News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Vote 2026: Long Island elections
66°
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Vote 2026: Long Island elections

Beloved Cinema Arts Centre director fired, sparking community backlash

The board has not provided details, saying only in a letter to the community that there was "serious misconduct."

Jenna Rae Gaertner

•

Sep 4, 2026, 10:25 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

The Cinema Arts Centre, a cornerstone of the Huntington community for more than 50 years, is facing growing backlash after the firing of Dylan Skolnick, the son of the theater's founder and its longtime co-director.

Community members, film historians and longtime patrons have voiced concerns over the decision, with many demanding more information from the organization's board.

"Cinema Arts Centre has been a really big part of my life, and a lot of people's lives here in Huntington for a long time, and it's just a shame that it has to come down to this," said Wallace Matthews.

In a letter to the community, the Cinema Arts Centre's board said, "the Centre parted ways with Mr. Skolnick after discovering and communicating to him what it believed to be, and continues to believe was, serious misconduct."

However, the board has not publicly provided additional details regarding the allegations.

The lack of explanation has frustrated many members of the film community.

Film historian Foster Hirsch criticized the board's handling of the situation.

"I think it sets a terrifying, chilling precedent to fire somebody like this and say, 'Oh, we can't tell you why.,'" Hirsch said. "What sort of a precedent does that set? You can say anything about anybody. Defame character. Destroy career. Oh, but I can't speak."

David Schwartz, a film programmer and writer who has attended the Cinema Arts Centre since the 1970s and known Skolnick for most of his life, also questioned the board's explanation.

"When you use the phrase 'serious misconduct,' that implies something really bad... and nothing like that is being asserted from what I know," Schwartz said. "I think people need a better explanation for what happened, but from what I've seen, there is no good explanation. And Dylan is irreplaceable."

Despite the controversy, the theater remained busy Friday night. Still, several longtime members and film presenters told News 12 they are boycotting the center until the matter is resolved.

Hirsch said he plans to stay away from the theater unless Skolnick returns, even forgoing events he has on the caldendar. Schwartz, who has been programming the Jewish Film Festival for the past four years, added he won't bring the event back to the CAC unless the issue is resolved. Other patrons are following suit.

The Cinema Arts Centre has not released additional information regarding the circumstances surrounding Skolnick's termination. Community members continue to call for greater transparency from the organization's leadership. A petition has been circulating to reinstate Dylan Skolnick and has collected more than 800 signatures so far.

Top Stories

01:23
LI 5PM TUES_Port Jeff Animal Investigation_ajc_2026-09-29-17-13-40

Three people arrested for allegedly neglecting 13 animals in Port Jefferson

02:12
F P1 PM 1

Dry evening across Long Island; patchy fog possible overnight

01:18
Water Damage MS 092926_2026-09-29-17-07-43

LI restaurant flooded by nor'easter to reopen Wednesday following 3.5 feet of water damage

01:46
li5pmbolcecilihitherhills_2026-09-29-17-26-58

Hither Hills takes a serious hit from weekend nor'easter

01:45
Bettys Burgers Daylight

Nor'easter shuts down Merrick burger restaurant less than 2 months after it opened

01:23
LI 5PM TUES_Port Jeff Animal Investigation_ajc_2026-09-29-17-13-40

Three people arrested for allegedly neglecting 13 animals in Port Jefferson

00:17
ESCOOTER

Teen on e-scooter seriously hurt in crash with garbage truck in Hicksville

00:21
AP26259698495198

Aaron Judge left off Yankees' Wild Card Series roster vs Red Sox with calf injury

00:19
sleight of hand

Women wanted for sleight-of-hand scam at Selden business

AC/DC and Foo Fighters

For those about to rock: Foo Fighters to join AC/DC at MetLife show

AP26269729156337

Senate passes college sports bill that would rein in athlete payments and transfers

01:44
LITaxig929_2026-09-29-06-49-25

Taxing Long Island: How storms can take a toll on your car and wallet

WCHV17thCongressionalDistrictDebate

Rep. Mike Lawler, Cait Conley go head to head in News 12 debate as they vie for NY-17

Vote 2026

Voter Guide 2026: Long Island election voting guide

01:12
9292026WChaunted_2026-09-29-06-21-31

Is this haunted theater's scariest show happening after the curtain falls?

00:22
DUTCH

Hofstra University introduces first collegiate ‘Puppy with a Purpose’

01:47
li10pmboljeremyskibabeach_2026-09-28-22-07-56

Nor’easter causes erosion, closures and flood damage at Long Island state parks

00:52
li10pmbolkarinahospitalityball_2026-09-28-22-28-30

Long Island charity event raises money for people impacted by cancer

02:14
li5pmbolkevinvbeacherosion_2026-09-28-17-09-53

Nor’easter ravages Long Island beaches, leaving severe erosion in its wake

00:26
Arrest Made Generic

Dentist from Hicksville arrested, accused of stealing over $300,000 from Medicaid 

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices