News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys
Sunny
50°
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys

Court records: Man accused of breaking into parents' home before deadly fire

Police say five officers were hospitalized for smoke inhalation after attempting to rescue the animals from the burning home.

Jeremy Skiba

•

Oct 4, 2026, 12:19 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A Brooklyn man is accused of breaking into his parents' Central Islip home, setting it on fire and killing two dogs that were trapped inside, according to Suffolk County police and court documents.

Authorities identified the suspect as 39-year-old Alston of Brooklyn.

According to court documents, Alston broke into the home through a kitchen window before allegedly setting the fire. No one else was inside the house at the time, investigators said.

Police say officers responded to a 911 call reporting a fire at a home on East Cherry Street in Central Islip at approximately 12:20 a.m. Saturday. When officers arrived, they tried to enter the home to rescue two dogs inside but were unsuccessful.

The Central Islip Fire Department, along with several neighboring fire departments, extinguished the blaze. Once the fire was brought under control, firefighters found the two dogs dead inside the home.

Investigators said five police officers suffered smoke inhalation while responding to the fire and were taken to the hospital.

Neighbors said the large emergency response woke them from their sleep.

"The ambulances and police cars were going off for a good solid five minutes. I checked outside to see what was going on and there was a fire down the street at the house. It was really unexpected," said Ozil Acosta of Central Islip.

Acosta said he frequently saw the dogs at the home and was shocked by what happened.

"I would see the dogs all the time. They would bark at me too. When I saw the dog get carried out, it was really shocking to me," he said.

Other neighbors expressed disbelief after learning investigators accused the homeowners' son of starting the fire.

"Wow, the son? Wow, that's hard. That's a family member, that's crazy," said Nelson Espinal of Central Islip.

"It's tragic and I feel bad for them," said Denilson Acosta.

Acosta added, "That's messed up and awful at the same time. Your own son would try to rob you and burn down the place. It's not really acceptable."

Residents said the allegations came as a surprise in their generally quiet neighborhood.

"It honestly does surprise me. Everyone here is nice and quiet. Nothing much happens here. Everyone gets along with each other," Acosta said.

Following an investigation by Suffolk County Arson Squad detectives, Alston was charged with arson, burglary and false personation, which authorities described as giving police a false name.

Alston was arraigned Saturday at First District Court in Central Islip, where he pleaded not guilty. His next court date is scheduled for Oct. 8.

Top Stories

00:18
MAP

Police investigating after woman bleeding from neck flags down officers in Uniondale

02:31
FC1

STORM WATCH: Dry today before stormy weather arrives Thursday

00:29
1111liecrash_2026-11-11-08-00-02

Driver critically injured in two-vehicle Long Island Expressway crash

01:26
1111knifeinbackpack730_2026-11-11-07-33-53

Teen arrested after switchblade found in bag at Elmont Memorial High School

Article 243275 Thumbnail

From free meals to free haircuts! Here are some popular Veterans Day deals and discounts

00:22
LIJCCSWASTIKA1111_2026-11-11-05-06-30

Police arrest man for allegedly drawing swastika on Jewish center door

00:21
pizza

Merrick pizzeria opens 2nd location down south

00:43
11112026WCai_2026-11-11-06-26-15

New York launches first-in-the-nation AI research institute to test powerful systems

00:18
LIBREEZEFLIGHTS1111_2026-11-11-05-47-04

Breeze Airways discounts base airfares for its annual Kindness Week

01:15
1111whatscooking_2026-11-11-08-13-00

What’s Cooking: Pumpkin ravioli with autumn sauce

01:24
1111jennveterans_2026-11-11-05-20-29

One volunteer's mission to make sure local veterans are never forgotten

00:32
111measles1_2026-11-11-05-18-35

United States on brink of losing measles elimination status

01:24
Alex plants

November gardening: When to prune, what to plant and why you should leave the leaves

02:00
LIstolenvalorkk_2026-11-10-17-15-19_17-04-04,29

DA: Self-proclaimed war hero from Hampton Bays made up military service, stole more than $80K from American Legion

01:42
li10pmboldznillaracist_2026-11-10-22-05-51

Union demands accountability after Riverhead school district employees allege racism, retaliation

00:36
li10pmboljeremyhuntingtonpolice_2026-11-10-22-06-10

Police activity in Huntington Station leaves neighbors searching for answers

00:48
Screenshot 2026-11-10 1837126465345

Juleigh Chin declares victory in Nassau Legislature District 9 race

Missing Voices

Homeless Youth in Crisis: The Missing Voices

00:30
Screenshot 2026-11-10 1330075454

ICE detainer lodged against 16-year-old accused of bringing loaded handgun to Smithtown High School West

00:30
LIcolcasescrackedkk_2026-11-10-17-13-30

'Montauk Mary,' found slain in 1978, among unidentified cold case victims to be named

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices