual Kindness Week

00:21
LItopgolfpriceskk_2026-11-10-12-39-16

Topgolf cutting prices in response to customer feedback over high cost

00:40
BAGEL1

Plainview bagel shop offering Veteran's Day freebie

00:27
CASSELFIRE1

4 people displaced after New Cassel house fire

00:36
LIshorttermrentalskk_2026-11-10-12-38-13

Southold considers slashing Airbnb-style rentals by 80%

00:27
LILINDYHITRUN1110_2026-11-10-05-02-59

Woman arrested for hitting pedestrian, leaving the scene in North Lindenhurst

01:02
ce72a972-e171-4ec8-8a63-a6c1ae81b689

Hot Toys: Character craze toy guide from KPop Demon Hunters to Paw Patrol and more

00:21
LIMASTICSTABBING1110_2026-11-10-05-06-42

Man stabbed during dispute at Mastic group home

01:25
99e7c9da-303e-4a6c-81a6-2cc1d67bf48b

Veterans to receive 3.6% benefit increase under new cost-of-living adjustment

01:35
bbef86ce-2cff-4734-b3c6-42e46f3cdbdd

After insurance coverage lapse, Freeport senior faces $1,000 monthly premium. Here's how drivers can avoid the same problem

00:18
SINKING VESSEL

Father, son rescued from sinking vessel near Moriches Inlet

02:00
li10pmboljeremyskiba_2026-11-09-22-13-28

East Northport neighbors say rat infestation is tearing up yards, raising concerns

01:53
li10pmboldaniella_2026-11-09-22-13-56

New York state universities awarded grant funding to combat campus sexual violence

01:39
LIinwoodthreatkk_2026-11-09-17-08-21

Inwood man accused of hurling antisemitic remarks at grocery store customers

01:46
li5pmbol2026logandwi_2026-11-09-17-29-23

Faces of tragedy: New Suffolk trailer puts victims of impaired and distracted driving front and center

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices