News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys
Clear
38°
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys

Made on Long Island: Uncle Jeff’s Pecan Pies and More LLC in Amityville

While he usually works alone in the kitchen, Church says baking is a job he truly loves, especially knowing his pies will bring people together around the dinner table.

Jenn Seelig

•

Nov 16, 2026, 5:39 AM

•

Updated

Share:

A retired FDNY emergency medical technician is turning a longtime passion for baking into a sweet success story on Long Island.

Jeff Church, owner of Uncle Jeff’s Pecan Pies and More LLC, has been making homemade pies since 2004. What started as a hobby eventually grew into a business, with Church first sharing his creations with fellow firefighters at the firehouse. After retiring from the FDNY, Church took his love of baking to the next level, building a business out of his Amityville kitchen.

Today, he makes a variety of homemade pies, including traditional pecan, chocolate pecan, apple, blueberry and cherry. His pies come in different sizes and can be shipped anywhere in the country. He’s even sent one across the pond to England.

Church says his recipes are made without preservatives or artificial ingredients, with each pie handcrafted from start to finish.

November is typically his busiest month as customers prepare for Thanksgiving and the holiday season. While he usually works alone in the kitchen, Church says baking is a job he truly loves, especially knowing his pies will bring people together around the dinner table.

Top Stories

01:17
LIPATRICIASFIRE111626_2026-11-16-05-33-38

Fire rips through Patrizia’s in Massapequa Park, damages neighboring Bagel Boss

02:49
F P2 PM 1

Sunny and cool Monday for Long Island before mid-November warmup

01:48
turkey1

The Cost Of: Thanksgiving turkey, ham and drinks

01:26
pecanpie1

Made on Long Island: Uncle Jeff’s Pecan Pies and More LLC in Amityville

00:30
RTLIMassapequaHouseFire11152026VO10pm_2026-11-15-22-10-41

Box truck catches fire before flames before spread to Massapequa home

00:29
LIASSAULTARREST1116_2026-11-16-05-14-34

Target employee, 2 officers hurt following alleged assault, larceny in Valley Stream

00:24
american legion

Man turns himself in after hitting Southold American Legion, fleeing

APGroundStop11142026At10pmSG001

LIVE UPDATES: Trump administration asks for billions to overhaul FAA. Democrats question how money was spent

01:23
li12pmbolhicksvilleshooting_2026-11-15-12-12-33

Yonkers man charged after accidentally shooting and killing his brother in Hicksville, prosecutors say

01:07
li5pmbolpizzeriafiremp_2026-11-15-17-06-55

Fire damages Massapequa Park restaurant, neighboring businesses

00:50
LIworkerstillmissingkk_2026-11-15-13-44-39

Search for missing worker continues days after deadly scaffolding collapse in Point Lookout

00:39
LIriverheadmvakk_2026-11-15-09-02-10

Shirley man killed after head-on crash causes multi-vehicle wreck in Riverhead

00:20
dirt bike

17-year-old dirt bike rider seriously injured after crashing into parked vehicle in Selden

00:50
li12pmboutique_2026-11-15-12-30-01

Long Beach school district hosts free boutique event for families in need

02:03
li5pmboljskibamca_2026-11-14-17-10-35

MacArthur Airport travelers scramble after nationwide ground stop disrupts flights

01:43
RTLIPlainviewRats11142026JRGaertner10pm_2026-11-14-22-21-52

‘I have the heebie jeebies.’ Plainview residents report growing rat infestation in neighborhood

00:18
li5pmbolbaldwinshootingvo_2026-11-15-12-17-37

Baldwin shooting leaves 25-year-old man critically injured

01:07
RTLILightForACureJRGaertnerVOSOT10pm_2026-11-14-22-22-29

Deer Park family uses holiday light display to raise money for Type 1 diabetes research

00:48
li12pmbolturtle_2026-11-14-12-18-32

Push to protect turtles crossing Smithtown Boulevard

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices