News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Vote 2026: Long Island elections
Fair or Mostly Clear
55°
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Vote 2026: Long Island elections

Tax payment checks stolen from Centereach Post Office

Town of Brookhaven Tax Receiver’s office is investigating how many people were affected.

Jenna Rae Gaertner

•

Jun 4, 2026, 10:13 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Some tax payment checks in the town of Brookhaven were stolen and cashed.

It’s a process called check washing. Someone intercepts a check, changes the information on it and cashes it without the sender even knowing.

“I think it's very concerning,” said Patrick Waryold, of Centereach. “You hear about check washing all the time. That's why I do everything online.”

It happened to a Brookhaven resident in January. Town Supervisor Dan Panico says the check was due at the receiver of taxes office, but a few days ago, the tax office said it never arrived.

Panico says he found out there was a break in at the Centereach post office back in January. That’s when he says checks were stolen that were intended for the tax receiver.

“I don't understand why the security is not enough that something like that couldn't happen at the post office,” said one Centereach resident.

Panico doesn't know how many checks were stolen. He said the one he saw that was "washed" had the name whited out and replaced.

There have also been reports of fake phone calls saying residents have outstanding tax balances. Panico says the tax office does not contact people for payments over the phone.

“A new scam is born every day, unfortunately, in the society in which we live,” Panico said. “So you have to be vigilant.”

If you sent a tax payment in January through the Centereach post office, check to see if it was received.

Top Stories

01:41
LIbarricadedkk_2026-11-02-17-08-50

Police respond to barricaded situation at Farmingville apartment complex

01:54
Headlines - Evening (11)

Warm, dry conditions ahead for Long Island before rain chances return late week

00:29
Screenshot 2026-11-02 171838

BLOG: Person injured in police-involved shooting in Fordham, sources say

Vote 2026

Voter Guide 2026: Long Island election voting guide

01:33
Crash Sentencing MS 110226_2026-11-02-17-06-45

Lindenhurst man sentenced in fatal DWI crash that killed man in Freeport

01:12
Car Thefts MS 110226_2026-11-02-17-07-26

Car theft, attempted thefts and break-ins raise concerns among Massapequa residents

01:46
5PMCeciliatributeusethisonekk_2026-11-02-18-34-57

'We don't want to forget our guys.' Retired police officer paints stones to be placed at graves of first responders

00:54
li5pmbolislanderschildsupport_2026-11-02-17-41-42

Islander player cuts ribbon on hospital support room in honor of late mother

01:51
MP Lewd Act

Police release surveillance video as they continue searching for man accused of exposing himself to 3 girls in Massapequa Park

00:15
LI MORN SHOW MON_Car Theft_ajc_2026-11-02-05-38-23

Police search for 2 men accused of stealing car in Nesconset

00:39
wagyuburger

Sample the best of Long Island's eats during Restaurant Week

01:52
Blakeman 9

Hochul, Blakeman set for governor's race after years of public clashes

00:30
LInewsrideskk_2026-11-02-12-36-17

Adventureland gearing up for 65th anniversary next year with new rides

02:28
electiondy

Former Nassau, Suffolk officials on polls, 'the blue wave' and more

01:14
LIfield112_2026-11-02-07-54-38

Suffolk County clerk race gains attention as write-in campaign picks up momentum

FSA Once Upon a Farm Image 5

FDA: Once Upon a Farm toddler bars linked to serious choking hazard

00:35
Jerry Larsen

East Hampton mayor backed by write-in campaign for Town Supervisor race

00:10
LI MORN SHOW MON_Auto Shop Fire_ajc_2026-11-02-05-38-56

Fire damages auto body shop in North Patchogue

00:24
LI MORN SHOW MON_Jericho Stabbing_ajc_2026-11-02-05-37-55

Taxi driver accused of stabbing passenger in chest, abdomen over fare in Jericho

01:45
RTLIWeekendPartiesBustedJRGeartner10pm_2026-11-01-22-20-11

Police break up multiple underage Halloween parties, resulting in arrests and hospitalizations

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices