News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Vote 2026: Long Island elections
Mostly Cloudy
75°
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Vote 2026: Long Island elections

Frantoni’s Woodbury location to close as community rallies behind beloved pizzeria

Supporters flood local restaurant after owners cite rising costs, while hopes remain for a future return.

Jenna Rae Gaertner

•

Oct 2, 2026, 6:18 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A beloved Woodbury pizzeria is preparing to close its doors this weekend, but an outpouring of community support is giving the owners hope for the future.

Frantoni’s, founded in 1988 in Williston Park, has operated its Woodbury location for the past seven years. Owners say increasing expenses, including insurance, produce and rent costs, have made it impossible to sustain the business at the location.

Since announcing the closure, customers have shown up in large numbers to support the restaurant, which many describe as a staple of the neighborhood not only for its food but also for its involvement in the community.

Among those supporters is 11-year-old Asher Goodman, who has been visiting Frantoni’s since kindergarten. Goodman recently launched an Instagram page called Save Frantoni’s in an effort to support the business.

“It has amazing pizza first of all. And every time I come here, I make a new memory. A new milestone,” Goodman said.

For co-owner Anthony Suppa, the community response has been deeply meaningful during a difficult time.

“It’s heartbreaking for us. It’s our income. The community though, what they’re doing and how they came out is literally life saving for me because it just makes me know that they appreciated everything that we did and everything that we tried to do. And for them to appreciate that is unbelievable,” Suppa said.

Sunday will be the final day of operations at the Woodbury location. However, the owners say they have not ruled out the possibility of reopening in the future.

In the meantime, customers are encouraged to visit Frantoni’s locations in Williston Park and East Meadow as supporters continue to stand behind the longtime local business.

Top Stories

01:27
Skeletal Remains MS 100226_2026-10-02-17-05-21

Skeletal remains found in Manhasset park believed to be missing person

02:00
Headlines - Evening (10)

Showers tonight usher in cooler weather for the weekend

01:57
li5pmboljennapizzaplace_2026-10-02-18-16-40_17-08-07,06

Frantoni’s Woodbury location to close as community rallies behind beloved pizzeria

01:48
SH Fire MS 100226_2026-10-02-17-08-21

Southampton fire under investigation at home tied to recent burglary and marijuana seizure

00:52
CoxVeteran

Health aide pleads guilty to endangering welfare of disabled vet at state-run facility

00:28
flockcameracrackdownbillCM_2026-10-02-16-45-15

New bill seeks to ban federal use of Flock license plate readers

LI 10PM THURS_Weekend Events Storm_ajc_2026-09-24-22-11-15_22-08-51,06

Jones Beach IRONMAN rescheduled following cancellation due to nor'easter

00:13
lietruckfireclosure12pm_2026-10-02-12-36-02

Vehicle fire on LIE temporarily closes all eastbound lanes

00:20
car wash rescue

Man gets leg stuck in roller at East Islip car wash

00:18
bicycle stolen

Police search for man who stole customer’s bike from Centereach Walmart

02:02
LIBarabbi102_2026-10-02-05-49-23

VOTE 2026: Nassau Legislature's 9th District race could play pivotal role in battle for majority

00:40
LIFarmingdale102_2026-10-02-09-16-58

All-abilities drumline proves music is for everybody

02:36
Image (8)

RISE of the Jack O'Lanterns returns to Melville this weekend

01:41
IMG 1507

Islanders home opener brings new season, new eats and giving back

02:18
Image (6)

Car Show Long Island happening Saturday at Tobay Beach

00:28
LI 10pm_Creepy Guy_ajc_2026-10-01-22-04-00

Man seen 'behaving inappropriately' outside of elementary school in Oyster Bay

01:58
ap cornell

New York's governor removes DA in Cornell rape allegations, appoints AG Letitia James to take over

01:35
LI 10pm_CI LIRR Crossing_ajc_2026-10-01-22-07-22

Central Islip residents press for more rail crossing fixes despite MTA's planned eliminations

01:36
LI 10pm_HHM Hempstead_ajc_2026-10-01-22-19-45

Village of Hempstead celebrates Hispanic Heritage Month, honors community leaders

01:49
101wantaghdecision_2026-10-01-13-00-13

Appeals court backs NY mascot ban, but Wantagh fight continues

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices